When Afghans Look to Border With Pakistan, They Don’t See a Fixed Line

[Sugarcane]

Go to afghanistan and tell them that your country is our fifth province, they would definitely skin you alive....Afghan huriat-pasand aur azad log hain , mahkomi may rehna pasand nai kate.

Yup - we have seen how much azad Karzai is, even his name ....

 

[Don Jaguar]

Go to afghanistan and tell them that your country is our fifth province, they would definitely skin you alive....Afghan huriat-pasand aur azad log hain , mahkomi may rehna pasand nai kate.

Mahkoom kon bana raha hai bhai ko?

Hum tu bhai charay ki baat ker rahay hain.

 

[Pakistanisage]

The Pukhtoon areas in Afghanistan belong to Pakistani Khyber-Pakhtoonkhwa Province.......

We want them back.......

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

Mahkoom kon bana raha hai bhai ko?

Hum tu bhai charay ki baat ker rahay hain.

Ye fifth province ki baat afghano ko gaali ki tara lagti he....ahmed aur sher malang se poch lu.

The Pukhtoon areas in Afghanistan belong to Pakistani Khyber-Pakhtoonkhwa Province.......

We want them back.......

What about sistan-balochistan province of Iran?

 

[FaujHistorian]

Ye fifth province ki baat afghano ko gaali ki tara lagti he....ahmed aur sher malang se poch lu.
?

MDL Yara, Not sure why you posted this?

Many of your posts show that you are patriotic Pakistani and a proud Pashtun.

The problem with this argument "5th province talk and Afghanistanis" is like the story of old Mullah, his young son, and their donkey.

Afghanistanis and Pakistanis have shared border, that both should respect. However if we see this constant mud-slinging by Afghanistanis and their Indian pithus (bi-aaa-chis) what should we do then?

They respect our border, we respect theirs. Is it too hard to understand?


However the same Sher and same Malang come on Pakistani boards and boast about nullifying Pakistani border. Haven't you seen this?

So if they can say such things, we too can get tired of defending, and simply go along. Sure nullify the border and make Afghanistan as our 5th province.

So please be fair and do not turn this discussion into the Mullah-son-donkey story. Please!

What about sistan-balochistan province of Iran?

If Iranians come on this board and talk about grabbing our Balochistan, then yes, we'll say the same thing about Seestan too. But so far Iranians are a bit more smarter than Afghanistanis.


peace

 

[wakapdf]

Time to include Afghanistan as new province of Pakistan and focus on occupying parts of land on our Eastern front

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

MDL Yara, Not sure why you posted this?

Many of your posts show that you are patriotic Pakistani and a proud Pashtun.

The problem with this argument "5th province talk and Afghanistanis" is like the story of old Mullah, his young son, and their donkey.

Afghanistanis and Pakistanis have shared border, that both should respect. However if we see this constant mud-slinging by Afghanistanis and their Indian pithus (bi-aaa-chis) what should we do then?

They respect our border, we respect theirs. Is it too hard to understand?


However the same Sher and same Malang come on Pakistani boards and boast about nullifying Pakistani border. Haven't you seen this?

So if they can say such things, we too can get tired of defending, and simply go along. Sure nullify the border and make Afghanistan as our 5th province.

So please be fair and do not turn this discussion into the Mullah-son-donkey story. Please!




If Iranians come on this board and talk about grabbing our Balochistan, then yes, we'll say the same thing about Seestan too. But so far Iranians are a bit more smarter than Afghanistanis.


peace

Claiming Afghanistan as fifth province of pakistan reflects arrogance......jaise taqat ka nasha sar pey charha ho.......tit for tat doesnt fit in Afghanistan case, islam k naam par banay wala pakistan agar religous afghans par badmashi karega tu nazria-e-pakistan hi nullify ho gaya.....afghano k khilaf jihad bi nahi kar sakte kyun k afghan KPK aur FATa ko maang kar koi ghair-islami kaam bi nahi kar rahe.....
This durand issue should be settled, but pakistan is not serious and doesnt consider it even an issue, if it is an international border then why it is so porous?....

MDL Yara, Not sure why you posted this?

Many of your posts show that you are patriotic Pakistani and a proud Pashtun.

The problem with this argument "5th province talk and Afghanistanis" is like the story of old Mullah, his young son, and their donkey.

Afghanistanis and Pakistanis have shared border, that both should respect. However if we see this constant mud-slinging by Afghanistanis and their Indian pithus (bi-aaa-chis) what should we do then?

They respect our border, we respect theirs. Is it too hard to understand?


However the same Sher and same Malang come on Pakistani boards and boast about nullifying Pakistani border. Haven't you seen this?

So if they can say such things, we too can get tired of defending, and simply go along. Sure nullify the border and make Afghanistan as our 5th province.

So please be fair and do not turn this discussion into the Mullah-son-donkey story. Please!




If Iranians come on this board and talk about grabbing our Balochistan, then yes, we'll say the same thing about Seestan too. But so far Iranians are a bit more smarter than Afghanistanis.


peace

Claiming Afghanistan as fifth province of pakistan reflects arrogance......jaise taqat ka nasha sar pey charha ho.......tit for tat doesnt fit in Afghanistan case, islam k naam par banay wala pakistan agar religous afghans par badmashi karega tu nazria-e-pakistan hi nullify ho gaya.....afghano k khilaf jihad bi nahi kar sakte kyun k afghan KPK aur FATa ko maang kar koi ghair-islami kaam bi nahi kar rahe.....
This durand issue should be settled, but pakistan is not serious and doesnt consider it even an issue, if it is an international border then why it is so porous?....

 

[wakapdf]

Why are you limiting Nazria-e-Pakistan to Afghanistan and Pakistan? Expand it to include India as well. Afghano kay khilaf jihad nahi kar sakte lekin Hindustan/India kay khilaaf to jihad kar sakte hain na. Chalo jihad kay hi bahane Afghani humare saath ho jaaen gay

P.s. Afghanistan is part of Pakistan

 

[FaujHistorian]

....
This durand issue should be settled, but pakistan is not serious and doesnt consider it even an issue, if it is an international border then why it is so porous?....

..

Any border between two countries is "shared" responsibility. Afghanistanis and Pakistanis can agree on set of rules.

What are those rules?

Like any international border, you have to have some ID to cross the border.

Generally it is a passport.

But it can also be National ID card, or a driver's license.

In this age of computers and biometrics, people can use other methods too.

With such ID system, Pakistanis and Afghanistanis can come and go across the border.

So anyone who doesn't want Pakistan to make the 5th province out of Afghanistan, should seriously think about ID system.


The same ID system means the border is no longer porous but instead it is "managed".

peace

 

[wakapdf]

^fully agree

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

Because its some how a reflection .

yahan hansi mazak ke liye join kia he?

 

[darkinsky]

Ye fifth province ki baat afghano ko gaali ki tara lagti he....ahmed aur sher malang se poch lu.

fifth province nahi, a colony

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

fifth province nahi, a colony

Afghanistan was never colonized like UP, delhi and other urdu speaking areas

 

[SHAMK9]

Time to include Afghanistan as new province of Pakistan and focus on occupying parts of land on our Eastern front

Hell to the no, just keep FATA safe and maintain border there, why would you want Afghanistan to be part of Pakistan and want more afghans moving to lahore, islamabad, karachi and other cities?

 

[snakeeagle]

they considered kpk as thier part of country,even zalme kalel dad want back from landi kotil to attack,only one thing is in thier way is duard line.