What are the similarities/differences of Bengali peoples in Bangladesh vs India

[TopCat]

Which hurt me more is Murshidabad and Malda isnt within our boundary. WTF. Whole Bengal should come under our flag based on Bengali secularism agenda. But by Muslim Bengali agenda Malda and Murshidabad are our legitimate area by long sttlements and structures.

WBengalis traded Khulna for Murshidabad to have a contiguous landmass connecting north bengal for West Bengal as a state to srurvive.

 

[Joe Shearer]

I think you couldnt grasp the meaning of my post. Lets clear myself.


While West Bengal's symbol of transportation is: Hand pulled Rickshaws, Ambassador Taxis, Trum
There Bangladesh's symbol is: Cycle Rickshaw
So there are some differences between the two people relating this lifestyle.


While West Bengal was created on the basis of religion, Bangladesh was created on the basis of nationalism.
So Durga is the symbol of joy and unity of West Bengal. Bangladeshis also do their respective religious tasks but their national pride and symbol is Shaheed Minar, Sriti Shoudho, Pohela Boishakh.

The op also strike me by calling us Bengalis non martial race which was imposed on us by the British.
So I showed the pics that we reclaimed our martial status back. While the West Bengalis couldnt. Now some West Bengalis can say stuffs like they are better integrated in other units of IA but my point is the Bengal force which was scrapped by the British, independent India never revoked that decision. Yes Bangladeshis are proud on this that they operate their own independent ethnic Army and Indian Bengali mindset is different that whole IA is theirs.




I had only wear Lungi once or twice. Its a thing of working class, older generation and Villege comfort. While Dhoti is used in festivals like puja and Hindu weddings. Bangladeshis wear panjabi pajama in namaj and Muslim weddings.



You are confused, it seems. They are very conscious of their religious identity.
Bangladeshi readers read all the writers, dont judge by one's religious identity. They judge its readable or not.
While west Bnegal readers dont like to read Muslim Bengali stuffs. When they see Muslim terms like Amma, Fupu, Namaj strange reaction strikes them.. Its confirmed by one of their writer Samaresh Mojumder, that compared to Bangladeshi readers West Bengali readers are much more fundamentalist.

“আমাদের বই যখন বাংলাদেশের পাঠকরা হাতে পান, তখন তারা বিচার করেন না- এটা কোন ধর্মের লেখক। তারা বিচার করেন এটা পাঠযোগ্য কিনা, কাহিনী তার ভালো লাগছে কি না, কিংবা পড়তে তার আরাম লাগছে কি না। কিন্তু বাংলাদেশের লেখকদের বই আমাদের পশ্চিমবঙ্গের হিন্দু পাঠকরা আম্মা, ফুপা, নামাজ এইশব্দগুলো যখন দেখতে পায়- তখন তাদের মধ্যে একটা অদ্ভুত প্রতিক্রিয়া তৈরি হয়। এবং এই প্রতিক্রিয়ার কারণেই বাংলাদেশের অনেক লেখকের বই এখানকার পাঠকদের কাছে পৌঁছে না। আমি পরিষ্কার করে বলছি, বাংলাদেশের পাঠকদের তুলনায় পশ্চিমবঙ্গের হিন্দু পাঠকরা অনেক বেশি মৌলবাদী।" সমরেশ মজুমদার

It would not be a hugely positive or constructive gesture to pull hairs with you and quibble about your points. Let us leave it at that, and approach our posts from a neutral point of view in future. As far as this is concerned, it is irrevocably ruined. To react to a post about the differences or similarities with a fierce and uncompromising catalogue of the causes of complaint, a charge-sheet, in short, will only cause further friction.

WBengalis traded Khulna for Murshidabad to have a contiguous landmass connecting north bengal for West Bengal as a state to srurvive.

Factually wrong. Look up the maps before 1956 and after 1956. Somebody quite different contributed to this.

 

[rongbaz]

If you consider music, you will find better musicians among Bangladeshi Bengalis. There is no better guitarist like AB, Komol or Sazzad in West Bengal, no better base-guitarist than Basebaba Sumon, no better drummer than Funty, Turjo or Tony in west bengal. I like only tuness of Fossils from only West Bengal Bands. I will appreciate opinions from neutral points of view.

 

[nForce]

If you consider music, you will find better musicians among Bangladeshi Bengalis. There is no better guitarist like AB, Komol or Sazzad in West Bengal, no better base-guitarist than Basebaba Sumon, no better drummer than Funty, Turjo or Tony in west bengal. I like only tuness of Fossils from only West Bengal Bands. I will appreciate opinions from neutral points of view.

How did you compare music ? What parameters? Tell me about it.

 

[BDforever]

How did you compare music ? What parameters? Tell me about it.

ok lets start westbengal and bangladeshi songs thread
bands, solo songs etc

 

[nForce]

ok lets start westbengal and bangladeshi songs thread
bands, solo songs etc

man.. you know ill love to.. and you also know people will ruin it.. I love music.. I don' t like people ruining that too..

 

[BDforever]

man.. you know ill love to.. and you also know people will ruin it.. I love music.. I don' t like people ruining that too..

i like music too, lets start it , no abuse will be tolerated in thread , ok ?

 

[nForce]

i like music too, lets start it , no abuse will be tolerated in thread , ok ?

agreed.. ill create a thread in member's club.. Bangla music only ?

Some other Bengali musicians too, ill add, perhaps, since , you know India it is.. so some Bengali artists work in other languages as well.

 

[BDforever]

agreed.. ill create a thread in member's club.. Bangla music only ?

no, "music from two bangals- West Bengal and Bangladesh (no abusive word)"
----- this will be title
this will draw large attention

agreed.. ill create a thread in member's club.. Bangla music only ?

Some other Bengali musicians too, ill add, perhaps, since , you know India it is.. so some Bengali artists work in other languages as well.

bro, leave it only in bangla

 

[nForce]

bro, leave it only in bangla

ok

 

[Joe Shearer]

Kolpona-ta darun! Bouncer-er chakri pawa jachhe?

 

[BDforever]

Kolpona-ta darun! Bouncer-er chakri pawa jachhe?

sure but free service lol

 

[bongbang]

If you consider music, you will find better musicians among Bangladeshi Bengalis. There is no better guitarist like AB, Komol or Sazzad in West Bengal, no better base-guitarist than Basebaba Sumon, no better drummer than Funty, Turjo or Tony in west bengal. I like only tuness of Fossils from only West Bengal Bands. I will appreciate opinions from neutral points of view.

And they dont have any rockstar like James

WBengalis traded Khulna for Murshidabad to have a contiguous landmass connecting north bengal for West Bengal as a state to srurvive.

Something could be done to take both Murshidabad and Khulna. Because part of my family and his total clan moved from Murshidabad to Khulna. Murshidabad any day better than Swamp land Khulna. Only interest in the sea.

 

[Joe Shearer]

sure but free service lol

 

[asad71]

Which hurt me more is Murshidabad and Malda isnt within our boundary. WTF. Whole Bengal should come under our flag based on Bengali secularism agenda. But by Muslim Bengali agenda Malda and Murshidabad are our legitimate area by long sttlements and structures.

Actually our objective is to reclaim that which was taken from us in 1757. For this we need to wait for the inevitable weakening of the Brahmonic hold over Delhi.