We Are All Harappans

[Hamza913]

ASI movement happened from the west to east, then south

Prior or post IVC?

 

[Water Car Engineer]

Prior or post IVC?

Both. Decline of civilization and climate problems, then incursion from ANI groups surely hastened the movement from west to east, south. ANI markers also did the same movement, however, in a quicker pace being more mobile pastoralist.

 

[Icewolf]

What is this “culture of the Indus”?
Can you be more specific about what similarities in culture exist between the modern day Pakistani and the people of the IVC? Any rituals, festivals, language that was only privy to the people of the IVC and now apparently to the region of Pakistan only that would help us understand what is being stolen or the validity of your “Harappan” identity?

Another nice try kiddo. IVC is thousands of years old dumbass. How is the culture gonna be the same thousands of years old. Dumbass do you think Egyptian people still build pyramids and worship cat gods? Do you think Scandinavians still pillage villages and build Viking boats? Do you think Mexicans still build Aztec and Incan temples? Stupid dumbass Shudra. Learn some logic and reasoning I know your Dasyu mind cannot comprehend simple logic.

 

[Icewolf]

ASI didnt live everywhere at the time, this was a specific mix that happened in the border region between two completely different groups ME farmers and S. Asian hunter gathers. Subcontinent wasnt populated to that extent, let alone civilized. ASI movement happened from the west to east, then south - no different to ANI. Yes, there is relation between those groups outside Pak and the people populating Indus vally civ.

This mixture of the two groups started from there.

Listen you dumbass Dasyu. We don’t care about your Dravidian history . We have our own history. All we want is that you stop claiming our history as your own and only focus on your history how ever hard it may be for you. We know your people were cockroach munching, cow piss drinking, jungle savages before our ancestors (Aryans) civilized you. But still no need to steal our history for your own.

 

[Hamza913]

Both. Decline of civilization and climate problems, then incursion from ANI groups surely hastened the movement from west to east, south. ANI markers also did the same movement, however, in a quicker pace being more mobile pastoralist.

Any evidence that a major movement of ASI people from Indus Valley Civilisation further into Hindustan occurred?

 

[Peshwa]

Another nice try kiddo. IVC is thousands of years old dumbass. How is the culture gonna be the same thousands of years old. Dumbass do you think Egyptian people still build pyramids and worship cat gods? Do you think Scandinavians still pillage villages and build Viking boats? Do you think Mexicans still build Aztec and Incan temples? Stupid dumbass Shudra. Learn some logic and reasoning I know your Dasyu mind cannot comprehend simple logic.

Well you’re the one who claimed we were “stealing Indus culture” from Pakistan, so why don’t you tell us what culture we stole (since you seem to know about it) and explain it instead of throwing a childish tantrum?

Besides it’s funny you mention Egypt and the Vikings, unlike these civilizations which were continuous, you didn’t even know the IVC existed until the British came up and excavated it for you.
The Egyptians knew their history and, hence can claim lineage to that civilization as descendents.
You didint even know IVC existed. What claim are you going to draw to ancestry when you have zero clue such a civilization even graced the land, let alone show any signs of continuity in culture, language, script, religion?

You want to call it co-terminous Pakistan, go ahead, but please don’t fool us with some ancestry bullshit. You have no proof of it, nor any exists to show links between the IVC people (read DNA) and that of modern day Pakistanis. Your claims are the same as that of a renter living in a heritage building claiming to be nobility because you somehow reside in the building you had nothing to do in the construction of, nor Knew the people who built it. It’s quite laughable to say the least.

Now please save your BS for the simple minded sheep from your side of the border.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

Saying all this and yet keeping Tipu Sultan as your DP shows everything.

Indians are envious for our culture, languages, history, food, dress, and looks.

No Pakistani will ever claim to be Indian, but every Indian claims to be Pakistani. Lol.

 

[Peshwa]

Saying all this and yet keeping Tipu Sultan as your DP shows everything.

Indians are envious for our culture, languages, history, food, dress, and looks.

No Pakistani will ever claim to be Indian, but every Indian claims to be Pakistani. Lol.

If you’re directing this towards me, I’ll have you know that my DP is that of Peshwa Baji Rao. A famous general in Maratha history.

The rest of your post is quite funny too. Do you actually believe this stuff?

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

If you’re directing this towards me, I’ll have you know that my DP is that of Peshwa Baji Rao. A famous general in Maratha history.

The rest of your post is quite funny too. Do you actually believe this stuff?

Maratha, yes, the arsonists and rapist looters who preyed on defenseless civilians. Very famous history.

 

[padamchen]

Do you actually believe this stuff?

Psilocybin.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Mamluk]

Besides it’s funny you mention Egypt and the Vikings, unlike these civilizations which were continuous,

 

[Icewolf]

Well you’re the one who claimed we were “stealing Indus culture” from Pakistan, so why don’t you tell us what culture we stole (since you seem to know about it) and explain it instead of throwing a childish tantrum?

Besides it’s funny you mention Egypt and the Vikings, unlike these civilizations which were continuous, you didn’t even know the IVC existed until the British came up and excavated it for you.
The Egyptians knew their history and, hence can claim lineage to that civilization as descendents.
You didint even know IVC existed. What claim are you going to draw to ancestry when you have zero clue such a civilization even graced the land, let alone show any signs of continuity in culture, language, script, religion?

You want to call it co-terminous Pakistan, go ahead, but please don’t fool us with some ancestry bullshit. You have no proof of it, nor any exists to show links between the IVC people (read DNA) and that of modern day Pakistanis. Your claims are the same as that of a renter living in a heritage building claiming to be nobility because you somehow reside in the building you had nothing to do in the construction of, nor Knew the people who built it. It’s quite laughable to say the least.

Now please save your BS for the simple minded sheep from your side of the border.

Oh my lord you are so damn stupid.


Get this through your thick skull.

You think the average Egyptian knew exactly what was in the pyramids in the 1900s? (Same era IVC was discovered)
Of course they knew there was a civilization there because of the gigantic pyramids but doesn’t mean they fully understood . Hell even know historians don’t fully understand Ancient Egyptian history and culture.

Civilizations die and fall, and there are NUMEROUS civilizations that historians STILL have not discovered. Doesn’t mean they never existed and doesn’t mean they aren’t part of that nations history.

Basically, with your retarded logic you’re telling me that a Mexican farmer cannot claim Aztec civilization because he did not know it ever existed. You do know there are SOME people who don’t know about these civilizations and the history that accompanied them EVEN if it’s in their backyard right? It’s a historians JOB to educate them. You’re telling me that that Mexican farmer cannot claim his Aztec civilization as his because he doesn’t know it.
You do realize civilizations change very FREQUENTLY.


—————-


Now we got another retarded straw mans arguement. Pakistanis can’t claim IVC because there is no genetic evidence linking IVC people and modern day Pakistanis? What the hell is wrong with you?
You do realize that this region has remained pretty much the same genetically since the Aryan invasion right?

Let me make another straw mans argument then for you as well. Since there is NO evidence proving that Pakistanis are NOT linked to IVC people, your ARGUMENT IS MOOT. That’s what you call a straw mans argument. You need logical and critical thinking skills to understand this.



Oh wait I know where this heading. I guess the entire IVC civilization ancestors are your cockroach munching, street shitting, women raping kind right?

 

[newb3e]

we all are not harapan but you indians are surely chotia!

 

[my2cents]

we all are not harapan but you indians are surely chotia!

Why can't we agree that IVC is our shared history. There are more sites being found in India as we speak. Why are you guys so insecure about IVC being a shared history?

 

[newb3e]

Why can't we agree that IVC is our shared history. There are more sites being found in India as we speak. Why are you guys so insecure about IVC being a shared history?

we share nothing with you baboon indiots!