The transformation of Punjabi identity over the centuries Haroon KhalidUpdated November 29, 2017 304

[padamchen]

No you have misunderstood me, that time already happened some 1400 plus years ago and message has already been revealed, delivered, practiced and confirmed for completeness. That is why it needed to be spread, You won't understand it unless you read it yourself, research upon it (you are just basing your argument and opinion without knowing the message itself). Its not only for me, its for you too ......... so are you willing to look beyond your understanding that somehow I own the message and it has nothing to do with you? The invitation is simple, read it, understand it and if you still don't believe it ...... your choice, nothing to do with me.

That message was given to the Arab people 1400 years ago.

What followed was military imperialism.

The message of God has been revealed to other people by Prophets before Muhammad.

Were those messages wrong?

Or were those Gods lesser or false Gods?

If it's your argument that the message got corrupted by the people, and they needed a reminder by the birth of a new Prophet ....

Then look around you. And tell me what you see today.

Have the people evolved? Is this what you call evolution?

Look at Iran today. And compare them to the thousands of years of the glories if the Persian empires that ruled more than half the civilized world.

Look at Egypt today. And compare it and its place in the world to what it was in the time of the Pharaohs.

A people can never aspire for greatness on a borrowed (adopted, enforced, enslaved) philosophy.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Kabira]

Look at Iran today. And compare them to the thousands of years of the glories if the Persian empires that ruled more than half the civilized world.

Iran is doing very well for it self, now look at Hindustan which is still hindu as it gets.

 

[padamchen]

Iran is doing very well for it self, now look at Hindustan which is still hindu as it gets.

Yup.

Look at Hindustan too.

Pre and post the advent of Islam.

You just bolstered my point Kabira. Does that hurt a little?

Cheers, Doc

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

That is a sweeping statement and patently untrue. Maulana Azad, Ashafullah Khan, Shahnawaz Khan, not to mention Bharat Ratna awardee Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan fought gallantly for India's freedom. India is for everyone and every community contributed to its freedom movement.

Abdul Ghaffar Khan fought for an independent Pashtun state. My god, I don't know what the hell they are teaching you down there.

 

[Kabira]

Yup.

Look at Hindustan too.

Pre and post the advent of Islam.

You just bolstered my point Kabira. Does that hurt a little?

Cheers, Doc

There is no pre or post Islam for Hindustan when 90% is still Hindu. Islam didn't prevent Iran for being what it is today, a great nation. While Hindustan is still as it was in in 500BC. Only states where people don't live in gutter literally are IoK and east Punjab, both not your typical hindu states.

This shows blaming Islam for your ills doesn't make any sense and have nothing to do with ground reality.

 

[padamchen]

There is no pre or post Islam for Hindustan when 90% is still Hindu. Islam didn't prevent Iran for being what it is today, a great nation. While Hindustan is still as it was in in 500BC. Only states where people don't live in gutter literally are IoK and east Punjab, both not your typical hindu states.

This shows blaming Islam for your ills doesn't make any sense and have nothing to do with ground reality.

You are not particularly clever and are boring me now.

I think I'll wait for my friend to return ...

Cheers, Doc

 

[Kabira]

You are not particularly clever and are boring me now.

I think I'll wait for my friend to return ...

Cheers, Doc

And you are about to turn red again with your cleverness.

take care

 

[padamchen]

And you are about to turn red again with your cleverness.

take care

Please stop threatening.

It impresses me less than your cleverness does.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Kabira]

Please stop threatening.

It impresses me less than your cleverness does.

Cheers, Doc

And your trolling with hindu word which is used as derogatory is getting old

 

[padamchen]

And your trolling with hindu word which is used as derogatory is getting old

What Hindu word?

Cheers, Doc

 

[Kabira]

What Hindu word?

Cheers, Doc

You very well know "hindu" is used as insult, don't act clever gujju troll

 

[Jackdaws]

Abdul Ghaffar Khan fought for an independent Pashtun state. My god, I don't know what the hell they are teaching you down there.

Seriously???????
It makes perfect sense that he was given the Bharat Ratna for fighting for an independent Pashtun State.
Not to mention the Khudai Khidmatgar participating in the Quit India Movement or its close alliance with the Congress Party.

Now let's hear what is the "truth" that is taught to you down there?

 

[padamchen]

You very well know "hindu" is used as insult, don't act clever gujju troll

As far as I know, it is against forum rules to insult or abuse a community or nationality or race.

May I strongly suggest that you not flout the rules so brazenly?

Or does the fact that you are Pakistani embolden you with the promised immunity?

Cheers, Doc

 

[cocomo]

There is no pre or post Islam for Hindustan when 90% is still Hindu. Islam didn't prevent Iran for being what it is today, a great nation. While Hindustan is still as it was in in 500BC. Only states where people don't live in gutter literally are IoK and east Punjab, both not your typical hindu states.

This shows blaming Islam for your ills doesn't make any sense and have nothing to do with ground reality.

Point well made sir.

 

[Kabira]

As far as I know, it is against forum rules to insult or abuse a community or nationality or race.

May I strongly suggest that you not flout the rules so brazenly?

Or does the fact that you are Pakistani embolden you with the promised immunity?

Cheers, Doc

Only thing I said is stop insulting Pakistanis by using hindu word for us, you very well know insulting other communities is prohibited here. Stop being clever you cunny gujju, your insults will no longer be tolerated here.