Will Consider India for NSG Membership: Germany

[CardSharp]

The article I posted is much after 1998. If the opinion of M Hibbs counts so much for you, I would like to believe those in BARC. For two reasons both of which I cant post on a public forum.

Here is however something to chew :

Ok secret agent man.

 

[CardSharp]

Cardsharp, I can point to credible western estimates of yield that match the Indian claims. Read my previous reply and just go though the first link I have given. You will get references to the same western country scientists showing clear compliance to Indian measurements.

You mean the low rent html website (south asia analysis group) maintained by Brahma Chellaney (ex government minister)?

 

[ramu]

You mean the low rent html website (south asia analysis group) maintained by Brahma Chellaney (ex government minister)?

Your argument is where this article is hosted and not its content. Do you know who the author of the article is ?

Principal Scientific Adviser, Government of India

Here is the link to the journal since you don't trust "cheap html"

http://www.inderscience.com/search/index.php?action=record&rec_id=19890

 

[ramu]

Ok secret agent man.

I don't have to be a secret agent to hold on to what I know. I can use my discretion to reveal only those that I deem fit to be written in a public forum. Instead of all these tangential discussions, let me see a point by point rebuttal of the link I posted.

 

[Tshering22]

Excellent this will mean that India will have to promise not to partake in future nuclear tests.

Do you really think that a piece of paper would matter if we find it absolutely necessary to conduct tests? You're confusing us with Afghanistan. This goes for our no-first-use as well that is hailed so much. People often forget its third line stating that this policy is towards only non-nuclear countries unless and until absolutely necessary. Our ministers might be idiots but you're confusing strategists with them. They're two different breed.

 

[somebozo]

India did not have necessary industrial expertise to manufacture all the components needed for nuke tech so where did it get them from?? proliferation?

 

[deckingraj]

Do you really think that a piece of paper would matter if we find it absolutely necessary to conduct tests? You're confusing us with Afghanistan. This goes for our no-first-use as well that is hailed so much. People often forget its third line stating that this policy is towards only non-nuclear countries unless and until absolutely necessary. Our ministers might be idiots but you're confusing strategists with them. They're two different breed.

When you are signatory of NPT/CTBT then yes, the piece of paper will matter.....These are international agreements and not some joke.....

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Nazis (Germany) are really eager to aquire the nuclear bomb and then they will be back to their old ways

Note: My statement on Nazi is directed only at the elements who support , Nazism in germany and I think they control some portion of German Government secretly

 

[mautkimaut]

India did not have necessary industrial expertise to manufacture all the components needed for nuke tech so where did it get them from?? proliferation?

Friday ki namaz ke baad kuch ho jata hai kya?
If Pakistan can get it, N Korea can get it why cant India? you guys cant make a motor cycle but you made bomb didnt you unless you want to admit that it was basically a chinese bomb which you got..

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Friday ki namaz ke baad kuch ho jata hai kya?
If Pakistan can get it, N Korea can get it why cant India? you guys cant make a motor cycle but you made bomb didnt you unless you want to admit that it was basically a chinese bomb which you got..

First decide if it was korean,european or chinese nuke........... Till than go study the stolen candan nuclear reactor designs and russian help tht made india a nuclear power.

Abt motorcycles......Yes we make em.... so next time dont post crap.

 

[Ammyy]

First decide if it was korean,european or chinese nuke........... Till than go study the stolen candan nuclear reactor designs and russian help tht made india a nuclear power.

Abt motorcycles......Yes we make em.... so next time dont post crap.

Till now you are not able to made your own nuclear reactors but you have nuke bombs ????

Just like you dnt have SLV but missiles

 

[desiman]

India did not have necessary industrial expertise to manufacture all the components needed for nuke tech so where did it get them from?? proliferation?

and Pakistan does have that expertise ? Where did you get that from ? lol You guys practically invented the term proliferation and then you accuse India, funny.

 

[Roybot]

Eurofighter anyone?

 

[jbond197]

What are pros or cons of joining NSG and what are the pre-conditions? Just curious to know so guys who know enough please reply.

 

[jbond197]

Eurofighter anyone?

Quite possible, first there was a statement from French of stopping arm supply to Pakistan and now this statement from German Ambassador. Rafael vs Eurofighter fighting it out..