What's new

why a patriotic general turned unpatriotic...

Garry

BANNED
Joined
Feb 8, 2011
Messages
187
Reaction score
0
History behind the generalGeneral Shabeg Singh- the great general of modern times belonged to village Khiala, about nine miles from Am Chogwan Road. Displaying a keen interest in history and literature his village teachers were so impressed with his intellectual ability that they advised his father and mother to send him to a school. He was sent to Khalsa College Amritsar for secondary education and from there to a Govt. College at Lahore for higher education. He was an outstanding football and hockey player who excelled in athletics. At the age of 18 he had equaled the India record in 100 meters sprint and was the District Broad jump champion.In 1940, an officer’s selection team visiting Lahore colleges was looking for fresh recruits to the Indian Army officer’s cadre. Out of a large number of students, who applied, Shabeg Singh was the only one to be selected from a Government College for training in the officer training school.After training he was commissioned in the second Punjab Regiment as a Second Lieutenant. Within a few days the Regiment moved to Burma and joined the war against the Japanese, which was then in progress. In 1944 when the war ended he was in Malaya with his unit. After partition, when reorganization of the regiments took place, he joined the Parachute brigade as a Paratrooper. He was posted in the 1st para battalion in which he remained till 1959. He was an instructor in the Military Academy at Dehra Dun and held a number of important staff appointments in various ranks In the army he had a reputation of being fearless officer and one who did not tolerate any nonsense. People either loved him or dreaded him because of his frank and forthright approach. During the course of his service in the Indian army, Shaheg Singh fought in every war that India participated in..

Shabeg Singh Getting a Wartime medal from President of India In 1947, he was at Naushera in Jammu and Kashmir fighting against the Pakistan Army.
n 1962 during the India-China war, he was in the Northeast Frontier Agency as a Lt. Col. in HQ four Corps where he was GSO-J (Intelligence). In the 196S operations against Pakistan, he was in the Hajji Pir Sector in Jammu and Kashmir, commanding a battalion of Gorkha troops. He commanded 3/11 Gorkha Rifles with distinction and was mentioned in dispatches for the capture of important enemy positions on the Haji Pir front.
A few days before the battalion was to he launched into attack, the Commanding Officer (that time Lieutenant Colonel) Shabeg Singh received a telegram from his mother informing him that his father had expired. Being the eldest he quietly put the telegram in his pocket and no one in his battalion even knew that the commanding officer had lost his father on the eve of battle, Only when the operations were over, did he apply for leave and perform his duty of consoling his mother and family. His mother, Pritam Kaur, never asked why he had not been reached for performing the last rites. Everything was understood the call of duty to defend the nation's frontiers was of primary importance.
Soon after the 1965 operations, Shabeg became Col G.S. of an infantry division, after which he was given command of the crack 19 Infantry brigade in Jammu Sector. In 1%9 when the Eastern sector of India was becoming deeply involved in Naga anti-insurgency operations he was posted as Deputy GOC of the largest Indian Division - eight Mountain Division which had nearly 50 thousand troops under his command. With his leadership qualities and use of daredevil tactics he was greatly successful in handling the counter-insurgency operations in that region.

Role in Bangladesh war:The Indian Army Chief, Field Marshal Manekshaw specially selected Shabeg Singh, then a brigadier, putting him in-charge of Delta Sector with headquarters at Aggartala. He was given the responsibility of planning, organizing and directing insurgency operations in the whole of Central and East Bangladesh. Under his command were placed all the Bangladesh officers that had deserted from the Pakistan Army. These included Col Osmani, as adviser, Maj Zia-Ur-Rehman and Mohammad Mustaq. Zia Ur Rehman later became the President of Bangladesh while Mustaq Mohammed became Bangladesh army chief.
The Indian Govt. did not want the world to know that the Indian Army was training and directing the Bengali insurgents so all activities were very secret. Shabeg was so thoroughly involved in these clandestine operations that for five months from December 70 to April 71, his family had no news about his whereabouts. They believed he was till in Nagaland and wondered why he did not write because he had always been regular in writing home to his wife. In April 1970, the first letter was received from the Civilian address of a Merchant shop in Aggartala and his name was written as S. Baigh, such was the nature of secrecy maintained of the Army's involvement in the insurgency movement. The wife was quite confused and the family wondered what was going on because the letter was very brief and just said, "don't worry I am ok.”
Meanwhile as the Mukti Bahini got bolder, the Pak Army in the East began to grow demoralized due to the onslaught. It got so widely dispersed in trying to contain the 'Mukti Bahini' that when the Indian Army launched its operations in Nov. 1971 they were able to walk through to Dacca, virtually unopposed.
The Indian government promoted Shaheg Singh to the post of Major General and awarded him the Param Vashist Sewa Medal in recognition of his services. He had earlier been awarded the Ati Vashist Sewa Medal also.

Reasons why He started supporting Bhindrawale:
1.He was made General Officer in Command of MP Bihar and Orissa. The Jaya Pyakash Narayan movement had started during 1972-73 and became a serious threat to the Indira Gandhi Govt. The Police were sympathetic with JP and his followers, so the Government decided to use the Army. Gen Shabeg was asked to arrest JP and take some harsh measure against his followers but he refused saying this was not his job.
The result was that the Congress Govt. later instituted a CBI inquiry to harass him on cooked-up charges and he was out posted of the area. After the Indo-Pak war, all the Pakistani POWs were under his jurisdiction and senior General Staff were kept at Jabalpur that was also the HQs of MP.Bihar and Orissa area. Due to jealousy of certain senior army officers, he was not given the command of a Division, which was a move of the Army for denying him promotion. Here was a field commander with so much war experience-denied command of a combat formation. Why so? Only to do deny him promotion when his name came up.
2.While he was posted as GOC of the UP Area HQs in whose jurisdiction the Kumaon Regimental Center is placed, it was found that the commander of the Kumaon Military Farm had given a large sum money to the Chief, Gen Raina, who was himself from the same regiment. A court of inquiry discovered that General Raina (a Kashmiri Brahmin), Army received over two hundred thousand rupees from the Kumaon farm to meet expenses for his daughter's marriage.
When this information was brought to the notice of the General Office Commanding, Shabeg Singh; he told Gen Raina about the findings of the Court of Inquiry and requested the chief to return the amount as the Military farm of the Kumaon Regt was already running a loss. The result was that Gen Shabeg was promptly posted out of this indiscretion and the inquiry hushed up.
3.The forthwith posting was an unprecedented action because peacetime postings had never been conducted on such an emergency basis. Soon after that the Army instituted a court of inquiry against Gen. Shabeg Singh which dragged on for one year till the date of his retirement on May, 1 1976. The main charge against the General was that he had accepted a plaque valued at Rs 2500 as a gift on his posting out of the Jabalpur area HQs. -Even though a similar present had been given to his predecessor and it had been common for senior officers to accept such gifts. However, in the case of Gen. Shabeg it suddenly became an offense. Some other flimsy charges were also leveled against the General a charge was brought against the lands associated with his official residence to be used for cultivation and another permitting resale of goods purchased in the area HQ's Canteen. These practices had been going on long before the Gen. had taken command of the area in 1972.
4.That the Indian Government, in concert with the Army Chief, was on a witch hunt became perfectly clear, when one day prior to Gen. Shabeg's retirement, on April 30, 1976 the hero of 'Mukti Bahini', a highly decorated general with both the PVSM and AVSM, one who had been actively involved in every operation the Indian Army had fought since his joining the service and who had spent the major portion of his life in field areas far from his family—sacrifycing time with his wife and children, was suddenly dismissed from the Army
5.His brother, who was progressive and a succesful farmer and an active political worker in the Terrai (state of UP in North India) at Bazpur became the first victim of the Government's oppression on the General's family. The local Congress leader along with the police connived to finish him and he was killed by the Congress leader in 1978. The same congressman has ever since been terrifying the Sikhs in that area.
6.he general and his family members were harassed, the CBI tried to implicate the general in a case of alleged misappropriation of wealth and dragged on the case till 1983 Dec., to embarrass and harass him. Eventually the case fell through due to its flimsiness . For five years he had to bear with this govt. sponsored harassment only because he had opted to politics and not taken repressive means against Jaya Prakash Narain's movement a few years earlier.
7.Gen Shabeg Singh was very active during the Akali's peaceful agitation against Government policies of "seeing Sikhs as terrorists" and "river waters and transfer of Chandigarh to Punjab" of 1980 to 84. He courted arrest a number of times and won the hearts of the agitationist who saw that here was one leader who did not accept any preferential treatment in prison.During the periods when he was out of jail he spent a major portion of his time in the village at Khiala where his mother lived He did not care for the old age comforts that he had planned for by constructing a comfortable house at Dehra Dun. His wife too came to stay in the village where he spent most of the time. This was inspite of her ill health due to a defective kidney and hypertension and the neglect of their house at Dehra Dun. Punjab had become a leaderless state in 1982- or perhaps there were two many leaders. The people of Punjab were confused. There was Gurcharan Singh Tohra, Parkash Singh Badal, Sant Longowal, Jagdev Singh Talwandi and a host of other big and small leaders. But everyone was suspect in the eyes of the people thanks to the Govt. propaganda and machination of Congress led by Gandhi.
 
.
i have seen some posts in forum labeling shahbeg singh as a traitor..so thought to post the story of the other side of the coin....please keep the discussion civil and dont bring bluestar ..or demand of khalistan or questioning the sikh loyality in the thread
 
.
If this is true it is disgusting but not that surprising- the Indian armed forces remain impresivly apolitical and self-admittedly at the will of the govt, so these incidents are bound to happen - the armed forces are the punch bag the political scum like to beat.
 
. . .
i have seen some posts in forum labeling shahbeg singh as a traitor..so thought to post the story of the other side of the coin....please keep the discussion civil and dont bring bluestar ..or demand of khalistan or questioning the sikh loyality in the thread

Thank for digging this out. I always read about Shabeg being a great soldier and his unceremonious exit was always perplexing. Even Brar in his book on 1984 tried to discredit Shabegh as a man with a dubious past. I am glad the other side of the story is talked about too.
 
. .
Thanks for sharing this.

The man played an important role in my country's history, I just can't ignore him.

It is a shame that the great general had to be treated that way in the end. All because of jealousy.

Maj. General Shabeg Singh helped my country to freedom. And he was a damn fine and a daring warrior. Acted like his rank. Mark of a true general.

:police: *salutes* :police:
 
. .
1.Delta Sec Comdr Sabegh Gingh was a legend and hero to the thousands of Mukti Bahini youth he had trained and organized with the help of Maj Khaled Musharraf, Comdr Sector 2 and Capt Hyder, an SSG officer. BD shall always remember this great soldier.

2. Adding to his biography, I would like to mention that he was very much a blue eyed favorite of Gen Arora. Even during the 71 War others had become jealous of him. It was so clear to see. Sabegh Singh was unconventional, different and quiet. Most of the time he stayed away from the crowd of officers.
 
. .
Sorry, GoI does not like dissent in the defence forces. You are not allowed to point fingers at civilian authority, you cannot express your political views, you cannot disagree to direct order.
You can always advice and express your opinion in private to govt.
He is not the only guy dismissed, I remember BJP govt dismissing the then Navy chief, because he openly criticized defence minister.

Moral of the story: Dont mess with civilian govt when you are in forces, you will be kicked out, no matter who you are. If you want to do something else, resign from forces first.
 
. .
So sad a hero like this of our country to be treated like this.

Garry i thank you for sharing this info with us.
 
.
I knew it, but no one would believe it, here is the proof, HE WAS NOT A TRAITOR.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom