What's new

Islam didn't enter the present day subcontinent via Sindh (Mohammad bin Qasim) correcting history.

First of all thanks for yr reply,
U have written that Caste system make difference in peoples and distribute people and group for specific task like brahmans, shuds, thakur etc . It used to be earlier not know,well any one came can become a prime minister or president.
Earlier A caste was based on social standing, heredity and ethnicity while A sect is a division of a religion,caste used to be a SOCIAL position,sect is religious doctrine based society.
Actually my response was to a Pakistani poster who wrote that he embraced Islam due to failed caste system. My knowledge of Islam is limited. But I remember reading somewhere that in Islam there are 73 sects,All Muslim sects happily claim that their sect is the ‘saved one’ (naji) and the ‘others’ are destined for hell.

PS: About me, I was born in a Hindu Brahmin family from Southern India

Actually 73 sects is a myth and we have more then 73 sects and yes few of them claim that they are the only who is naji but as a whole all a agree that when someone recite Kalma then all his sins and other matters will be handed over to Allah and it is he the supreme power to decide the faith of human being. We called that mutafiq aaliya.

PS: are you pandit, sharma or someone else?

Correction :

Caste : Pathetic word given by Britishers, it was Jati used to divide people based on the service they used to provide to the society. Later on exploited by Brahmins, and changed in the last chapter of Rig veda i.e 10th .

Sect : Its not somebody chooses, but it is what somebody becomes based on his/her parents belief. So don't bring the sh!ts like "people choose Sunni, Shiya or Ahmedi coz they are willing".

Jati & Sects both are same, everybody gets tagged the moment they are born & they all discriminate against each other.

Then enlighten us that who force them to follows?. Few of my family members are Ahlay Hadith, few of my relative are from Shia community and i my self following Hanafi but in some cases Shaifi or Hambali. By the way Ahmedi is not a muslim because they stated that Prophet Mohammed was not last messenger of Allah
 
I thought Islam first came to Sub continent through sea route .
They first landed in South India just like Jews and Christians .
 
The Cheraman Juma Masjid (Malayalam:ചേരമാൻ പള്ളി) is a mosque in Methala, Kodungallur Taluk, Thrissur District in the Indian state of Kerala. Built in 629 AD, it is the first mosque in India. It was built by Malik Deenar, an Arab propagator of Islam and a follower and contemporary of Islamic Prophet Muhammad.

Prophet Mohammed died in the year 632 AD. At that time the blue region is under the influence of Islam.

islamic-conquest_map632.JPG
. There is no information as to what happened to those followers.. were they really the seed of Muslim community in the subcontinent? We don't know..we do know is that the conquest of makran was when Muslims used a base in panjgur to further extend their arm towards east.we know many converted in the meanwhile and actual Muslim majority towns started popping up around Indus. This extension was more prominent during m Qasims era but it actually started back in 2nd caliph s time.The. course of history tells us the Muslim communities started building up in India after Junaid and his successors invaded present day India from the west and not the other way around. Besides whether Muslim traders first landed Kerala or some other port on the west(less proximity) is also debatable.
 
But we have forum etiquette too.
Yea I guess! Arab imperialists did try to invade current day sindh and some parts of india way before Islam existed. That's why I called his post ignorant.
 
Which Means You Don't Know Anything


BTW These Gentleman Know A Lot About Christianity and They Left It












Yes We Do

(Guinness World Records 2003, pg 102)

(Allah and Elohim - Are they the Same God? , Preface)


http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tan...e-the-worlds-fastest-growing-religious-group/


http://edition.cnn.com/WORLD/9704/14/egypt.islam/



Because you make a lot of babies, which all living things do. Big whoop-di-doo, congratulations, you responded to a troll with fap.

Well you should be fearless and express
Like me 8-)
 
In islam there is no caste only several sects. Well u have written that caste system is a failed project. What do you say about sect.


Islam doesn't recognise any sects ......... in fact it prohibits from forming sects and division of people.
 
If You Want To Destroy Your Afterlife Fine With Me I Don't Care
This is off topic but I can't resist.
'you will not live to see your afterlife':D

Anyways this thread was a good read.
 
Then enlighten us that who force them to follows?. Few of my family members are Ahlay Hadith, few of my relative are from Shia community and i my self following Hanafi but in some cases Shaifi or Hambali. By the way Ahmedi is not a muslim because they stated that Prophet Mohammed was not last messenger of Allah

Well then apologies, I didn't knew the world is so beautiful between Islamic sects.

I didn't knew that the news regarding the SA vs Iran, Sectarian Mosques getting bombed in my neighbor, Syria, Yemen, etc were actually fake news, I was f**king brainwashed by media. Thnx for enlightening me.

And whether Ahmedis are muslim or not, should not be decided by Mullahs and molvis. It is the god who will actually decide whether to accept them or not. :coffee:
 
'you will not live to see your afterlife'

.

You Mean I Will End Up In Chakra of Birth and Rebirth :o::o:

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

culkin.jpg


Because you make a lot of babies, which all living things do. Big whoop-di-doo, congratulations, you responded to a troll with fap.


Like me 8-)

Read The Links Again What Part of 12.5 Million More Converts Don't You Get.Read This If You Want More.
And BTW The Videos Are Of Men With Strong Christian Upbringing and Sheikh Yusuf Was An Islamophobe Before Converting.Read This

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...UK-White-women-keen-embrace-Muslim-faith.html
 
You Mean I Will End Up In Chakra of Birth and Rebirth :o::o:

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I consider concepts like rebirth and afterlife as hogwash. It has absolutely no meaning for me.
 
Read The Links Again What Part of 12.5 Million More Converts Don't You Get.Read This If You Want More.
And BTW The Videos Are Of Men With Strong Christian Upbringing and Sheikh Yusuf Was An Islamophobe Before Converting.Read This
I didn't say there wasn't any converts to Islam, most of the growth however is from fertility of Muslims. No need to hyperventilate.

http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/04/23/

You posted this link first. ^^^^
 

Back
Top Bottom