What's new

Bacha khan's grand daughter is an Indian

Any picture of the grand daughter?

Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan and his granddaughter Zarina Khan in Bandra, Bombay, in 1969.

upload_2020-5-16_10-51-46.png
 
.
Pakistani parroting Hindu Mahasabha line.
4

There are Gandhi's love letters to Kallenbach and testimonials that prove so.You cant just erase this part of hsitory.


Why would i as a Pakistani be " parroting Hindu Maahsabha line".Im absolutely neutral towards you and your counterparts..
 
Last edited:
.
4

There are Gandhi's love letters to Kallenbach and testimonials that prove so.You cant just erase this part of hsitory.


Why would i as a Pakistani be " parrot Hindtingu Maahsabha line".Im absolutely neutral towards you and your counterparts..

Because both Indian Muslim League and Hindu Mahasabha were created by the British. Both have the same goal of dividing people of the subcontinent on religious lines to further the interests of the British.
 
.
Wow, didn't know this. But I remember Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan being mentioned in our history books as the 'Frontier Gandhi'. Need to read up on him in detail.

Just checked up on his Wikipedia page, he passed away at the age of 98 in 1988!
 
.
Absolutely. Any Pushtun living in Pakistan/Afghanistan should be given citizenship of India if they opt to immigrate to India.

Good on Mods for giving you a much deserved negative rating, I think you need more.

First work to keep citizenship of Indian Muslims, and prevent abuse of their religious rights.

You cannot handle Pukhtoons or Baloch. Go back to your daydream.


What is this? Hindu radical version of Khaksar Tehreek?
 
.
Pakistan is not india

I do not want India to be Pakistan either.

Good on Mods for giving you a much deserved negative rating, I think you need more.

Why? What did I say wrong?

First work to keep citizenship of Indian Muslims, and prevent abuse of their religious rights.

Of course I will. You can bet.

You cannot handle Pukhtoons or Baloch. Go back to your daydream.

It is not a dream but India's responsibility.
 
. .
The purpose of NRC is to maintain a national record of all citizens of India. It is very much desirable. The proposed bill is still not an act but the act should have a future cutoff date (for example :01-APR-2021) for requiring any Date of Birth documentation and grant automatic citizenship with NO documentation to all people who have already been living in India.

Admirable. But you should understand (and I am sure you do) that the sole intention of the proposed NRC is to disenfranchise Muslims and reduce them to a stateless minority (like what Burma did to the Rohingya). The NRC will never be implemented if this desired goal cannot be done.
 
. . .
Admirable. But you should understand (and I am sure you do) that the sole intention of the proposed NRC is to disenfranchise Muslims and reduce them to a stateless minority (like what Burma did to the Rohingya). The NRC will never be implemented if this desired goal cannot be done.

All most all countries maintain their citizenship records except India. NRC would help in delivering social security benefits and security of the citizens. Hopefully this debate will result in everyone registering their Births, Marriages and Deaths going forward.
 
.
All most all countries maintain their citizenship records except India. NRC would help in delivering social security benefits and security of the citizens. Hopefully this debate will result in everyone registering their Births, Marriages and Deaths going forward.

Not one Pukhtoon accepts your offer, now shoo.

We are discussing other matters here.
 
. .
All most all countries maintain their citizenship records except India. NRC would help in delivering social security benefits and security of the citizens. Hopefully this debate will result in everyone registering their Births, Marriages and Deaths going forward.

Disagree. There is no citizenship record in the US. No one has to submit to a special citizenship test. Documents issued by various authorities form the basis of your citizenship (birth/naturalization).

The same situation exists in India as well at the present. Documents issued by various authorities form the basis of your citizenship. Why does another government entity need to be involved to check the documents issued by other government entities and bless them? So much for minimalist governance.
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom