Afghan Students in trouble in Indian universities

[kbd-raaf]

All of the above is based on estimates, that is not the case with India.

It is obviously going to be based on estimates when there are no official numbers being reported by your Government.

 

[Kompromat]

This image doesn't answer his question.

What he (and I) are looking for are the un-reported rape statistics (estimates obviously) for both Pakistan and India.

Unreported rape cases make up the majority of rapes in the world. They are based on "estimates",therefore no accurate research can be conducted,if it is it will not be peer reviewed for no credible source and therefore will not be published.

 

[kbd-raaf]

Unreported rape cases make up the majority of rapes in the world. They are based on "estimates",therefore no accurate research can be conducted,if it is it will not be peer reviewed for no credible source and therefore will not be published.

Yes, that is clear, even if we assume unreported rape numbers is the same in India as it is Pakistan, it is obvious that India is doing better in terms of protection for women.

But in reality, unreported rape in India is likely to be far less than in Pakistan.

 

[Kompromat]

Is that talking about the ratio or number of cases reported?

You are asking for something that doesn't exist. Only thing that exists is estimates,which are hardly credible. We have to argue on information at hand not the information that cant be accumulated and assessed.

 

[qamar1990]

Afghans in trouble in Indian universities

Mian Saifur Rehman
Friday, June 21, 2013
From Print Edition

Following the bashing of many Afghan students in India’s Sharda University, a good few Afghan parents have withdrawn their children from Indian institutions and also requested the Kabul government to intervene and take up the matter with New Delhi government to stop these ethnic conflicts.

The News has learnt from reliable sources that have been instrumental in Pak-Afghan Ulema peace conference and have close connections in Afghanistan that reports were not satisfactory and good about the condition of Afghan students getting higher education in some Indian institutes. The sources told The News that yet greater cause of concern was the breach of security of Afghan students on some occasions at the hands of Indian students and their accomplices some of whom were reportedly toughies enjoying patronage of the local influential.

Giving detailed account of the happening, the sources said that in May 2013, some local students of Sharda University Campus (Greater Navaida) teased an Afghan girl student and even tried to abduct her.

Following the Afghan students’ reaction, the Indian students got infuriated and then followed clashes among Indian and Afghan students.

Heavy contingents of police intervened and shifted Afghan students to a safer place outside the University premises because some Indian students had threatened to kill them (the Afghan students). As many as 30 students and a few cops were injured during this scuffle.

Sources say that certain quarters were fomenting ethnic hatred and prejudices the demonstration of which was witnessed even earlier in February 2013 in the Annual Cultural Festival of National Institute of Technology Rourkela, India. In that occurrence too, many Afghan students were hurt.

Similar clashes, according to sources, erupted yet earlier in Raween Shah University in which many Afghan students were injured including the son of a Karzai government minister. At that time, 58 Afghan students including two female students were forced to take refuge in New Delhi following threats to life received from some Indian students.

The Afghan-connected sources further informed The News that the parents of Afghan students had expressed their satisfaction over the nice treatment given to their children in Pakistani Universities.

These parents say that their children were also studying in European, Iranian and some other countries’ institutions but at no place other than India, they (the Afghan students) were subjected to intimidation and coercion.

Afghans in trouble in Indian universities - thenews.com.pk

good these afghans deserve it.
they bit the hand that fed them(pakistan) and they went to indias lap and this is what they gonna get now.

 

[Icewolf]

Yes, that is clear, even if we assume unreported rape numbers is the same in India as it is Pakistan, it is obvious that India is doing better in terms of protection for women.

But in reality, unreported rape in India is likely to be far less than in Pakistan.

How?
India has almost the same reported rape per capita as Pakistan.
Now India has 7x more population than Pakistan.

Can you use your brain? India is literally a no-go area for women.

 

[mahabharath]

You are asking for something that doesn't exist. Only thing that exists is estimates,which are hardly credible. We have to argue on information at hand not the information that cant be accumulated and assessed.

@Icewolf

 

[kbd-raaf]

How?
India has almost the same reported rape per capita as Pakistan.
Now India has 7x more population than Pakistan.

Can you use your brain? India is literally a no-go area for women.

Are you sure you are a functional literate?

No. Pakistan has a HIGHER rape per capita.

Per capita is important, absolute numbers are NOT.

 

[karan.1970]

All of the above is based on estimates, that is not the case with India.

Not so

Interior Ministry documents placed before the National Assembly in 2008 revealed that a staggering 7,546 women were raped in a mere 24-month span between 2007-2009, a rate of 314 rapes every month.

Why the deafening silence after rape? – The Express Tribune Blog



with those numbers (NOT ESTIMATES), it translates to 2.25 rapes per 100,000 population in Pakistan against the figure of 1.8 in India..

And these are 4 year old figures.. violence and lawlessness has only gone up in last 4 years in Pakistan

 

[Aka123]

Making a Mountain out of a mole!

Clash of Afghan students topic changed into Indo Pak rape ratio topic.

Wah! Badiya.... and this is what u called Healthy discussion.
@WebMaster..... Plz check this thread.... Indo Afghan student topic, changed into Indo Pak rape topic.

 

[karan.1970]

You are asking for something that doesn't exist. Only thing that exists is estimates,which are hardly credible. We have to argue on information at hand not the information that cant be accumulated and assessed.

Not estimates my friend.. Formal figures presented in your National Assembly...

 

[Ayush]

Are you sure you are a functional literate?

No. Pakistan has a HIGHER rape per capita.

Per capita is important, absolute numbers are NOT.

why not both..

 

[Kompromat]

Yes, that is clear, even if we assume unreported rape numbers is the same in India as it is Pakistan, it is obvious that India is doing better in terms of protection for women.

But in reality, unreported rape in India is likely to be far less than in Pakistan.

That is just your own assumption [you can live with it]...it wont be mine as if what you are saying cant be believed as Pakistan doesn't even make it to top 10 rape offending nations. Protection is out of question when the on hand statistics tell a different story. Raping in Pakistan mean you are dead. Just for further reading, that Pakistani govt doesn't gather statistics on rape but human rights organizations and NGOs do including the UN. Top 5 countries for harshest rape punishment are all Muslim countries with each awarding capital punishment. There is no Muslim majority country in the top 10 rape offending nations, for obvious reasons as it is not culturally acceptable and we hand out the biggest shaft in store to the offenders.

 

[kbd-raaf]

why not both..

That meme is fast becoming my most frequently used.

 

[qamar1990]

Yes, that is clear, even if we assume unreported rape numbers is the same in India as it is Pakistan, it is obvious that India is doing better in terms of protection for women.

But in reality, unreported rape in India is likely to be far less than in Pakistan.

that is not the case, in india a woman gets raped every few mins.