“Udhar tum, idhar hum”: When Bhutto pushed Bangladesh to the edge of Pakistan

[Mage]

@Mage which river is like ravi river in Bangladesh?

I don't know what is Ravi river like....Bangladesh have many beautiful rivers. It is not called the land of rivers without a reason.

 

[JohnWick]

I don't know what is Ravi river like....Bangladesh have many beautiful rivers. It is not called the land of rivers without a reason.

Hi, ma boi how r u?

 

[Mage]

Hi, ma boi how r u?

I is gud...let's drink to the good health of Mr. Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto

 

[JohnWick]

I is gud...let's drink to the good health of Mr. Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto

Yeah I also have a regard for Bilawal Bhitto?”...

 

[CHACHA"G"]

Bengalis fought for the creation of Pakistan. Bengalis voted for the creation of Pakistan.

So does many other Ethnicities …… They(bangalis) have no other option...………………………………………………………… Do they ??????????? Please shear if yes?????? Don't forget It was Muslim movement for Pakistan ,,,,,,,,,,, Not Bangali movement...….

The union was unnatural and without autonomy of each wing, it was never going to work out. Hence autonomy was asked from our side.

This was your intentions from day 1 ……………. Fist you joined to get independence …… As soon as Muslim movement for Pakistan Succeeded ,,,,,,,,, bangali movement started,,,,,,, Base on ethnicity and language(later you guys used economics and India joined hands with your elite ) …. You wont be able to do that in united bangal under India ,,,,,,,, thus you guys waited for Muslim Movement for Pakistan to succeed .

@BHarwana , @django , @war&peace , @Imran Khan

 

[Mage]

Yeah I also have a regard for Bilawal Bhitto?”...

Let's drink to good health of both.

 

[JohnWick]

Let's drink to good health of both.

Kal bhi bhutto zinda tah
Aj bhi Bhutto zinda hai...

 

[Mage]

This was your intentions from day 1 ……………. Fist you joined to get independence …… As soon as Muslim movement for Pakistan Succeeded ,,,,,,,,, bangali movement started,,,,,,, Base on ethnicity and language(later you guys used economics and India joined hands with your elite ) …. You wont be able to do that in united bangal under India ,,,,,,,, thus you guys waited for Muslim Movement for Pakistan to succeed .

Chacha, not everything is evil conspiracy...some wanted a Bengali nation...some wanted a nation to be part with Pakistan because of Islam....economic, political, cultural difference eventually led to breakdown. Perhaps a loose federation with autonomy in both wings could have prevented the breakup....but it's too late now.

Do your best with your current Pakistan. Let us do our best with our Bangladesh.

Kal bhi bhutto zinda tah
Aj bhi Bhutto zinda hai...

Glory to Bhuttos.

They will rule Pakistan again.

 

[CHACHA"G"]

Chacha, not everything is evil conspiracy...some wanted a Bengali nation...some wanted a nation to be part with Pakistan because of Islam....economic, political, cultural difference eventually led to breakdown. Perhaps a loose federation with autonomy in both wings could have prevented the breakup....but it's too late now.

Do your best with your current Pakistan. Let us do our best with our Bangladesh.

You again did not answered what I asked …… You again left it or runaway from it. I quoted my own post for reference .

So does many other Ethnicities …… They(bangalis) have no other option...………………………………………………………… Do they ??????????? Please shear if yes?????? Don't forget It was Muslim movement for Pakistan ,,,,,,,,,,, Not Bangali movement...….

 

[JohnWick]

Chacha, not everything is evil conspiracy...some wanted a Bengali nation...some wanted a nation to be part with Pakistan because of Islam....economic, political, cultural difference eventually led to breakdown. Perhaps a loose federation with autonomy in both wings could have prevented the breakup....but it's too late now.

Do your best with your current Pakistan. Let us do our best with our Bangladesh.


Glory to Bhuttos.

They will rule Pakistan again.

Sure brother!

 

[Mage]

So does many other Ethnicities …… They(bangalis) have no other option...………………………………………………………… Do they ??????????? Please shear if yes?????? Don't forget It was Muslim movement for Pakistan ,,,,,,,,,,, Not Bangali movement...….

Active participation of Bengalis made the movement stronger. Heck even Liaqat Ali had to stand from Bengal to win a seat in 1946 election from Muslim league. The one who represented the Lahore resolution in parliament was a Bengali, Fazlul Haq.

 

[JohnWick]

The one who represented the Lahore resolution in parliament was a Bengali, Fazlul Haq.

They were our true leaders.

 

[Mage]

They were our true leaders.

First gen of leadership was good. They meant well...Jinnah and his close colleges. After that specially since Iskander Mirza, it went bad.

 

[CHACHA"G"]

Active participation of Bengalis made the movement stronger. Heck even Liaqat Ali had to stand from Bengal to win a seat in 1946 election from Muslim league. The one who represented the Lahore resolution in parliament was a Bengali, Fazlul Haq.

Excuse me aren't Muslim participating in Movement ????????? And according to your own words it just made movement stronger that's it...………
And same bangalis know they have 00000000 chance of Bangladesh at that time...…..

 

[Mage]

Excuse me aren't Muslim participating in Movement ????????? And according to your own words it just made movement stronger that's it...………
And same bangalis know they have 00000000 chance of Bangladesh at that time...…..

If Bengalis hadn't joined, there would be 00000 chance of Pakistan in 1947. Leaders like Liaqat Ali had to contest from Bengal to win a seat with Msulim League.