What's new

Why was Bose diminished on Republic Day?

No. We have forgotten him. We have failed. It is our collective failure. We try to pour all the blame on Congress and other xyz. But the lion's share of the blame is on us. Then of course, there was the political mainstream.

Had he been alive in the first 10 years of Independent India, I am sure India would have been a very different country...... His approach also would have incorporated in our way of life........
 
.
Those who are not prepared to handle truth ...always chose to IGNORE it .
 
. .

first off all do you agree with title ?

It calls Netaji as Fascist leader ?

Second thing - what is the point in circulating speculator stories ?

If Netjai who had dared to go to Germany , Japan to fight against all powerful british will he choose to live in isolation , in cognito as a Gumaani baba in an Independent India ?

You should think before you keep posting such rubbish . One long thread is filled with such rubbish already !!!
 
.
Those who are not prepared to handle truth ...always chose to IGNORE it .

Oh well, what truth? You didn't indulge in any constructive debate other than demanding your rantings to be the truth, did you?

first off all do you agree with title ?

It calls Netaji as Fascist leader ?

Second thing - what is the point in circulating speculator stories ?

If Netjai who had dared to go to Germany , Japan to fight against all powerful british will he choose to live in isolation , in cognito as a Gumaani baba in an Independent India ?

You should think before you keep posting such rubbish . One long thread is filled with such rubbish already !!!

Have you read it beyond the title?
 
.
Oh well, what truth? You didn't indulge in any constructive debate other than demanding your rantings to be the truth, did you?

so the story that Netaji held his umbrella against neck of governor general and told him to mind his own business is true .

and if one counters that ...it is rant ?
 
.
Oh well, what truth? You didn't indulge in any constructive debate other than demanding your rantings to be the truth, did you?



Have you read it beyond the title?
Ignore him.

The author's POV is something I don't fully agree with. The jury can't be out without the 39 remaining docs that are still classified. But the contents are awesome. The coincidences are mind boggling.
 
.
Have you read it beyond the title?

I havde read it to the last line ..and I have read multiple such rubbish articles over last few days ...
in thread titled Stalin Killed Netaji ...

what is your point ?
 
.
so the story that Netaji held his umbrella against neck of governor general and told him to mind his own business is true .

and if one counters that ...it is rant ?

If you counter, counter with proof, or just say you don't believe it and leave it there, what is the need for going into an unending ranting over three pages. We could have discussed his life here instead, but no.
 
.
If you counter, counter with proof, or just say you don't believe it and leave it there, what is the need for going into an unending ranting over three pages. We could have discussed his life here instead, but no.

this is as much important .

this is how the gossip becomes myth and myth becomes truth ...when churned out by hundreds of mouths .

who started the rants on Nehru-Gandhi. ?

did I ?

why is that every thread on Netaji has to start with bashing Nehru and Gandhiji ?

you should ask op and others who are doing that .

did you ask them ?
 
.
If you counter, counter with proof, or just say you don't believe it and leave it there, what is the need for going into an unending ranting over three pages. We could have discussed his life here instead, but no.
Put him on your Ignore List. I have. :)
I have read a couple of books on him. Any other you would like to suggest? :)
 
.
10 Interesting Facts about Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose
Posted on January 23, 2013 by TNI Bureau

By Srikant Mohanty: A proud nation pays rich tribute to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose on his 116th birth anniversary today. The legend is the idol of millions of people, for his noble sacrifice and able leadership during freedom struggle of India. His unique vision for his country is still an inspiration for Indians from generation to generation. Although his life remains an open book, certain facts in his life show his brilliance and rare courage.



Ten interesting facts of this visionary are as follows.

1. Netaji was born in the year 1897 as the 9th child of his parents at Cuttack in Odisha. He was exceptionally brilliant and secured top ranks throughout his study in the school and university. He was placed 4th in order of merit in the examination of Indian Civil service and qualified as an ICS Officer. He showed his depths in nine subjects, while appearing at the civil services, which proved his exceptional brilliance.

2. Netaji refused to obey the prohibition to carry his umbrella while meeting the Governor General at his office in Kolkata after being successful in Indian Civil Services (ICS) examination. It was then a traditional dignity to carry the umbrella for every Bengali gentleman. When the Governor General objected to this, asking him to explain his behavior, he dared to put the umbrella around the neck of British Governor General and warn him to mind his behavior.

3. Netaji resigned from the lucrative career of civil service to join the freedom struggle.

4. During the period of 1921-1941, he was imprisoned eleven times in various jails in India.

5. In the year 1941, with a daring escape from house arrest in India, Netaji Subhas Bose went from Kolkata to Gomo by a car and from there travelled to Peshawar by train. From Peshawar (now in Pakistan), he went to Kabul and from there he travelled to Germany to seek help from Adlof Hitler.

6. During his stay in Berlin in the year 1943, Netaji had established the Free India Center and Azad Hind Radio station. In January 1943, the Japanese invited Bose to lead the Indian nationalist movement in East Asia. He accepted and left Germany on 8 February and later led INA.

7. Netaji Subhas Bose travelled from Germany to Madagascar by a German Sub-marine named U-180 and from there a Japanese sub-marine called I-29 took him to Japan. The voyage in two sub-marines covering such a long distance was extremely hazardous and it does not find any parallel in any freedom struggle.

8. Netaji differed from Mahatma Gandhi’s view of gaining independence through a non-violent struggle. In a unique comment, he described the British dominion of India as a fortress and the non-violent struggle would be like just raising a commotion around it without any effect.

9. Netaji appeared at the 1939 Congress meeting on a stretcher. He was reelected as president over Gandhi’s preferred candidate Pattabhi Sitaramayya.

10. Netaji’s death in a plane crash is still not proven by any evidence. There are many of evidences in favour of Netaji’s existence in Russia and India even after many years of India’s independence.

10 Interesting Facts about Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose |The News Insight
 
.
Netaji is the greatest leader of modern day India.

I request you to read is life.
 
.
thread is opened by @Janajaweed

all that @levina has done is to post her rants . which is partly good because that means ..she remembers Netaji's birthday .

I think we should take opportunity to pay obeisance to Netaji .

Rtaher than turn it into Netaji Vs Gandhi -Nehru kind of tussel .

It does not befit great soul like Netaji ...
Good that I didnot receive any alert for this mention, or else I would have grilled you like a sausage 3 days back :coffee:
When did you see me ranting on this thread??
Btw, I am going to visit Netaji's house today.
How did it go??
And no I am not the Op of this thread. :)
I wonder why Netaji did not use that umbrella as a weapon and finish off the Governor general and won the Independence for the country . Poor Gandhiji then would not have had to comb through the country to awaken the nation :D
Because Netaji was smarter than you think. :coffee:

10 Interesting Facts about Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose
Posted on January 23, 2013 by TNI Bureau

By Srikant Mohanty: A proud nation pays rich tribute to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose on his 116th birth anniversary today. The legend is the idol of millions of people, for his noble sacrifice and able leadership during freedom struggle of India. His unique vision for his country is still an inspiration for Indians from generation to generation. Although his life remains an open book, certain facts in his life show his brilliance and rare courage.



Ten interesting facts of this visionary are as follows.

1. Netaji was born in the year 1897 as the 9th child of his parents at Cuttack in Odisha. He was exceptionally brilliant and secured top ranks throughout his study in the school and university. He was placed 4th in order of merit in the examination of Indian Civil service and qualified as an ICS Officer. He showed his depths in nine subjects, while appearing at the civil services, which proved his exceptional brilliance.

2. Netaji refused to obey the prohibition to carry his umbrella while meeting the Governor General at his office in Kolkata after being successful in Indian Civil Services (ICS) examination. It was then a traditional dignity to carry the umbrella for every Bengali gentleman. When the Governor General objected to this, asking him to explain his behavior, he dared to put the umbrella around the neck of British Governor General and warn him to mind his behavior.

3. Netaji resigned from the lucrative career of civil service to join the freedom struggle.

4. During the period of 1921-1941, he was imprisoned eleven times in various jails in India.

5. In the year 1941, with a daring escape from house arrest in India, Netaji Subhas Bose went from Kolkata to Gomo by a car and from there travelled to Peshawar by train. From Peshawar (now in Pakistan), he went to Kabul and from there he travelled to Germany to seek help from Adlof Hitler.

6. During his stay in Berlin in the year 1943, Netaji had established the Free India Center and Azad Hind Radio station. In January 1943, the Japanese invited Bose to lead the Indian nationalist movement in East Asia. He accepted and left Germany on 8 February and later led INA.

7. Netaji Subhas Bose travelled from Germany to Madagascar by a German Sub-marine named U-180 and from there a Japanese sub-marine called I-29 took him to Japan. The voyage in two sub-marines covering such a long distance was extremely hazardous and it does not find any parallel in any freedom struggle.

8. Netaji differed from Mahatma Gandhi’s view of gaining independence through a non-violent struggle. In a unique comment, he described the British dominion of India as a fortress and the non-violent struggle would be like just raising a commotion around it without any effect.

9. Netaji appeared at the 1939 Congress meeting on a stretcher. He was reelected as president over Gandhi’s preferred candidate Pattabhi Sitaramayya.

10. Netaji’s death in a plane crash is still not proven by any evidence. There are many of evidences in favour of Netaji’s existence in Russia and India even after many years of India’s independence.

10 Interesting Facts about Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose |The News Insight
Thank you for posting this link..

Most fantastic story I have ever heard !!!
Pls read Dray's post.
 
.
Good that I didnot receive any alert for this mention, or else I would have grilled you like a sausage 3 days back :coffee:
When did you see me ranting on this thread??

How did it go??
And no I am not the Op of this thread. :)

Because Netaji was smarter than you think. :coffee:


Thank you for posting this link..


Pls read Dray's post.

He has read it in that 'Stalin killed Netaji' thread, this thread got deleted and it was restored just yesterday. Please delete the tag or quote to him to avoid mile long replies, in short he doesn't trust this internet link or any other similar links that I had provided him. However, I am ok with what he believes, but it doesn't end there as I am also required to believe what he believes. :)
 
.
Back
Top Bottom