What's new

‘Urdu is linguistic Taj Mahal of India’

third eye

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Aug 24, 2008
Messages
18,519
Reaction score
13
Country
India
Location
India
Urdu is easily the softest language. I agree with the author that language cannot have a religion.

The best Indian songs are written in urdu and ironically the authors are not all Muslim !

Urdu truly is the linguistic Taj Mahal of India.


javascript:window.top.sys.openArtWin('/Default/Scripting/ArticleWin.asp?From=Archive&Source=Page&Skin=TOINEW&BaseHref=CAP/2011/05/01&PageLabel=17&EntityId=Ar01701')

Mohammed Wajihuddin | TNN

Meri is baat se sab log hum aahang bhi honge...
Jahan payenge Urdu ko wahan Narang bhi honge...
(Everybody will concur with me/Wherever they will find Urdu, there will be a Narang too)
—Urdu poet Chandrabhan Khayal

Though many of his peers have grudgingly come to accept that Urdu is essentially spoken by Muslims today, Professor Gopi Chand Narang still fights the good fight. Language, he tirelessly intones, has no religion, Urdu belongs neither to Muslim nor Hindu and it will survive so long as India remains multicultural.

Narang’s steadfast belief is partly based on Urdu’s role in India’s freedom struggle. For a start, it gave us the slogan “Inquilab Zindabad” and contributed to our famed Ganga-Jamuni tehzeeb or composite culture. Unsurprisingly, the Delhi Urdu Academy acknowledges Narang’s role in giving Urdu a broad contextual placement, rather than a religious one. Just weeks ago, it gave him the Bahadur Shah Zafar Award. Akhtarul Wasey, vice-chairman of the Academy, says it was well deserved because the Award is named after the last Mughal emperor, who symbolized India’s secular, syncretic ethos.

Fortunately, Narang does not share yet another of the deposed poet-emperor’s traits – melancholy. Instead, he is optimistic about the future of Urdu and is so well known as an ambassador for it that Hindi writer Kamleshwar once said every language needed a Narang.

“There are three hallmarks of the Mughal era — the Taj Mahal, Ghalib’s poetry, and Urdu. A common spirit of aesthetic excellence and elegance runs through all three. Although every language is beautiful, Urdu’s sophistication and charm captivate everyone. That’s why I call Urdu India’s linguistic Taj Mahal,” explains the 82-year-old scholar-critic.

To those who call Urdu a videshi language, he retorts: “It is a hybrid, but Urdu’s base is indigenous and its essence lies in Indian soil.” He warns against continuing to deny Urdu its rightful place in the secular education system. It might then be pushed into the madrassas and will lose its secular character, he laments.

Narang is severe when asked about the great language paradox — Urdu couplets are quoted by everyone, including politicians, but almost no one is prepared to champion it otherwise. Is Urdu being punished for its apparent association with the Muslim community? Narang says, “If Urdu is the language of the Muslims, then how come non-Muslim writer-poets like Gulzar, Pavan K Varma, Sheen Kaaf Nizam (Shiv Kumar), Chandrabhan Khayal and Jayant Parmar are thriving?”

Born in Baluchistan, Narang is a partition refugee who insisted on studying Urdu rather than agricultural science, as his father wanted him to. Later in life, Delhi’s Jamia Millia proved to be the perfect lab for Narang and he even served as acting vice-chancellor for a year.
 
. . .
Alot of Bollywood songs are written in Urdu, because thausands of Bollywood songs are actually stolen from Pakistan:

If you can, then watch all 17 parts:


 
Last edited by a moderator:
. .
So many mistakes in the articles but again the purpose of this article is to show how urdu is a bharti langauge and there is no linguistic difference between pakistani and bhart.

The origin of urdu language is older than arrival of mughals.
Urdu may or may not be a muslim language but it sure is not indigenous to bharat. Urdu originated during Ghaznavid Empire in its second capital Lahore. The earliest literary remains of urdu are the poems of Massod Saad of Lahore of around 10th century.

Muslim captured Delhi 2 centuries later when in 12 th century when urdu was brought to Delhi by muslim invaders.

The developmment of urdu in Bharat was helped by the conquest of the area. It is not a bharti language, you people are welcome to speak it but its a pakistani language and it originated here, It wasn't brought here by invaders.
 
. . .
How is it "your" language? There was no modern india before 1947.

Of course there was. Pakistan has existed throughout history and so has India. Just because we were ruled by common outsiders, does not mean anything.
 
. .
So many mistakes in the articles but again the purpose of this article is to show how urdu is a bharti langauge and there is no linguistic difference between pakistani and bhart.

The origin of urdu language is older than arrival of mughals.
Urdu may or may not be a muslim language but it sure is not indigenous to bharat. Urdu originated during Ghaznavid Empire in its second capital Lahore. The earliest literary remains of urdu are the poems of Massod Saad of Lahore of around 10th century.

Muslim captured Delhi 2 centuries later when in 12 th century when urdu was brought to Delhi by muslim invaders.

The developmment of urdu in Bharat was helped by the conquest of the area. It is not a bharti language, you people are welcome to speak it but its a pakistani language and it originated here, It wasn't brought here by invaders.

Missing the woods for the trees !

No where in post No 1 does the author mention date lines or origin.

For heavens sake lets stop displaying our knowledge of history and re read this :

Language, he tirelessly intones, has no religion, Urdu belongs neither to Muslim nor Hindu and it will survive so long as India remains multicultural.


I speak Punjabi even though I am a Rajput, does it make me a Punjabi ? I have observed Rozas during Ramzan , does it make me a Muslim ? I speak and understand Urdu, does it make me Muslim ?

Obviously No. But I speak Punjabi & Urdu and kept Rozas during Ramzan cause I like the language & the concept of self control for a month in a year.

Thats all.
 
.
Muslim captured Delhi 2 centuries later when in 12 th century when urdu was brought to Delhi by muslim invaders.

Really, It was brought to India? Is that what you really think? Sure it was influenced by other languages outside India like Persian. But the language has ancestry with other languages of ancient India Prakrit buddy.
 
.
Missing the woods for the trees !

No where in post No 1 does the author mention date lines or origin.

For heavens sake lets stop displaying our knowledge of history and re read this :

Language, he tirelessly intones, has no religion, Urdu belongs neither to Muslim nor Hindu and it will survive so long as India remains multicultural.


I speak Punjabi even though I am a Rajput, does it make me a Punjabi ? I have observed Rozas during Ramzan , does it make me a Muslim ? I speak and understand Urdu, does it make me Muslim ?

Obviously No. But I speak Punjabi & Urdu and kept Rozas during Ramzan cause I like the language & the concept of self control for a month in a year.

Thats all.

Urdu started in Lahore, Punjab, Pakistan. We're not going to have you bharati people telling us our National language came from Bharat.
 
.
He means Lahore which is outside india.
 
.
Really, It was brought to India? Is that what you really think? Sure it was influenced by other languages outside India like Persian. But the language has ancestry with other languages of ancient India Prakrit buddy.

Prakrit, Hindvi, Hindustani, Dehlavi were all created in Muridke and then brought to Delhi and other Parts of India.

You need to brush up on history, you may have passed the age of indoctrination, but you can try.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom