Aryans vs Dravidians?

[Azizam]

Most bollywood actors are not punjabis and bollywood portrays the language and culture of states of hindi belt not punjab

Which communities or ethnic groups in India speak Hindi?

 

[Azizam]

many pakistanis have access to indian DTHs .every dth provides more than 70 south indian channels.take ur time and watch those channels.then tell me if u can really see big differences between the facial features of north and south indians.not all north inds look like tht sikh and not all south indians look like tht south indian.

Well, many of those TV stars artificially whiten their skin colour. They are not naturally light skinned buddy. I have also seen some Tamils with a lighter skin colour but I suspect they were also Aryan migrants who accepted the Tamil culture.

 

[PARAS]

Name non Punjabi-pathan leading actors of bollywood if you can.

Culture: Bollywood has run out of Punjabis by Aakar Patel

"They rule Bollywood and always have. To see why this is unusual, imagine a Pakistan film industry set in Karachi but with no Pashtuns or Mohajirs or Sindhis. Instead the actors are all Tamilian and the directors all Bengalis. Imagine also that all Pakistan responds to their Tamil superstars as the nation's biggest heroes. That is how unusual the composition of Bollywood is."

Communities which makes just 2.5% of population dominates Indian biggest film industry.

Biggest superstar of Bollywood is Amitabh Bachchan and he is not punjabi . The punjabis mentioned in the article are still just a few and almost all actors and no actresses. Except for the few kapoors etc no one is punjabi and none of the khans are pure pathans . They are more Indian than afghan . Also almost all but a few actresses are non punjabis as well .

 

[INDIC]

Name non Punjabi-pathan leading actors of bollywood if you can.

Culture: Bollywood has run out of Punjabis by Aakar Patel

"They rule Bollywood and always have. To see why this is unusual, imagine a Pakistan film industry set in Karachi but with no Pashtuns or Mohajirs or Sindhis. Instead the actors are all Tamilian and the directors all Bengalis. Imagine also that all Pakistan responds to their Tamil superstars as the nation's biggest heroes. That is how unusual the composition of Bollywood is."

Communities which makes just 2.5% of population dominates Indian biggest film industry.

During 50-70s most of the popular Hindi movie actors were Bengalis. Amitabh Bachchan is from East UP, Shatrughn Sinha is from Bihar.

Hindus dominated the movie industry of Punjab before partition, most of the studios in Lahore was owned by them but partition came as a disaster for Punjabi film industry and Pakistan never had a vibrant movie industry. Punjabis came to rule Bollywood with migration of Kapoor family(Prithviraj Kapoor and their sons) from Peshawar. Bollywoods most favorite villian Pran Sikand was a popular movie actor of Punjabi movies in Lahore but partition ruined his career in Punjabi movies and he started afresh in Bollywood.

 

[PARAS]

Which communities or ethnic groups in India speak Hindi?

The people of the red region speak proper hindi or its varieties.

The Hindi languages predominate in the Indian states and union territories of Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Delhi, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand.

 

[INDIC]

Which communities or ethnic groups in India speak Hindi?

These areas speak Hindi

 

[Azizam]

The people of the red region speak proper hindi or its varieties.

The Hindi languages predominate in the Indian states and union territories of Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Delhi, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand.

What are the Ethnic groups that speak Hindi?

 

[Nassr]

That is not what I am saying, merely that any opposing argument must be met only by force of facts, not of innuendo & name calling to dismiss debating the argument(Hindu nationalists etc..etc...). A predetermined conclusion cannot then be sought to be supported by evidence, it must be the other way around.

I agree with you. However, identifying a person or a set of people as Hindu nationalists or Hindu/Muslim fundamentalists due to a particular thinking or ideology is certainly not name calling or an innuendo, unless deliberately used in the manner. I am not saying that it is not used as such, what I am saying is that it is for the person to identify the sense of such usage and then respond. Though in the mass that express their views here or other such forums, the sense looses to senselessness.

 

[PARAS]

What are the Ethnic groups that speak Hindi?

Except for the few tribals of bihar, jharkhand and madhya pradesh and the mongoloids in uttarakhand and himachal pradesh all others are almost the same people and can't really be classified into different ethnicities .

 

[eastwatch]

note that these people of south east asia are fundamentally different from both the Aryans (Indo-European) or the Dravidians

here are few chakmas of people of Bangladesh

The top photo is of two Bangladeshi models wearing Lungi. They are not Chakma tribal people.

The 2nd photo is of a group of Chakma women.

The 3rd photo is of a Bangladeshi woman or model. She is not a Chakma.

 

[dravidianhero]

Not much difference between North Indian and South Indian since both look pretty much the same. The only difference is between punjabis and non punjabis, watch bollywood and tamil movies for confirmation.

stop ur crap...i admit there is a difference between most punjabis and most tamils.but i dont agree most paak punjabis look any diff from indians(most ind punjabis look a bit diff though).
Nawaz sharif,mustaq ahmed,shoaia malik,saqlain mustaq,shoaib akhtar,hafeez,amir sohail,saeed anwar ;the list goes on.
Do anyone among them look any diff from any indian?if u say yes,i can only laugh at you.

 

[Azizam]

Except for the few tribals of bihar, jharkhand and madhya pradesh and the mongoloids in uttarakhand and himachal pradesh all others are almost the same people and can't really be classified into different ethnicities .

So who developed Hindi language? It is still a puzzle to me. Even I couldn't find an ethnicity that speaks Hindi language as their primary language. Everyone has their own language like Biharis have Bihari and Punjabis have Punjabi.

 

[LaBong]

Not much difference between North Indian and South Indian since both look pretty much the same. The only difference is between punjabis and non punjabis, watch bollywood and tamil movies for confirmation.

Uncle is that you in your avatar? Somebody show uncle some pics of pakistani Punjabis. Uncle forgot to watch the mirror it seems!

 

[PARAS]

So who developed Hindi language? It is still a puzzle to me. Even I couldn't find an ethnicity that speaks Hindi language as their primary language. Everyone has their own language like Biharis have Bihari and Punjabis have Punjabi.

There is no language such as bihari . There are number of dialects of hindi such as khariboli or standardised hindi , haryanvi , kanauji , braj , awadhi , malwi , marwari etc and most of them are not mutually intelligible .

Hindi in its standardised form i.e, khariboli originated in western uttar pradesh from the local dialects and it is used by speakers of other dialects for conversation and is taught in schools .

Urdu , which is a sister language of Hindi , also originated in western UP

 

[LaBong]

stop ur crap...i admit there is a difference between most punjabis and most tamils.but i dont agree most paak punjabis look any diff from indians(most ind punjabis look a bit diff though).
Nawaz sharif,mustaq ahmed,shoaia malik,saqlain mustaq,shoaib akhtar,hafeez,amir sohail,saeed anwar ;the list goes on.
Do anyone among them look any diff from any indian?if u say yes,i can only laugh at you.

Nawaz Shrif is Kashmiri btw. I agree pakistani Punjabis look different than Indian Punjabis. At least their cricketers do.