The Spy Chronicles - Book Review by Dr Naeem Mushtaq

[Umair Nawaz]

 

[Umair Nawaz]

very good review.

I agree with everything he has reviewed...But abt Balochistan and ISI's lack of coordination is 100% true. ISI is known for her arrogance in this regard by IB n co.

Balochistan really has more American and israeli presence then RAW's or Irani VEVAK's.....Problem is hum log RAW k kandhy pr bandook rakh k MOSAD or CIA ko cover krty hain....because they r simply too powerful n resourceful. Their target is CPEC hence why china is also present there, it co-ordinates its activities with Pakistan for protection of CPEC in Balochistan

@Zarvan @DESERT FIGHTER @Irfan Baloch @BHarwana @tps77

@snow lake @RiazHaq

it looks to me that this book was launched to divert the attention from the real issue ie Kishanganga Dam's inauguration.

 

[Aamir Hussain]

The eventual classic coup goes to RAW!!! A spy even a retired one will remain a spy for the rest of his life. Gen Durrani forgot the oldest adage of intelligence agencies here.

Got carried away in Track 2 diplomacy. Gen Durrani got sucked in ---- classic sucker!!! He was overzealous to go pro Nawaz Shariff and anti establishment.

They must be laughing their heads off in N. Delhi.

 

[Umair Nawaz]

RAW should be given credit for turning a DG level ISI/ Lt Gen army officer to work for them like Durrani, while writing in this book that they havnt been able to turn any ISI officer even a low level for RAW.

While Kulbhushan Yadav was only a Colonal level officer and ISI has never been able to do the same ever.
Just look at how Dulat and Anchorperson is trying to hide their laughter with either their hands and arms when talking abt same subject with Lt Gen Asad Durrani

 

[Hareeb]

Anyone having the soft copy or the link of this book. Please share.

 

[Umair Nawaz]

The eventual classic coup goes to RAW!!! A spy even a retired one will remain a spy for the rest of his life.

Gen Durrani got sucked in ---- classic sucker!!! He was overzealous to go pro Nawaz Shariff.

Gen Durrani is like an unloved Child....jisko jaha sy b pyar milta ha wo waha chala jata ha.
They have for sometime now, been of great praise of General's intelligence, Strategic knowledge and foxy demeanor....Even i was highly impressed by him in the interviews that he gave to international media.

Just read the comments under this video.......

Then watch this. Iss ko sahe utha k rakha hua tha international media ny.

 

[Aamir Hussain]

Yes true. ISI, since his retirement, kept him at an arms length while he strived for attention levels that Gen Hameed Gul got in the media.

 

[Signalian]

Maj Gen Mahmud Ali Durrani admits that General Asif Baig (COAS at that time) asked him to distribute funds to Islami Jamhoori Ittehad (IJI)(coalition of 9 parties) standing against PPP. Islami Jamhoori Ittehad (IJI) was led by Nawaz Sharif.

https://www.pakistantoday.com.pk/20...al-money-distributed-on-orders-of-aslam-baig/


Islami Jamhoori Ittehad (IJI) and its history.
http://historypak.com/islami-jamhoori-ittehad/

Now that PML(N) is stuck in thick moat, this books comes out.

 

[Umair Nawaz]

Maj Gen Mahmud Ali Durrani admits that General Asif Baig (COAS at that time) asked him to distribute funds to Islami Jamhoori Ittehad (IJI)(coalition of 9 parties) standing against PPP. Islami Jamhoori Ittehad (IJI) was led by Nawaz Sharif.

https://www.pakistantoday.com.pk/20...al-money-distributed-on-orders-of-aslam-baig/


Islami Jamhoori Ittehad (IJI) and its history.
http://historypak.com/islami-jamhoori-ittehad/

Now that PML(N) is stuck in thick moat, this books comes out.

And right after inauguration of Kishanganga dam. After this book kashmir cause and the already low trust of Kashmiris towards Pakistan will get severely damaged....Kashmiris will now no longer trust Pakistan nor will they in future ever! This will help America to increase its influence on the Kashmiri freedom groups in the future so much so that they will micromanage Kashmiri resistance activities and as usual like in Afghanistan Pakistan shall be blamed always and that will tarnish any peace advnture or relation with india or maybe China in future because CIA/MOSAD/MI6 can use them against China as well. Depending upon what they want and how they want.

This is what AS Dulat as a Kashmir specialist wants the most from this book. Thats why timing was with kishanganga dam.......Nawaz Sharif isnt too important for india.......He actually is a CIA/MI6's pawn more then RAW's...He was known to coordinate directly with them while in office. Thats my information and assessment. Problem with this forum is that there r a lot of dual nationals like him in here with split loyalties, vested interests with Christianize/secular lifestyles and even r part of administration of this forum......Thats why before today, i never shared any real information/knowledge or assessment here...But now after kishanganga and timing of this book it is a greater deal.

 

[Sine Nomine]

I agree with everything he has reviewed...But abt Balochistan and ISI's lack of coordination is 100% true. ISI is known for her arrogance in this regard by IB n co.

I second that,that arrogance is costing us a lot in field of counter intelligence.

The eventual classic coup goes to RAW!!! A spy even a retired one will remain a spy for the rest of his life. Gen Durrani forgot the oldest adage of intelligence agencies here.

That's not his fault,none of Pak Army person deputed in ISI is a career spy.He wasn't a spy, he was a soldier.

 

[Tps43]

very good review.

I agree with everything he has reviewed...But abt Balochistan and ISI's lack of coordination is 100% true. ISI is known for her arrogance in this regard by IB n co.

Balochistan really has more American and israeli presence then RAW's or Irani VEVAK's.....Problem is hum log RAW k kandhy pr bandook rakh k MOSAD or CIA ko cover krty hain....because they r simply too powerful n resourceful. Their target is CPEC hence why china is also present there, it co-ordinates its activities with Pakistan for protection of CPEC in Balochistan

@Zarvan @DESERT FIGHTER @Irfan Baloch @BHarwana @tps77

@snow lake @RiazHaq

it looks to me that this book was launched to divert the attention from the real issue ie Kishanganga Dam's inauguration.

As far as vevak is concerned they have 2 lobbies one is anti pakistan and other is pro pakistan . Pro pakistan is in minority . When ever they get in power there activity in pakistan declines but usually anti pakistan one's are in power so they blindly do things without realising there after effects .

 

[Umair Nawaz]

I second that,that arrogance is costing us a lot in field of counter intelligence.

That's not his fault,none of Pak Army person deputed in ISI is a career spy.He wasn't a spy, he was a soldier.

speaking specifically abt that,...., ISI doesnt trust anyone, even if she does, it only done half heatedly with a bad intend.

As far as vevak is concerned they have 2 lobbies one is anti pakistan and other is pro pakistan . Pro pakistan is in minority . When ever they get in power there activity in pakistan declines but usually anti pakistan one's are in power so they blindly do things without realising there after effects .

their biggest influence is among the hazara people of quetta and on PPP. according to my assessment.

 

[MBilal106]

Anyone having the soft copy or the link of this book. Please share.

http://www.*************/file/bae4c...I and the Illusion of Peace - A.S. Dulat.pdf

 

[Umair Nawaz]

I second that,that arrogance is costing us a lot in field of counter intelligence.

That's not his fault,none of Pak Army person deputed in ISI is a career spy.He wasn't a spy, he was a soldier.

there r plenty of carrier spies both civil n military in ISI just that DG ISI or its head is installed by COAS who has never served in intelligence....this cold war era method however needs to change.

 

[Tps43]

I second that,that arrogance is costing us a lot in field of counter intelligence.

That's not his fault,none of Pak Army person deputed in ISI is a career spy.He wasn't a spy, he was a soldier.

CI of ISI is very strong , things which doesn't come out in public not means that there is lack of work or collaboration there , IB is more focused on political activities which costs us much more plus many senior IB officials are from police cadre who doesn't want to give space and they are there due to political affiliations.




CMI = corp of mill intellegnce is proper branch of army who are specialized
And amry personals rotate between ISI and MI like 5 years there 5 years here.
As far as PAF and PN is concerned in ISI there participation lacks but somehow PN have better ratio then Paf . Paf lacks there the most actually the thing is ISI have no say in promotion of these 2 services so people avoid it . I have seen many brillant operators and officers but alas they giveup ISI because for them its like running without a cause.

speaking specifically is abt that is that ISI doesnt trust anyone, even if she does, it only done half heatedly with a bad intend.


their biggest influence is among the hazara people of quetta and on PPP. according to my assessment.

No , there biggest influence is in punjab . U will be suprised to read this