'They are Northeastern people not Bangladeshis', says Karnataka Home Minister

[Black_cats]

Protests ? Withdrawn from what ?

Are you living in some sort of parallel universe ?

That is Indian supplied data without any reliable source. That is why I asked you what was the source of it? India has info about 3.2 million Bangladeshi living in India illegally and they never raised it with Bangladeshi government?

The protest was there was no reliability of the figure. That is why UN withdrawn it.

 

[gslv mk3]

India has info about 3.2 million Bangladeshi living in India illegally and they never raised it with Bangladeshi government?

It has, on several occasions.

The protest was there was no reliability of the figure. That is why UN withdrawn it.

When did UN withdraw it ? Are you high or something ?

 

[UKBengali]

When did UN withdraw it ? Are you high or something ?

How on earth would the UN know how many "illegal BD'shis" there are in India dude?

I am not denying that there may be millions of BD'shi Hindus that went to India after 1971 or were born there to illegal BD'shi Hindu parents.

 

[gslv mk3]

How on earth would the UN know how many "illegal BD'shis" there are in India dude?

I am not denying that there may be millions of BD'shi Hindus that went to India after 1971 or were born there to illegal BD'shi Hindu parents.

How on earth would UN know that ?

The estimates of the migrant stock were prepared by the
Population Division of the Department of Economic and Social
Affairs of the United Nations Secretariat. The data presented
here refer to the international migrant stock defined as a mid-
year estimate of the number of people living in a country or area
other than the one in which they were born or, in the absence of
such data, the number of people of foreign citizenship. Most
statistics used to estimate the international migrant stock were
obtained from population censuses, population registers and
nationally representative household surveys.

Yeah and keep inventing theories about the same just like billion dollar Walton export fantasies...

 

[fallstuff]

'They are Northeastern people not Bangladeshis', says Karnataka Home Minister

Written By: Vicky Nanjappa Updated: Tuesday, April 3, 2018, 10:31 [IST]

https://www.oneindia.com/india/they...his-says-karnataka-home-minister-2670401.html

The people from Northeastern states are being mistaken as Bangladeshis, Karnataka Home Minister Ramalinga Reddy has said.

Karnataka Home Minister Ramalinga Reddy

The BJP has, time and again, claimed that the ruling Congress helped get Bangladeshi immigrants included in the electoral rolls ahead of the Assembly elections.

"People from the Northeastern states are confused as Bangladeshis," Reddy told reporters.

"We have special squads to check on illegal immigration. We found only 40-50 illegal Bangladeshi immigrants all over Karnataka and they have been deported."

He blamed the BJP-led NDA government at the Centre for failing to secure India's borders. "The Centre should tighten checks on immigrants in Assam and other states."

Reddy came down heavily on the BJP's charge sheet, in which the saffron party highlighted failures of the ruling Congress on various fronts. "The charge-sheet should be thrown into the dustbin or a paper scrapyard. Or, it should be used to pack pakodas as Prime Minister Narendra Modi said," Reddy quipped. He was referring to Modi's statement that selling pakodas was equal to employment.

Training his guns at BJP national president Amit Shah, who has been attacking the state government over farmers' suicides, Reddy said the number of farmers' suicides was highest in the BJP-ruled Maharashtra.

"Shah is shedding crocodile tears over the suicides. Since 2014, as many as 8,651 farmers have ended their lives in Maharashtra and 4,098 in Madhya Pradesh."

Reddy said 3,781 farmers committed suicide in Karnataka owing to consecutive droughts for four years.

Reddy mocked the BJP's 'Mushti Dhanya Sangraha Abhiyana', wherein the party is going door-to-door to collect a handful of rice. "With what face are they going to farmers' homes? They didn't do anything in the last four years."

Read more at: https://www.oneindia.com/india/they...his-says-karnataka-home-minister-2670401.html

Assam CM Tarun Gogoi: Not a single Bangladeshi national in Assam

• December 2, 2012

Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi on Sunday claimed that there was not a single Bangladeshi national in the state.

Addressing a rally at Juria in Nagaon district, Gogoi said that the claim by various political parties and civil society groups that there had been a huge influx of illegal Bangaldeshi nationals to Assam was nothing but false propaganda.

https://www.indiatoday.in/india/nor...ngladeshi-national-in-assam-123103-2012-12-02


https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/taru...-single-bangladeshi-national-in-assam.546486/

 

[Nilgiri]

Assam CM Tarun Gogoi: Not a single Bangladeshi national in Assam

• December 2, 2012

Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi on Sunday claimed that there was not a single Bangladeshi national in the state.

Addressing a rally at Juria in Nagaon district, Gogoi said that the claim by various political parties and civil society groups that there had been a huge influx of illegal Bangaldeshi nationals to Assam was nothing but false propaganda.

https://www.indiatoday.in/india/nor...ngladeshi-national-in-assam-123103-2012-12-02


https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/taru...-single-bangladeshi-national-in-assam.546486/

And he got ejected from power by the people he claim to speak for (who literally have first hand experience in it not being true).....and now a NRC is full underway and about to slap the crap out of BD this year.

Got anything else to cling on to?

 

[bluesky]

And he got ejected from power by the people he claim to speak for (who literally have first hand experience in it not being true).....and now a NRC is full underway and about to slap the crap out of BD this year.

Got anything else to cling on to?

Will you stop talking stupid and insane? What is the relationship between an election result and rectifying a false assumption? It is BD which is suffering because the unemployed Indians regularly pole vault to BD, get employment and remit $4.5 billion to their families in the rich India. Do we regularly complain about this? But, the little Indians complain when even tens from BD are not found in their hungry Europe. It is because the Indians are bigots.

 

[comfortably_numb]

Assam CM Tarun Gogoi: Not a single Bangladeshi national in Assam

Tarun Gogoi was the same person who advocated including the voters list and other relevant documents from 1985 to 2014 in NRC updation. Currently only documents till 1971 are admissible. His government was actively aiding and abetting infiltration and were putting their names into the later voter lists. Now that the cutoff has been set earlier the scumbags are at a loss.

Few ministers in his cabinet were directly responsible for settling BD illegals in Assam around major towns in ghettos and in the ecologically fragile areas where encroachment, poaching and smuggling are rampant.

 

[Bilal9]

The minister is a a congressi who will lie to protect his beloved hilsaphiles. The reality is we've taken a survey and found millions of these scum bonging around the North East. The Centre is most likely going to close the Siliguri so they can't bongomigrate into the rest of India, and then begin their de-bongoing campaign.

We will not stop until we,

a) De-populate the South of all Sanghis.

b) Improve your gene pool to remove the gene that causes Indian habit of 'Kanjoos-e-makkhi-choos'.

This really needs to be done.

Will you stop talking stupid and insane? What is the relationship between an election result and rectifying a false assumption? It is BD which is suffering because the unemployed Indians regularly pole vault to BD, get employment and remit $4.5 billion to their families in the rich India. Do we regularly complain about this? But, the little Indians complain when even tens from BD are not found in their hungry Europe. It is because the Indians are bigots.

Sanghi-walara jaat-kipta ar jaat-harami.

Bhab dekhai mosto pahlawan.

Chuler muthi dhorley pant-e peshab koira dai.

The Jumma people as you like to call them were forcibly driven away from their homes, their lands and property confiscated to implement state projects. Their womenfolks had to bear the brunt of your army's atrocities, no wonder that some of them chose to pick up arms. Even then, you made no distinctions between the militants and those who remain peaceful. Your army massacred them regardless.

It is only recently that you have started to provide them education in their own languages. But this half baked measure count for nothing as BD is still to implement the Chittagong Peace Accord even after 22 long years while they continue to be unrecognized by your constitution.

You call the Indians rapestanis, let me tell you that CHT is known as rapist's paradise courtesy your BD army. Remember Kalpana Chakma and many like her.

You have no one to blame besides your govt. because your govt. armed the Shanti Bahini insurgency deliberately. Now you're shedding crocodile tears for Chakma, Hajong and Marma troublemakers. Mess with us, we will mess with you.

Assam also needs a separatist movement and we should help them.

The center is robbing Assam of its resources high and dry. Majority of Assam leaders are corrupt and lapdogs of the corrupt sanghis running the center. I blame general naivete of the Assamese population for this state of affairs.

Now this Assam topic is entirely OT so let's open a separate thread if you want to discuss this.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

They do not have to if they don't wish to. This ethno-fascism is outright deplorable. They are a group with different culture, traditions and practices and as a democratic nation it is your responsibility as majority to not enforce your beliefs upon them.

Do you know what binds India's northeast together, a place your kind often deride as being less developed yet try to crawl in at the first opportunity. It is the government's policy of recognizing the uniqueness of each tribal groups and allowing them the opportunity to self govern themselves.

As a result, you have the autonomous councils for the Bodos, Dimasas and the Karbis among others. And that is precisely what differentiates Bangladesh from India.

Bangladesh is a unitary state unlike India which is federal.So we have no scope for any state or autonomous territory.We have no administrative fragmentation.Entire Bangladesh is under one single govt. rule. India is a country of many different ethnicities, languages,religion, races and cultures.People from one part of India is totally alien from other part. So that type of autonomous arrangement works in India. But in Bangladesh, more than 98 percent people are ethnically Bengali and 90 percent are muslim. This is an exceptionally homogeneous country.Less than 2 percent people are non Bengali(Bihari, Chakma, Marma, Garo, Santals and other tribals) and they live scatteredly in various bordering districts.

 

[comfortably_numb]

Assam also needs a separatist movement and we should help them.

You know jack sh!t about Assam, Bill. Sitting in your cramped cubicle working your scrawny as$ off to make ends meet in a faraway unwelcoming land has taken quite a toll, hasn't it Bill. So much so that you have resorted to pander to your abominable delusions.

I will write on this thread whatever I deem fit to be relevant for discussion. It is none of your business to tell me otherwise.

 

[Bilal9]

You know jack sh!t about Assam, Bill. Sitting in your cramped cubicle working your scrawny as$ off to make ends meet in a faraway unwelcoming land has taken quite a toll, hasn't it Bill. So much so that you have resorted to pander to your abominable delusions.

I will write on this thread whatever I deem fit to be relevant for discussion. It is none of your business to tell me otherwise.

Dada kheipa gesey...

 

[comfortably_numb]

Bangladesh is a unitary state unlike India which is federal.So we have no scope for any state or autonomous territory.We have no administrative fragmentation.Entire Bangladesh is under one single govt. rule. India is a country of many different ethnicities, languages,religion, races and cultures.People from one part of India is totally alien from other part. So that type of autonomous arrangement works in India. But in Bangladesh, more than 98 percent people are ethnically Bengali and 90 percent are muslim. This is an exceptionally homogeneous country.Less than 2 percent people are non Bengali(Bihari, Chakma, Marma, Garo, Santals and other tribals) and they live scatteredly in various bordering districts.

India is federal in spirit, not in letter, it is an union of states. The autonomous councils in India do not seek in any way to shield the tribals from the rest of the population. On the other hand it decentralises the power allowing those with distinct cultures to self-govern themselves.

Chattogram, for example has a different cuisine and dialect from your brothers in Sylhet or Dhaka though all of them are a part of the same unitary state. If your government were to make Sylheti as the sole state language would such a move be popular with the rest. Divisions exists everywhere, we must learn to coexist and take pride in our diversity.

Dada kheipa gesey...

Chabuk er bari ta thik jaygay porse mone hoitase, Billu. Thik ki na re?

 

[Mage]

One language keeps united is just fallacy ? then why we do have canada & usa or usa & uk?

Like we have Bangladesh and West Bengal. Some places can't stay together despite having common language..Unfortunate but that's how it is. India tries to promote Hindi, In Pakistan everyone has to learn Urdu. In China Mandarin is the way to go. UK, USA, Aus go for English...I wonder how Bangladesh is doing something bad that those countries aren't? @comfortably_numb

What middle east , aren't most of the countries use arabic there?

ME except Iran should be a federal state...but people are too busy killing other because of religious sects...

autonomy & respect for each others & converging self interests are what keeps ppl interested.

Autonomy doesn't satisfy Uyghurs in China...despite autonomy there are separatist movements in India costing lives and resources....
Respect for each other and self interest...I agree.

Further more having ppl of the same ethnicity/language simply ends up creating herd mentality. Germany & japan are good examples , technologically & economically they are great but without diversity they are prone to majoritarianism views/opinion which may be completely wrong.

Japan and Germany are two great countries. Very stable and very peaceful. They are an example to follow for BD.

 

[comfortably_numb]

India tries to promote Hindi, In Pakistan everyone has to learn Urdu. In China Mandarin is the way to go. UK, USA, Aus go for English...I wonder how Bangladesh is doing something bad that those countries aren't? @comfortably_numb

Two points, first, there exists constitutional safeguards to preserve the linguistic minorities in India vis-à-vis BD. The Bhasha Andolan in Assam that I talked of earlier is a case in point.

Secondly, no one in India will be in a disadvantageous spot w.r.t employment and opportunities if they do not speak Hindi. That is guaranteed by our constitution. Can you say the same for BD?