vi-va
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2019
- Messages
- 6,475
- Reaction score
- 3
- Country
- Location
Vietnam's infrastructure is not good. Vietnam is labor-intensive industry export driven economy.Well....couple of counterpoints.
1. You may be partially right about the Philippines being not as industrialized than Vietnam, but their industrialization goes back a long way. They are very active in value-added assembly of electronics, high grade consumer products (SLR cameras and lenses for example), large shipbuilding sector and of course back-office business like Indians because of English skills.
2. Malaysia and Thailand got to being industrialized way before Vietnam did. Their backward integration in industrialization and also, dependence of internal consumer economy for growth is very high, they are at that next stage already and as a result have what is called a stagnancy in middle income growth. There are industrial park and metro rail development companies in Thailand that Bangladesh is currently cooperating with and Thai industrial parks are some of the most picturesque and well-designed industrial parks, exceeding US and EU standards in some cases. Ditto for Malaysia. There is no doubt that Thailand and Malaysia is no less industrialized than Vietnam, probably more. Growth has though slowed a little right now.
3. Industry from wealthier and better-developed economies in Asia and ASEAN (for example Korea, China, Japan and Taiwan) will always gravitate to lowest cost labor destinations in the region for value addition (assembly mostly) to save cost and offer a competitively priced and profitable product. This includes stitching of apparel, shoes and assembly of cellphones like Vietnam is doing right now.
4. The final point is, Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia have become high labor cost places for industrial assembly (Indonesia cost is a bit lower than the other two) - while Vietnam and Bangladesh both still claim low cost labor. I'd argue that Bangladesh labor costs are about half that of Vietnam for apparel and shoes, but the sunk FDI in Vietnam already means production will still take a while to get to Bangladesh. Bangladesh and Vietnam are vying nose-to-nose for top apparel exports to US right now. Last year it was Vietnam, this year we took back top spot again. When labor cost goes high in Vietnam, it will be in Thailand and Malaysia situation too.
There is no "we are the best" situation here - things can change in less than a year's time sourcing wise. The point is how long can you let foreigners exploit your low labor cost (lowest common denominator) until you offer skills and educated expertise which trumps that of EU and US and foreigners pay for that instead of dumb (and dumber) low cost labor?
That should be the ongoing thought for the future, not competing for lowest cost among ourselves as Asians, exploiting poor people and driving down labor costs for poor people lower, lower and lower - just so EU and US folks can have cheap clothes, cellphones and shoes.
Vietnam's economy has low glass ceiling due to 2 factors:
- Vietnam Investment accounted for 26.7 % of its Nominal GDP. Not good enough.
- Vietnam is aging