What's new

Bacha khan's grand daughter is an Indian

Because both Indian Muslim League and Hindu Mahasabha were created by the British. Both have the same goal of dividing people of the subcontinent on religious lines to further the interests of the British.

lol
everything you dont like is British..Nice self-delusion.

People of the subcontinent were always divided..We are not the same people.
 
.
What commonality you have with Pukhtoon or Baloch?

May as well unite Kurdistan and Armenia with India... lol

Differences and Commonalities are relative.

Do Punjabhis have commonality with Sindhis, Baloch or Pushtuns?

It is all about seeing half glass full or half glass empty.

But anyway I do not want to digress.

My point has nothing to do with commonality or differences but India's responsibility towards them.

Have you been in Pakistan to make that comment. Because I have travelled extensively in northern indian

Which comment?
 
.
Do you know that Sir Syed Ahmed Khan was a Freemason?

http://www.lodge-prudentia.org/eminent_freemasons.html

So, many leaders flirted with various organizations. Djamaluddin Al Afghani, Muhammad Abduh, and Atatürk were Masons too, once upon a time.

It means nothing unless you climb higher into their order.

Differences and Commonalities are relative.

Do Punjabhis have commonality with Sindhis, Baloch or Pushtuns?

It is all about seeing half glass full or half glass empty.

But anyway I do not want to digress.

My point has nothing to do with commonality or differences but India's responsibility towards them.



Which comment?

Yes, we are all related and our language, cultures, and social mores are inter-related. This is why our people supported Pakistan in overwhelming majorities, even in Kashmir which you occupied illegally.

You cannot say the same for Indians.

My point has nothing to do with commonality or differences but India's responsibility towards them.

Take Rohingya, why do you not want them?

India has no responsibility to them? They are related to you by blood and ethnicity.
 
. . .
Differences and Commonalities are relative.

Let me break it down for you.
Indian Hindus will lynch and assault Indian Muslims who often share the same language, culture and ethnicity. How will they deal with non-Indian Muslims who don't share any of those characteristics?

Do Punjabhis have commonality with Sindhis, Baloch or Pushtuns?

Yes lmao.
 
.
Disagree. There is no citizenship record in the US. No one has to submit to a special citizenship test. Documents issued by various authorities form the basis of your citizenship (birth/naturalization).

The same situation exists in India as well at the present. Documents issued by various authorities form the basis of your citizenship. Why does another government entity need to be involved to check the documents issued by other government entities and bless them? So much for minimalist governance.

How does US know that there are undocumented aliens in the country?

Comparing US or EU with India is not valid. Many people in the developed countries are well documented while there is hardly any documentation in India.

The same situation exists in India as well at the present. Documents issued by various authorities form the basis of your citizenship. Why does another government entity need to be involved to check the documents issued by other government entities and bless them? So much for minimalist governance.

Many people do not have ration cards or DOB certificates. I am totally against asking for documents from the people who are already born and living but it should be made mandatory going forward for all new births.
 
.
How does US know that there are undocumented aliens in the country?

Comparing US or EU with India is not valid. Many people in the developed countries are well documented while there is hardly any documentation in India.

Your statement above highlights the issue. When there is hardly any documentation in India, how would one prove his citizenship, when the onus is on him/her to prove such.

I will disregard your comment on illegal immigrants in US. They do not have access to documents that prove their citizenship.

Many people do not have ration cards or DOB certificates. I am totally against asking for documents from the people who are already born and living but it should be made mandatory going forward for all new births.

Again that is admirable and that is how it should be.
 
.
Again that is admirable and that is how it should be.

Every Indian Hindu on this forum present themselves as Robinhood, you would think they are robbing BJP and helping Indian Muslims survive.

Yet vast majority of Indian Hindus are firmly behind BJP, what does that tell us?

False promises mean nothing. Anyone can sell snake oil.
 
.
Yes, we are all related and our language, cultures, and social mores are inter-related. This is why our people supported Pakistan in overwhelming majorities, even in Kashmir which you occupied illegally.

You cannot say the same for Indians.

Kashmiri is spoken only in the valley not in AJK or GB. A person from Jammu can speak better Kashmiri than someone from GB.

A Sindhi in Indian Gujarat is much close to people of Sindh, culturally, than a person from Rawalpindi.

See its not that simple.


upload_2020-5-16_12-24-19.png
 
.
Kashmiri is spoken only in the valley not in AJK or GB. A person from Jammu can speak better Kashmiri than someone from GB.

A Sindhi in Indian Gujarat is much close to people of Sindh, culturally, than a person from Rawalpindi.

See its not that simple.


View attachment 632990

Who made that false map? Lol.

Low level trolling from you.
 
.
Every Indian Hindu on this forum present themselves as Robinhood, you would think they are robbing BJP and helping Indian Muslims survive.

Yet vast majority of Indian Hindus are firmly behind BJP, what does that tell us?

False promises mean nothing. Anyone can sell snake oil.

LoL

Vast majority of Hindus did not vote for BJP. It got 38% of the votes in total during the last elections.

Considering Hindus are make up 80% of the total population, they got less than 50% of Hindu votes.

Who made that false map? Lol.

Low level trolling from you.

LoL . The map is from Kashmir Study Group. Here is the link.

http://kashmirstudygroup.com/awayforward/mapsexplan/languages.html


In New York, Imran Khan meets with Kashmir Study Group

In New York, Imran Khan meets with Kashmir Study Group
New York, Sep 22 (IANS) As part of his ''Mission Kashmir'' to draw global attention on the issue, Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan has urged the Kashmir Study Group to highlight the situation in Jammu and Kashmir, which he said "poses a grave threat to regional peace and security".

Khan met with the founder of Kashmir Study Group, Farooq Kathwari, who called on him in New York and both discussed the prevailing situation in J&K.

During the meeting, Pakistan Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi, Special Assistant to the PM Naeem ul Haq, UN Ambassador Maleeha Lodhi, Ambassador to the United States Asad Majeed Khan and other senior officials were also present.

Khan urged Kathwari to outline the issue of India''s revocation of special status of Jammu and Kashmir, which Pakistan has termed as "illegal annexation", and the alleged human rights violations there, in order to "expose the real face of fascist Modi-led Hindu nationalist government in front of the world".

Kathwari had earlier served as member of the US President''s Advisory Commission on Asian Americans.

Kathwari highlighted the Kashmir Study Group''s earlier engagement on the Jammu and Kashmir issue and efforts for conflict resolution.

Khan is here on a week-long visit to attend the UN General Assembly session and hold high-level meetings with world leaders.

According to Lodhi, upon his arrival here Khan has begun "mission Kashmir for Pakistan" with full zeal in order to draw the world''s attention towards the Kashmir issue.

"This is mission Kashmir for the prime minister and for Pakistan his message will be clear: the occupation must end, and a peaceful solution found for the Kashmir dispute. He will highlight the plight of the Kashmiri people who continue to suffer a suffocating lockdown and a brutal occupation," said Lodhi said, adding the Prime Minister would meet world leaders and the UN secretary general.

This is the Prime Minister''s first General Assembly visit and "he will be the voice of the Kashmiri people at the UN," she said.

Earlier, Foreign Minister Qureshi told reporters that Khan wanted to listen to Kashmiris from both parts of Kashmir ahead of his speech to the UN General Assembly on September 27

Qureshi said the main objective of Imran''s visit to US was to highlight alleged Indian atrocities in the valley.

Speaking to the media in New York, Qureshi said Imran will hold meetings with heads of different states and a Kashmiri delegation.

The Kashmir Study Group (kashmirstudygroup.org), consisting of 25 members with political, diplomatic and academic backgrounds, who extensively interact with the parties to the Kashmir issue. Established in 1996, KSG is headquartered in Larchmont, New York.

The Kashmir Study Group (KSG) works with the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Washington on Kashmir.

--IANS

rn/kr

https://www.outlookindia.com/newssc...n-khan-meets-with-kashmir-study-group/1624550
 
. .
Where did I talk about armies or any war? You still seems to not understand my point.

This is about keeping our part of the promise. Who and how many people will avail that offer and immigrate to India is the prerogative of the Pushtuns and Pushtuns only.



I have already stated my position on some thread earlier. CAA and NRC would be great acts with some minor modifications.

The purpose of CAA is to grant citizenship to non-Indian citizens who are already living in India. The current act needs to be modified to have NO reference to religion.

The purpose of NRC is to maintain a national record of all citizens of India. It is very much desirable. The proposed bill is still not an act but the act should have a future cutoff date (for example :01-APR-2021) for requiring any Date of Birth documentation and grant automatic citizenship with NO documentation to all people who have already been living in India.



I would be happy to do that.



And that is my point. Frontier Gandhi was pro United India just like Gandhi but unfortunately we could not help him and his followers due to partition. Better late than never. Hence India should help them now and keep our side of the bargain. We should provide citizenship of India to any Pushtuns who wants to immigrate and become citizens of India.



Where? In India or Pakistan?



Pakistani parroting Hindu Mahasabha line. Am I surprised? Not at all. Please continue. It reflects on your upbringing.

Birds of same feather flock together.

Stop wasting our time and convince your Afghan brothers and sisters to migrate to Hindustan. Afghans keep coming in record numbers to Pakistan. Frankly we don’t want them here in Pakistan. RSS Indians and Afghans deserve each other. Both of you have a lot in common.

Every Indian Hindu on this forum present themselves as Robinhood, you would think they are robbing BJP and helping Indian Muslims survive.

Yet vast majority of Indian Hindus are firmly behind BJP, what does that tell us?

False promises mean nothing. Anyone can sell snake oil.

LOL these Indians keep raping and lynching Indian Muslims. Here they are pretending to be the saviors of Afghans.
 
.
LoL

Vast majority of Hindus did not vote for BJP. It got 38% of the votes in total during the last elections.

Considering Hindus are make up 80% of the total population, they got less than 50% of Hindu votes.



LoL . The map is from Kashmir Study Group. Here is the link.

http://kashmirstudygroup.com/awayforward/mapsexplan/languages.html


In New York, Imran Khan meets with Kashmir Study Group

In New York, Imran Khan meets with Kashmir Study Group
New York, Sep 22 (IANS) As part of his ''Mission Kashmir'' to draw global attention on the issue, Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan has urged the Kashmir Study Group to highlight the situation in Jammu and Kashmir, which he said "poses a grave threat to regional peace and security".

Khan met with the founder of Kashmir Study Group, Farooq Kathwari, who called on him in New York and both discussed the prevailing situation in J&K.

During the meeting, Pakistan Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi, Special Assistant to the PM Naeem ul Haq, UN Ambassador Maleeha Lodhi, Ambassador to the United States Asad Majeed Khan and other senior officials were also present.

Khan urged Kathwari to outline the issue of India''s revocation of special status of Jammu and Kashmir, which Pakistan has termed as "illegal annexation", and the alleged human rights violations there, in order to "expose the real face of fascist Modi-led Hindu nationalist government in front of the world".

Kathwari had earlier served as member of the US President''s Advisory Commission on Asian Americans.

Kathwari highlighted the Kashmir Study Group''s earlier engagement on the Jammu and Kashmir issue and efforts for conflict resolution.

Khan is here on a week-long visit to attend the UN General Assembly session and hold high-level meetings with world leaders.

According to Lodhi, upon his arrival here Khan has begun "mission Kashmir for Pakistan" with full zeal in order to draw the world''s attention towards the Kashmir issue.

"This is mission Kashmir for the prime minister and for Pakistan his message will be clear: the occupation must end, and a peaceful solution found for the Kashmir dispute. He will highlight the plight of the Kashmiri people who continue to suffer a suffocating lockdown and a brutal occupation," said Lodhi said, adding the Prime Minister would meet world leaders and the UN secretary general.

This is the Prime Minister''s first General Assembly visit and "he will be the voice of the Kashmiri people at the UN," she said.

Earlier, Foreign Minister Qureshi told reporters that Khan wanted to listen to Kashmiris from both parts of Kashmir ahead of his speech to the UN General Assembly on September 27

Qureshi said the main objective of Imran''s visit to US was to highlight alleged Indian atrocities in the valley.

Speaking to the media in New York, Qureshi said Imran will hold meetings with heads of different states and a Kashmiri delegation.

The Kashmir Study Group (kashmirstudygroup.org), consisting of 25 members with political, diplomatic and academic backgrounds, who extensively interact with the parties to the Kashmir issue. Established in 1996, KSG is headquartered in Larchmont, New York.

The Kashmir Study Group (KSG) works with the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Washington on Kashmir.

--IANS

rn/kr

https://www.outlookindia.com/newssc...n-khan-meets-with-kashmir-study-group/1624550

@Foxtrot Delta This Indian is claiming Azad Kashmiris are Punjabi speakers. Sorry to waste your time.

I am a Punjabi speaker, btw, and I don't speak a lick of Koshur. Punjabi is Indo-Aryan language which has larger Farsi influence, Kashmiri is a Dardic language.

Stop wasting our time and convince your Afghan brothers and sisters to migrate to Hindustan. Afghans keep coming in record numbers to Pakistan. Frankly we don’t want them here in Pakistan. RSS Indians and Afghans deserve each other. Both of you have a lot in common.



LOL these Indians keep raping and lynching Indian Muslims. Here they are pretending to be the saviors of Afghans.

Brother, besides Kabulie, Afghans are our brothers. We have fought the same enemies, triumphed over them, we are past the rough parts, now let's move forward together to the future.

LOL these Indians keep raping and lynching Indian Muslims. Here they are pretending to be the saviors of Afghans.

They don't know what Afghans think of Hindus. In Afghanistan, the word for slave is Hindu and it is a big insult.

You ask Afghans what they think of Indian "Blacks," they will show you how much venom they have for them.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom