What's new

Vietnam Defence Forum

Beautiful training vessel of Imperial Japanese Navy in Vietnam

JS Setoyuki
JS_Setoyuki_ship.jpg


@Suika

Surprise visit to Tokyo

Chief of the General Staff of the Vietnamese People’s Army Phan Van Giang pays a special visit to Admiral Katsutoshi Kawano, Chief of Staff of the Japanese Army on March 4.

View attachment 545685

JS Setoyuki is an old ship, but is OK since she comes as a training ship :-)

She didn't come alone but went with JS Shimayuki as well. About 390 personnel from both ships. They arrived at Da Nang on March 6th for a stay and will leave on March 9th.
inVietnam.jpg

http://vovworld.vn/ja-JP/ニュース/日本の海上自衛隊の練習艦タナンに寄港-729486.vov

inVietnam2.jpg

 
.
Ok let's analyze words by words

The virtue signaling is strong here. Our human rights & everything else still better than yours. According to every parameter. So what that makes vietnam then?

"Every parameter"? You want to tell that to people in Ache and Papua right this moment? Consider what happen at those region right now, I dare say plenty of people there would disagree but I guess their opinion is irrelevant to you, right?

Want a single piece of proof that Vietnam is better than Indonesia? BLOOD. Count how many Indonesian got slaughtered by Indonesia military and see the result. You could search "every parameter" you could get but you would find nothing about Vietnam security force open fire with live munition and rubber bullet on our people. Tear gas is as far as we dare to go but Indonesia, you guys sure get trigger happy from time to time.

Of all people you guys seems to forget about how difficult guerilla warfare is. Also we can't use heavy artillery since east timor due to the civilian government restriction. FYI we're winning anyway so why brought this up? Seems kinda pointless.

Vietnamese (including me) know everything that need to be known about "guerilla warfare". Guess what? The performance of Indonesian army still look kind of S-H-I-T.

"Winning"? As i recall, you guys have been "winning" in Papua for no less than 30 years. Every once in a while? Indonesia like "Peace is within reach", "The final rebels have been exterminated", "We have won the heart and mind of people in Papua",... Forget my directness but that sound lamer and lamer every time.

And people in glass house shouldn't throw rock. The Vietnamese navy lost a naval skirmish in the 80s against chinese on speed boats. I think the you guys take the cake on incompetence.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnson_South_Reef_Skirmish

Vietnamese casualty:
- 64 killed
-11 wounded
-9 captured
-2 armed transporters sunk
-1 landing craft destroyed

China's:
-1 wounded. (Womp, womp)

let me remind you again the chinese was on speadboats.

Uh... sorry? I already tell you our soldier in that battle are pioneer with construction equipment, not front line troops with heavy weapon. With their sacrifice, we managed to secure our territory in the Spratly Island. Can't say the same about Indonesian soldiers that die in the 21st century in Papua as they keep dying and the situation remain unchanged.

Plus, that thing happen the 1980s which is the last time we lost troops in skirmishes. Comparing a 1980s skirmish that end long ago to ongoing insurrection? You sense of time sure is good. Indonesian noways? Your troops keep stocking the body bag again and again and again and again... When will the killing end? NEVER. Since the 21st century Indonesia army SUCKS compared to the 21st century Vietnam Army when it come to dealing with terrorists. We could even go through the list of terror attack of both countries to prove that at least.

Look we all know you don't fool anyone here. You don't give a damn about the plight of human rights or indonesian in general. Especially when vietnam is already a human right basket case.

The real reason you use the human right cards is because you lost an argument on the legality of vietnam fishing in our territory.

Why don't you just admit it. After all who are you trying to convince the vietnamese members here are more or less are just bunch of degenerates that couldn't care less about human rights especially. The indonesians don't care because they know you're faking it. Know your audience

Well you get at least one thing right there: WE. DON'T. GIVE. ONE. FCK . ABOUT INDONESIA

This is the Vietnam Military Thread and believe me when I say we are pretty mellow fellows. We rarely go out of our way to crash the thread of others because of something flare up in the SCS. Did you see us go ham on the Indonesian in the forum because you unleash live ammunition near our Coast Guard?

No, we think "S-H-I-T happen, let's the officials sort it out". But guess what, Indonesian like you bash into our thread, pump your chest and scream: "Check out the coward Vietnamese. We shoot your boats. IN. YOUR. FACE". As usual, Indonesian unleash the first shot and as if we Vietnamese will let thing go the way you please.

"Lost an argument": I haven't lost crap. You "uhuhuhu" friend with slow-developed brain turn tail before I get to the bottom of things with him. You, on the other hand, insist that you side of story is always right. That is not an argument. That is you telling me to accept your point view and submit myself to your logic. AS IF THAT COULD WORK!

"more or less are just bunch of degenerates": Right, degenerates that have to welcome Indonesia "friends" that pop out from nowhere and crash our thread. You want us to serve milk and cookie? Beside, being called "degenerates" by people from a country that lock people in the same cage with snake, prosecute people because of a song and beat up minority ethic seem pretty amusing.

"The Indonesians don't care": You guys don't care about human right in Indonesia because that would admit that you guys run a freaking terrific government against other minorities. Sadly, people look over that every now and then so guess what they see? A pile of S-H-I-T :)

We have an MPA designed for sub warfare & a better navy & airforce compared to yours. So really go ahead, shoot if you dare.

Better than the Vietnam military in every regard...except the ability to stop dying in front of rebels armed with decade old rifles, right? Man that is one hell of a feat for the almighty Indonesian army with all of their "MPA designed for sub warfare & a better navy & airforce". Gosh to say that the such a invincible got their *** kicked by Papua rebels would be a unthinkable....Wait, they did die to the Papua rebels :)

Now if you have your fill, kindly fck off. Create a fcking thread to brag about the superiority of Indonesian army against rebel and Vietnam fisherman. Our thread is not the place for you boast about what kind of dick Indonesian are.

Vietnam 9th Division recently receive a visit of the Indianian military delegation

img_20190308_214028_fdpx.jpg


img_20190308_213949_koln.jpg


img_20190308_214005_coqu.jpg
 
.
We have an MPA designed for sub warfare & a better navy & airforce compared to yours. So really go ahead, shoot if you dare.
Then sink our coast guard ships first if your navy has the guts. What is the use of sending warship,but dare not shoot the VN coast guard ships ??

Stupid guy like u love to talk big, show ppl here if ID army have any weapon can harm out Kilos first while it so clear that VN Kilos can attack any ID naval ports wt land attack misslie and sail back without any problem:cool:

? Man that is one hell of a feat for the almighty Indonesian army with all of their "MPA designed for sub warfare & a better navy & airforce". Gosh to say that the such a invincible got their *** kicked by Papua rebels would be a unthinkable....Wait, they did die to the Papua rebels :)

Now if you have your fill, kindly fck off. Create a fcking thread to brag about the superiority of Indonesian army against rebel and Vietnam fisherman. Our thread is not the place for you boast about what kind of dick Indonesian are.

Vietnam 9th Division recently receive a visit of the Indianian military delegation

img_20190308_214028_fdpx.jpg


img_20190308_213949_koln.jpg


img_20190308_214005_coqu.jpg
Good to have fun wt that barbarian, want an arm race wt VN ?? Then the barbarian need to buy 6 sub marine that have same power wt VN Kilos first :laugh:
 
.
Good to have fun wt that barbarian, want an arm race wt VN ?? Then the barbarian need to buy 6 sub marine that have same power wt VN Kilos first

They like show off their muscle to us while still could not take care of some tiny groups of rebels lol.
 
.
They like show off their muscle to us while still could not take care of some tiny groups of rebels lol.
While such a search would test the capabilities of even larger navies, it has exposed some of Indonesia’s weaknesses, such as problems with night-time and all-weather searches and a lack of equipment to conduct sophisticated aerial maritime surveillance, said Mr Collin Koh, an associate research fellow at the S Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore who studies the modernisation of South-east Asia’s navies.

The Indonesian Navy has 213 ships in total, including more than 70 patrol and coastal combatants, said Mr Brian Harding, director for East and South-east Asia at the Washington DC-based Center for American Progress, said in a World Politics Review interview published last month.

“However, the sum is less than its parts, with fewer than half of the vessels combat-ready and most not well integrated,” Mr Harding said

https://www.todayonline.com/world/asia/search-jet-exposes-indonesian-navys-limitations


more than half of ID warships cant fight in real Naval battle, the rest r not well integrated :laugh:
 
.
Just wait and see US keep spanking CN. Its so clear that US want CN collapse like Soviet, so US can loot all CN properties like in Qing time

You really think so?

What about all properties owned by Jack Ma?
 
.
Then sink our coast guard ships first if your navy has the guts. What is the use of sending warship,but dare not shoot the VN coast guard ships ??

Stupid guy like u love to talk big, show ppl here if ID army have any weapon can harm out Kilos first while it so clear that VN Kilos can attack any ID naval ports wt land attack misslie and sail back without any problem:cool:


Good to have fun wt that barbarian, want an arm race wt VN ?? Then the barbarian need to buy 6 sub marine that have same power wt VN Kilos first :laugh:

Indonesian army is sh1t. They are full of it.
 
.
Stupid guy like u love to talk big, show ppl here if ID army have any weapon can harm out Kilos first while it so clear that VN Kilos can attack any ID naval ports wt land attack misslie and sail back without any problem:cool:


Good to have fun wt that barbarian, want an arm race wt VN ?? Then the barbarian need to buy 6 sub marine that have same power wt VN Kilos first :laugh:

Oh boyy its nice to be back,
whats next?vietnamese bragging about 6 Kilo class sub (meanwhile indonesia now in final stage for another 3 sub =total 8 sub), scud missile ? Lol as if it can harm our big cities LoL, T90? Well we have 100 leopards against 64 T90s

Hoahemmmm whats next viet? Those T90 will not be much help when we cuaght and burn your fishing fleet hehehehe. Peace

When PH sent warship to arrest CN fishing boats in Scabourough , CN also sent her warships there and took the scarborough shoal from PH.

So, when ID send warship to VN-ID dispute zone, then VN sub marine Kilos also have the right to sink your warship. Our Kilos r just busy wt CN navy now, so your warships still not be sunk yet. No one will support ID when your warship is sunk in disputed zone, just like no one support PH when she lost Scaborough cos PH sent warship to threaten CN fishing boast first.

As I know, ID navy has No thing strong enough to attack VN sub marine Kilos.
Oh boyyyy im so excited for this hehehehehehehe, 6kilo subs against indonesian navy . Ok nice
 
.
Oh boyy its nice to be back,
whats next?vietnamese bragging about 6 Kilo class sub (meanwhile indonesia now in final stage for another 3 sub =total 8 sub), scud missile ? Lol as if it can harm our big cities LoL, T90? Well we have 100 leopards against 64 T90s

Hoahemmmm whats next viet? Those T90 will not be much help when we cuaght and burn your fishing fleet hehehehe. Peace
The Indonesian Navy has 213 ships in total, including more than 70 patrol and coastal combatants, said Mr Brian Harding, director for East and South-east Asia at the Washington DC-based Center for American Progress, said in a World Politics Review interview published last month.

“However, the sum is less than its parts, with fewer than half of the vessels combat-ready and most not well integrated,” Mr Harding said

https://www.todayonline.com/world/asia/search-jet-exposes-indonesian-navys-limitations

More than hafl of ID ships are junks, the rest r not well integrated. We just need coast guard ship to slam your warship. Sink our coast guard ,dare u ?? Kilos under sea bed are waiting for a good excuse to sink the usless barbarain ships :cool:
 
.
This is what happens with most nov
The Indonesian Navy has 213 ships in total, including more than 70 patrol and coastal combatants, said Mr Brian Harding, director for East and South-east Asia at the Washington DC-based Center for American Progress, said in a World Politics Review interview published last month.

“However, the sum is less than its parts, with fewer than half of the vessels combat-ready and most not well integrated,” Mr Harding said

https://www.todayonline.com/world/asia/search-jet-exposes-indonesian-navys-limitations

More than hafl of ID ships are junks, the rest r not well integrated. We just need coast guard ship to slam your warship. Sink our coast guard ,dare u ?? Kilos under sea bed are waiting for a good excuse to sink the usless barbarain ships : cool:
Oh yes baby we have so much junk, hehehee, dont forget that your vietnam navy still operate petya class boat hehehe and dont forget those second hand pohang corvette , osa class 1960s or so missile boat and most important ww2 hand me please LST. Very advanced much fear

This Kilo class submarine wet dream will vanish as fast as vietnam vanishing fishing fleet hehehe
 
.
This is what happens with most nov

Oh yes baby we have so much junk, hehehee, dont forget that your vietnam navy still operate petya class boat hehehe and dont forget those second hand pohang corvette , osa class 1960s or so missile boat and most important ww2 hand me please LST. Very advanced much fear
Yes.petya boats are junk, they cant harm "black hole" Kilos and ID junk ships also cant harm our Kilos too.

Everyone can see who will win when VN kilos attack ID port and sink ID junk ships.
 
.
Then sink our coast guard ships first if your navy has the guts. What is the use of sending warship,but dare not shoot the VN coast guard ships ??

Stupid guy like u love to talk big, show ppl here if ID army have any weapon can harm out Kilos first while it so clear that VN Kilos can attack any ID naval ports wt land attack misslie and sail back without any problem:cool:


Good to have fun wt that barbarian, want an arm race wt VN ?? Then the barbarian need to buy 6 sub marine that have same power wt VN Kilos first [emoji23]
Those kilos will be easily detectable if you decided to use it in the natuna sea where we actually have the equipment there to detect submarine & vietnamese surface fleets are not even close to our capability. You guys even slapped on a ground based gun on your ship. No need to tell you how effective they'll be in combat.
They like show off their muscle to us while still could not take care of some tiny groups of rebels lol.
There's only tiny groups of rebels left because the vast majority have already surrendered or defeated. You don't see acehnese rebels or moluccas rebels on the news anymore.

Papua is whole different animal. The terrains there make vietnamese jungle look like nothing. That's why we can comfortably said we can beat the vietnamese during the war if we because we have experience in papua.

& no we don't use the sticks as often when the carrots works betters.
154 OPM soldiers surrendered themselves during 2017.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/nasion...pm-serahkan-diri-hasil-pendekatan-humanis-tni

https://m.detik.com/news/berita/d-3...tni-mereka-lihat-pembangunan-papua-makin-maju

There's a lot more cases like this one where hundred upon hundreds of OPM soldiers defected & not just their grunts but their generals. Mathias Wenda surrendered himselves last january.
 
Last edited:
.
Yes.petya boats are junk, they cant harm "black hole" Kilos and ID junk ships also cant harm our Kilos too.

Everyone can see who will win when VN kilos attack ID port and sink ID junk ships.
Yup seeing is believing, which kinda didnt happen till now lolololololol, well i appreciate your war fantasy but I think the more sane vietnam commander up above knows better about using 6 kilo class "black hole " against indonesian Navy. They know with their limited vessels they cant do shit about those poor vietnamese thief near natuna very sorry for that,

The same exageration happened when russia decide to station s300 and s400 air defence system in syria, most junkies think that syria is safe from coalition and israeli bombardment ....which is not the case, just like any exagerated russian weaponry. Sorry
 
.
Yes.petya boats are junk, they cant harm "black hole" Kilos and ID junk ships also cant harm our Kilos too.

Everyone can see who will win when VN kilos attack ID port and sink ID junk ships.
A sub is not a wunderwaffe. There's limitations on submarine & most of them are fatal. For once submarine are slow as F! The moment a sub open fire you just give away your position.

Fun fact: kilos were tested in indonesian water & was found to be too big to be used here. So that pretty much limit where they can operate.

Also we have 4th U-boat Coming with the same capability of the Kilo. Does that count?
 
Last edited:
.
A sub is not a wunderwaffe. There's limitations on submarine & most of them are fatal. For once submarine are slow as F! The moment a sub open fire you just give away your position.

Fun fact: kilos were tested in indonesian water & was found to be too big to be used here. So that pretty much limit where they can operate.

Also we have 4th U-boat Coming with the same capability of the Kilo. Does that count?
Can you detect VN submarine’s position if 300 km away? What if the sub fires a missile when submerged? Do you have planes or sats available everywhere? Vietnamese has 6 but can increase the submarines in a short time if required. We now focus on economy not war. Besides, Indonesia submarines are too weak. One single Kilo has enough weapons onboard to give a dead blow to your naval fleet. The Kilo is designed to hit to kill. Not for parade. The sub has Kalibr, this highly maneuverable, long range cruise missiles fly at Mach 3 when approaching targets. Your surface warships have no defense against such threat. I give 50:50 chance for US and Chinese destroyers and cruisers to intercept the Kalibr. But the Kilo seldom fires one missile. At least two will be fired to overwhelm enemy air defense. Having said that reminding you to stop playing a game of provocation.


upload_2019-3-13_8-42-48.jpeg
 
.
Back
Top Bottom