Xinjiang people over 60 enjoy pension insurance benefits even if they haven’t paid fees or insuffici

[Paul2]

Just curious, how can you tell from your own personal experience whether it's 10m or 20m though? It feels more crowded?

I'm of the view that Shenzhen has around 20m people as well.

1) Many official estimates put the effective population at 20m.
2) Number of official workers in Shenzhen are comparable to Shanghai.
3) It's unlikely that SZ's GDP per capita is 50% more than Beijing/Shanghai when average wages are lower.


https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/chin...ed-in-2018-10-087.590562/page-5#post-11011643
https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/chin...ed-in-2018-10-087.590562/page-5#post-11012882
https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/chin...ed-in-2018-10-087.590562/page-6#post-11013590

A feeling during the commute, I was never squeezed like that in any ~10M city even during worst rush hours. Same on roads. And that even if you make a discount for Shenzhen being a rather densely built up even by Chinese standards.

And I will trust professional demographers after all. They did a survey few year ago during Ma Xinrui's administration.

 

[Adam WANG SHANGHAI MEGA]

Explanation look very simple to me, and more sound to my knowledge of average incomes across China (I work close to manufacturing) : labour market was going further inland for many years, and salaries are getting equalised. Plain economics here.

A feeling during the commute, I was never squeezed like that in any ~10M city even during worst rush hours. Same on roads. And that even if you make a discount for Shenzhen being a rather densely built up even by Chinese standards.

And I will trust professional demographers after all. They did a survey few year ago during Ma Xinrui's administration.

You guys are really funny!!!
You know what! let us make 32 millions the number of population for Shenzhen. Then the GDP per capita of Shenzhen would be more reasonable for a developped country like China.

 

[Mista]

A feeling during the commute, I was never squeezed like that in any ~10M city even during worst rush hours. Same on roads. And that even if you make a discount for Shenzhen being a rather densely built up even by Chinese standards.

And I will trust professional demographers after all. They did a survey few year ago during Ma Xinrui's administration.

Heh, we have 5m people but trains are squeezy during rush hour too. I personally want to experience the rush hour of Tokyo or Beijing one day.

 

[Paul2]

Heh, we have 5m people but trains are squeezy during rush hour too. I personally want to experience the rush hour of Tokyo or Beijing one day.

I lived in Singapore for 2 years as an exchange student, and the squeeze there was nothing at all. Not like people lining outside of metro stations.

You guys are really funny!!!
You know what! let us make 32 millions the number of population for Shenzhen. Then the GDP per capita of Shenzhen would be more reasonable for a developped country like China.

You don't trust your fellow senior party member and professional demographers?? That's not funny.

 

[Mista]

Not like people lining outside of metro stations.

 

[Adam WANG SHANGHAI MEGA]

It is rush hours every single day in China,that is another reason why So many people want to immigrate to outside,coz they know they need to compete with 10 millions students to enter Beijing University .