Who are you ! Bangladeshi or Bangali ?

[Pakistani E]

In London, you're all Bengizz. Doesn't matter Bangladeshi or Bengali.

 

[Hasan89]

Neither...Alhamdulillah

No one asked you. Don’t butt in. Take the hint. We don’t care about you. Jheez. Besharam Pks!

Well,

Am a Bangladeshi origin, then bengali race. British-Bangladeshi. And proud.

 

[VikingRaider]

That is Bangla not Bangali. dude. !!!!

Bangali means symply who speaks in Bengali/Bangla language.
So I am a Bengali speaker, so indeed I am bangali.
On the other hand I am Bangladeshi as my country is bangladesh .
There are urdu speaking Bangladeshis too ( bihari), hill peoples are Bangladeshi too, just language is different.
Ps: But if you are trying to impose Khaleda-Hasina Theory about Bangladeshi and Bangali , then I am out, I don't have slightest interest.
@M.R.9

 

[Hasan89]

In London, you're all Bengizz. Doesn't matter Bangladeshi or Bengali.

What’s bengiz?
The white men didnt call bengalis bengiz. It did call Pakistanis as Pak!s! And it stuck forever. So don’t try inviting new term for bengalis. No such thing as bengiz. We don’t wanna nickname like you have, ‘pak!s’

 

[Pakistani E]

What’s bengiz?
The white men didnt call bengalis bengiz. It did call Pakistanis as Pak!s! And it stuck forever. So don’t try inviting new term for bengalis. No such thing as bengiz. We don’t wanna nickname like you have, ‘pak!s’

I have much bengali friends. They call each other Bengiz. Where do you live?

 

[war&peace]

No one asked you. Don’t butt in. Take the hint. We don’t care about you. Jheez. Besharam Pks!
.

GTFOH..

 

[Pakistani E]

The white men didnt call bengalis bengiz. It did call Pakistanis as Pak!s!

The white men doesn't call Pakis to the face of any ****. They say it sitting behind their computer screen, just like you.

 

[django]

Would you tell me please , Gangladesh , is a new country ? In the era of 2018 ? However - I dont believe in nationalism concept as well. :/

BTW- how are you HOpe you forgot me. It's Natural. ha ha ha

 

[Anubis]

Wrong- IF ppl needs to follow ethnicity, they have no need Nationality . Both r different-

Is that even meant to be a sentence?

 

[Hakikat ve Hikmet]

As per the High Caste Hindu folks in Bengal, being born in Bengal and speaking Bengali language don't automatically make you a Bengali!!! You have to have the following additional characteristics to be considered as a Bengali in their book (Inside Bangladesh today; an eye-witness account by Basant Chatterjee, New Delhi, S. Chand, 1973):

• You have to be a High Caste Hindu
• You need to be literate in Bengali, Sanskrit etc.
• Can't work in the fields (e.g., farmer, craftsman, fisherman etc.)
• Need to own some lands

Hence, the Muslims in Bengal are by definition opted out!!! It's no wonder that Tagore, the Nobel Laureate Bengali poet and novelist, didn't have a single Muslim character from Bengal in his tons of literary works!!! When asked, his reply was simple: I don't know anything about the Muslims in Bengal!!! Interestingly, Tagores were one of the greatest landlords of Bengal, and 90% of their subjects were Muslims!!! BD Muslims were such an underclass in the British India under the Permanent Settlement!!! The creation of Pak let them live like a human being again!!!! No wonder they were first to backstab Pak, and that too on the basis of the Bengali nationalism!!!! What an irony of fate....

 

[RaGotimaar]

As per the High Caste Hindu folks in Bengal, being born in Bengal and speaking Bengali language don't automatically make you a Bengali!!! You have to have the following additional characteristics to be considered as a Bengali in their book (Inside Bangladesh today; an eye-witness account by Basant Chatterjee, New Delhi, S. Chand, 1973):

• You have to be a High Caste Hindu
• You need to be literate in Bengali, Sanskrit etc.
• Can't work in the fields (e.g., farmer, craftsman, fisherman etc.)
• Need to own some lands

Hence, the Muslims in Bengal are by definition opted out!!! It's no wonder that Tagore, the Nobel Laureate Bengali poet and novelist, didn't have a single Muslim character from Bengal in his tons of literary works!!! When asked, his reply was simple: I don't know anything about the Muslims in Bengal!!! Interestingly, Tagores were one of the greatest landlords of Bengal, and 90% of their subjects were Muslims!!! BD Muslims were such an underclass in the British India under the Permanent Settlement!!! The creation of Pak let them live like a human being again!!!! No wonder they were first to backstab Pak, and that too on the basis of the Bengali nationalism!!!! What an irony of fate....

Great fiction. Your imagination is great.

You only need to like rice and fish to be a bengali or Bangla.

 

[Kandari-Hushiyaar]

!st of all. many So- called intellectual s Try to mess it up -

The Question is Are you Bangladeshi or Banglai ?

I don't believe in Nationalism Concept . However - both has 2 formats -

I am Bangladeshi Bengali. Bangladeshi is my nationality and Bengali is my ethnicity : these two aren't comparable.

 

[RaGotimaar]

I am Bangladeshi Bengali. Bangladeshi is my nationality and Bengali is my ethnicity : these two aren't comparable.

Itna bang bang. Khuda ka kauf rakho

 

[M.R.9]

In London, you're all Bengizz. Doesn't matter Bangladeshi or Bengali.

Do u think by doing Insult a man ever win a property ?

Bangali means symply who speaks in Bengali/Bangla language.
So I am a Bengali speaker, so indeed I am bangali.
On the other hand I am Bangladeshi as my country is bangladesh .
There are urdu speakers Bangladeshis too ( bihari), hill peoples are Bangladeshi too . Language is different.
Ps: But if you are trying to impose Khaleda-Hasina Theory about Bangladeshi and Bangali , then I am out, I haven't slightest interest.

Nope. Again Error dude-

Thoose who speak in Bangla , why they will be bangali ? And if they are Bangali, then the nationaly already divided into 2 parts. u dont understand that !! Customs or language or else just a part of a citizenship area.

BAngali means what i know that very very will. I will tell that in the end of the conversion.

Nope Khaleda - Hasina thory is just a shit to me. BCz BNP and BAL both does blv on the same concept what ur talking about .

 

[Homo Sapiens]

As per the High Caste Hindu folks in Bengal, being born in Bengal and speaking Bengali language don't automatically make you a Bengali!!! You have to have the following additional characteristics to be considered as a Bengali in their book (Inside Bangladesh today; an eye-witness account by Basant Chatterjee, New Delhi, S. Chand, 1973):

• You have to be a High Caste Hindu
• You need to be literate in Bengali, Sanskrit etc.
• Can't work in the fields (e.g., farmer, craftsman, fisherman etc.)
• Need to own some lands

Hence, the Muslims in Bengal are by definition opted out!!! It's no wonder that Tagore, the Nobel Laureate Bengali poet and novelist, didn't have a single Muslim character from Bengal in his tons of literary works!!! When asked, his reply was simple: I don't know anything about the Muslims in Bengal!!! Interestingly, Tagores were one of the greatest landlords of Bengal, and 90% of their subjects were Muslims!!! BD Muslims were such an underclass in the British India under the Permanent Settlement!!! The creation of Pak let them live like a human being again!!!! No wonder they were first to backstab Pak, and that too on the basis of the Bengali nationalism!!!! What an irony of fate....

Sometimes it amaze me seeing your fairly deep knowledge about Bangladesh. Your account on Tagore and other caste Hindu attitude are mostly true. But making pakistan was a wrong choice for us. It would have been much much better if a separate muslim country was founded instead of East Pakistan in 1947.

Jinnah and other top Urdu speaking Muslim League leadership in that time considered Bengali muslim leaders as a threat to their powerhold. There was an underline faultline even before forming Pakistan between Bengali and North western muslim league leadership. Jinnah was always uneasy with Bengali muslim league leaders. So he surrounded himself with the people from his part of the world. Hindustani, Punjabi etc and sidelined Bengali leaders. That leadership always overlooked the interest of Muslim Bengal during the bargaining of Partition. The end result of partition was, East Bengal was only province became Pakistan which came without it's capital city or any significant urban center. West Pakistani based muslim league leadership dreaded Calcutta being part of East Bengal. So they happily relinquished claim over the city for the bargaining of Lahore. This is just one example of what happen when your 'leadership' do not represent your interest with the bargaining with foreign power.