Wish we could have been a Federation as originally envisioned by Jinnah

[Water Car Engineer]

Unlike you we dont kill people for being low caste or muslims... sunshine... wake up.

Give me a break. Don't act like Pakistan is roses.

Both are third world countries, there will be such things. But India is the one with the billion people and many ethnic groups. It could be MUCH worse in India. Things are improving.

 

[RazPaK]

What it would be like is slavery to hindus. Yeap im good on that.

 

[Karachiite]

What it would be like is slavery to hindus. Yeap im good on that.

So your okay with being a slave to Americans, Mullahs and Arabs?

 

[RazPaK]

So your okay with being a slave to Americans, Mullahs and Arabs?

No american, mullah, nor arab dictates me.

 

[Pakistanisage]

What it would be like is slavery to hindus. Yeap im good on that.

In an undivided India, Muslims would have been close to 40% of Indian Population. To say that 40% percent of Population would have been enslaved is stretching credulity.

 

[Don Jaguar]

In an undivided India, Muslims would have been close to 40% of Indian Population. To say that 40% percent of Population would have been enslaved is stretching credulity.

Are you really against partition?

Well bro i am a big supporter of it.

If we were united today our condition would be miserable today.

Keep in mind in india muslims are the most poor people.

 

[Don Jaguar]

Also read the history of sub continent from 1900 to 1940 it was the same quaid-e-azam who finally decided to create Pakistan after he supported undivided india.

Actually if you will read it properly you will see india proved itself as bharat.

Every time muslims demand anything it was denied saying we are secular and we cannot give you this on the basis of religion and every time hindus need anything they get it saying we are majority.

 

[Thorough Pro]

I am not sure how old you are, but I am old enough for you to call me a son. If by using this phrase you meant to look big in stature, than that was a miserable try.

Before telling me or somebody else to read the Pakistan/India history, I think you should do it first and then come back for a meaningful discussion. And by your statment IO guess you are not even cognizant of the very reason for creation of Pakistan.

While you are free to think any way you like and express your opinion or share your thoughts, mind you they are insulting and hurtfull to millions who lost their dear ones in the process.

I have suffered personl losses, three of my real uncles were murdered in front my mother's eyes during the great migratin from India, there are others who lost even more.

The irnoy is people like you with no footing on the subject come to these forums and try to play great historians, philosphers, soocialists and politicians with your idiotically radical brain farts from behind a screen and start calling "Son" to people who might be their fathers age.

Learn some manners and learn your history. If you can't be patriotic don't be fifth columinist.

And don't bother, I am not going to respond to any more of your posts.

Easy Son, I am neither a false flagger nor a traitor to Pakistan. I just want to explore the thought of what if. You should learn little bit about our Sub-continent history instead of lashing out at me.

Do you even know that Muhammd Ali Jinnah had signed off to that agreement ( called Cabinet Mission Plan ) and had Nehru not pulled out of this agreement at the last minute after agreeing to it earlier, there would have been an India-Pakistan Federation.

Obviously, you are a hot blooded Pakistani youth with no concept of our country's history. Please update yourself and come back to engage in the debate. But this time come back with some manners that your parents might have taught you.

Pakistan Zindabad.

 

[Don Jaguar]

!!!PAKISTAN ZINDABAD!!!

 

[Thorough Pro]

LOL hahahahha coming from an indians mouth.............

As the saying goes ,U can Pick ur Friends ,but not ur neighbors. U think India has anything to loose with this staus quo?

Unfortunately many of us Indians are romantics that see the destruction that lies in over inflated egos and the strength in unity.

IF an average Pakistanis cant see it there loss. Maybe in good time.Everyone has to grow up sooner or later.

Stupid logic, What jinnah did along these lines was BEFORE Pakistan in undivided India. Guess you can't differenciate between the two situations.

Jinnah was a outstanding visionary, if cabinet plan would have been accepted Jinnah would have been Our First PM, with India & Pakistan two federal states like USA & Canada neighbouring each other peace fully, we would have been AXIS OF POWER OF ENTIRE ASIA.

But its gone oppurtunity and with the things happened in last 5-6 decades I think seperate existance of India & Pakistan is need of time. Jinnah's dream will go to trash of history



Bolded Part.... so according to your definition Mohd. Ali Jinnah was a false flagger & Non-Pakistani

 

[RazPaK]

I lost many family members during partition and pre partitition. Although i respect pakistanisage i can never forget the atrocities comitted against ny family. This thread was opened in poor taste.

 

[Thorough Pro]

There is a very clear difference in "Freedom of thought" and "Stupid thought", but dont bother you won't get it. For you freedom of thought means every thaought is great.

Nice post indeed !!!!

 

[Don Jaguar]

Thank you sir.

 

[ares]

Also read the history of sub continent from 1900 to 1940 it was the same quaid-e-azam who finally decided to create Pakistan after he supported undivided india.

Actually if you will read it properly you will see india proved itself as bharat.

Every time muslims demand anything it was denied saying we are secular and we cannot give you this on the basis of religion and every time hindus need anything they get it saying we are majority.

Why don't you be a doll, back up your argument and point out some of "those" things that were denied to Muslims(with evidence off course)!!

 

[kumarkumar1867]

whatever happened happened for the BEST. and looking at the posts by some indians it clearly shows that Jinnah was right Hindus wanted to walk all over the muslims

Please enlighten us Where did you see "Hindu wanted to walk all over muslims" in comments of indians??

Cabinet Mission Plan was a output of British favouritism towards a loyal Diplomat called Mohd. Ali Jinnah, who never protested British or supported any anti-british activities openly.The only reason he never saw imprisonment in life.

Nehru was a moderate hindu, he loved muslims but he equally loved hindus too. Apart from his quest/lust he was a man with mordern perspective & didnt wanted dominance of neither muslims nor hindus. Same was vision of Maulana Azad who wanted hindu & muslims to dwell in India equally & peacefully.

Cabinet Mission plan was type of black-mailing for Hindus/ Gandhi/Nehru who were supporter for UNDIVIDED INDIA , I am glad our leaders were not prey of this Jinnah-British Conspiracy.