What's new

The saga of an intrepid PAF pilot who humbled the Israelis

HAIDER

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
33,771
Reaction score
14
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Gp Capt KAISER TUFAIL writes a fascinating account of PAF's effective but little known role in defence of Arab skies

Post-haste summons for volunteers found an eager band of sixteen PAF fighter pilots on their way to the Middle East, in the midst of the 1973 Ramadan war. After a gruelling Peshawar-Karachi-Baghdad flight on a PAF Fokker, they were whisked off to Damascus in a Syrian jet. Upon arrival, half the batch was told to stay back in Syria while the rest were earmarked for Egypt. By the time the PAF batch reached Cairo, Egypt had agreed to a ceasefire; it was, therefore, decided that they would continue as instructors. But in Syria, it was another story.
The batch in Syria was made up of pilots who were already serving there on deputation (except one), but had been repatriated before the war. Now they were back in familiar surroundings as well as familiar aircraft, the venerable MiG-21. They were posted to No 67 Squadron, 'Alpha' Detachment (all PAF). Hasty checkouts were immediately followed by serious business of Air Defence Alert scrambles and Combat Air Patrols from the air base at Dumayr.

Syria had not agreed to a ceasefire, since Israeli operations in Golan were continuing at a threatening pace. Israeli Air Force missions included interdiction under top cover, well supported by intense radio jamming as the PAF pilots discovered. The PAF formation using the callsign 'Shahbaz' was formidable in size - all of eight aircraft. Shahbaz soon came to stand out as one that couldn't be messed with, in part because its tactics were innovative and bold. Survival, however, in a jammed-radio environment was concern number one. As a precaution, the Pakistanis decided to switch to Urdu for fear of being monitored in English. Suspicions were confirmed during one patrol, when healthy Punjabi invectives hurled on radio got them wondering if Mossad had recruited a few Khalsas for the job!

After several months of sporadic activity, it seemed that hostilities were petering out. While the Shahbaz patrols over Lebanon and Syria had diminished in frequency, routine training sorties started to register a rise. Under these conditions it was a surprise when on the afternoon of 26th April 1974, the siren blasted from the airshafts of the underground bunker. Backgammon boards were pushed aside and the 'qehva' session was interrupted as all eight pilots rushed to their MiGs; they were airborne within minutes. From Dumayr to Beirut, then along the Mediterranean coast till Sidon, and a final leg eastwards, skirting Damascus and back to Base - this was the usual patrol, flown at an altitude of 6 km. The limited fuel of their early model MiG-21F permitted just a 30 minutes sortie; this was almost over when ground radar blurted out on the radio that two bogeys (unidentified aircraft) were approaching from the southerly direction ie Israel. At this stage fuel was low and an engagement was the least preferred option. Presented with a fait accompli, the leader of the formation called a defensive turn into the bogeys. Just then heavy radio jamming started, sounding somewhat similar to the 'takka tak' at our meat joints, only more shrill. While the formation was gathering itself after the turn, two Israeli F-4E Phantoms sped past almost head-on, seemingly unwilling to engage. Was it a bait?

Flt Lt Sattar Alvi, now the rear-most in the formation, was still adjusting after the hard turn when he caught sight of two Mirage-IIICJ zooming into them from far below. With no way of warning the formation of the impending disaster, he instinctively decided to handle them alone. Peeling away from his formation, he turned hard into the Mirages so that one of them overshot. Against the other, he did a steep reversal dropping his speed literally to zero. (It takes some guts to let eight tons of metal hang up in unfriendly air!) The result was that within a few seconds the second Mirage filled his gunsight, the Star of David and all. While Sattar worried about having to concentrate for precious seconds in aiming and shooting, the lead Mirage started to turn around to get Sattar. Thinking that help was at hand, the target Mirage decided to accelerate away. A quick-witted Sattar reckoned that a missile shot would be just right for the range his target had opened up to. A pip of a button later, a K-13 heat-seeker sped off towards the tail of the escaping Mirage. Sattar recollects that it wasn't as much an Israeli aircraft as a myth that seemed to explode in front of him. (The letter 'J' in Mirage-IIICJ stood for 'Jewish', it may be noted.) He was tempted to watch the flaming metal rain down, but with the other Mirage lurking around and fuel down to a few hundred litres, he decided to exit. Diving down with careless abandon, he allowed a couple of sonic bangs over Damascus. (Word has it that the Presidential Palace wasn't amused!) His fuel tanks bone dry, Sattar made it to Dumayr on the vapours that remained.

As the other formation members started to trickle in, the leader, Sqn Ldr Arif Manzoor anxiously called out for Sattar to check if he was safe. All had thought that Sattar, a bit of a maverick that he was, had landed himself in trouble. Shouts of joy went up on the radio, however, when they learnt that he had been busy shooting down a Mirage.

The Syrians were overwhelmed when they learnt that the impunity and daring of the Pakistani pilots had paid off. Sattar was declared a blood brother by the Syrians, for he had shared in shedding the blood of a common enemy, they explained!

Sattar's victim Captain M Lutz of No 5 Air Wing based at Hatzor, ejected out of his disintegrating aircraft. It has been learnt that the Mirages were on a reconnaissance mission, escorted by Phantoms of No 1 Air Wing operating out of Ramat David Air Base. The Phantoms were to trap any interceptors while the Mirages carried out the recce. Timely warning by the radar controller (also from the PAF) had turned the tables on the escorts, allowing Sattar to sort out the Mirages.

The dogfight over Golan is testimony to the skills of all PAF pilots, insists Sattar, as he thinks any one could have got the kill had he been 'Shahbaz-8' on that fateful day. Sattar and his leader, Sqn Ldr Arif Manzoor, were awarded two of Syria's highest decorations for gallantry, the Wisaam Faris and Wisaam Shuja'at. The Government of Pakistan awarded them a Sitara-e-Jurat each. Sattar, an epitome of a fighter pilot, befittingly went on to command PAF's elite Combat Commanders' School and the premier PAF Base, Rafiqui. He retired recently as an Air Commodore.
SHAHBAZ OVER GOLAN
 
Arif had 1 kill and he came out victorious against 3 to 1 and no one mentions his dog fight. Most of the times Kaiser over glorified
people who didn't do ****. Same in 1965, 1971 war story in the Air was something different 5 min after landing the whole story changed.
Story of Pathankot Raid Nosiy Haider was made a hero that day The name Ghani Akbar never surfaced in the history books and was actually the hero of Pathankot. Officers like Ghani Akbar were very shy and were more interested in the war than getting there photos in the news papers and interviews with BBC.
Pilots like Ghani Akbar, Bahar Sahib, Naeem Atta, Arif Moota , Ijaz Azam, Maroof Mir, Imtiaz Haider and many more and these are the pilots who flew F-86s , in Bombers we had people who did things which were unbelievable only 1 or 2 names surface everytime what about the other 30 pilots . I made a lot of enemies in PAF just because of this reason. My couse mate goes up shots a Gnat and a hunter, he lands in kamra instead of his own base because of bad weather. The next day he comes and sees that the sqd commander has put his own name for the kill. A wing Cdre was a God in those days who could challenge them. I dont know if you noticed that 2 years back a few pilots who became very senior put there names in this list " AS CLAIMED BY BOTH" still few never challenged it because they had the respect for there counterparts and they knew that what they had done was good enough for them and Pakistan.
 
Its human nature I suppose , specially when you are a fighter pilot things tend to become a bit different.
 
Murad sahib,

Right on the dot. I have heard of many similar situations in the Army as well. True heroes are quickly forgotten and those who have had limited impact are recognized beyond what they deserve. If you get a chance, watch "Flags of our fathers". It has an interesting perspective on this issue of heroism and the associated recognition for it which is quite often misplaced.
 
Murad sahib,

Right on the dot. I have heard of many similar situations in the Army as well. True heroes are quickly forgotten and those who have had limited impact are recognized beyond what they deserve. If you get a chance, watch "Flags of our fathers". It has an interesting perspective on this issue of heroism and the associated recognition for it which is quite often misplaced.

Very true my youngest brother saved his platoon by throwing him self on a granade and got shot twice at sailkot sector, he never got a medal for it, he spent 6 months in the hospital and another 3 years to patch up things in him. Till today all his course mates are amazed that how did he survive.
Let me show you some of the people I was talking about who should get credit of what they have done for there country. Please respect my copy right THK
e87cd086d65b56b06bef6f5a215362d8.jpg


They were known as Nur Khans Tigers. Just look at there faces they were against 10 IAF Sqd and they fought like real Tigers.
 
This is something that they will never show on the history channel. i was kind a hoping that they would but when they didnt i was not surprised
 
In line with MuradK sahib's post, here is another blurb from Group Captain Cecil Chaudhry about those deserving not getting the proper recognition:

"Q. Any forgotten hero of 1965 particularly in the air war as you saw it?
In my opinion there are many. Somehow only the performance of the aircrew was highlighted. What about the radar controllers who, on numerous occasions, completely outwitted the Indian controllers who had better equipment? The airmen who recovered damaged aircraft in record time? Even amongst fighter pilots there were officers like Syed Mukhtar Ali (later retired as an Air Commodore) who were totally ignored because of personal likes and dislikes. There were officers from the F-104 Squadron who should never have been decorated, yet outstanding people like Aftab Alam from the same Squadron were completely ignored."

Chowk: Politics: Interview-Cecil Chaudhry-A.H Amin-PAF-1965-1971 Wars
 
In line with MuradK sahib's post, here is another blurb from Group Captain Cecil Chaudhry about those deserving not getting the proper recognition:

"Q. Any forgotten hero of 1965 particularly in the air war as you saw it?
In my opinion there are many. Somehow only the performance of the aircrew was highlighted. What about the radar controllers who, on numerous occasions, completely outwitted the Indian controllers who had better equipment? The airmen who recovered damaged aircraft in record time? Even amongst fighter pilots there were officers like Syed Mukhtar Ali (later retired as an Air Commodore) who were totally ignored because of personal likes and dislikes. There were officers from the F-104 Squadron who should never have been decorated, yet outstanding people like Aftab Alam from the same Squadron were completely ignored."

Chowk: Politics: Interview-Cecil Chaudhry-A.H Amin-PAF-1965-1971 Wars


:lol::lol:old memories Cecil and I are brothers his wife is related to mine. And just like Cecil and Mukhtar Sahib , these pilots knew there jobs and didn't take **** from no one, and I mean no one , A lot of times people have asked me on the form or personal emails why didn't they get to higher ranks. REASON : Simple PAF should have given them medals and most of all respect. They did'nt.
See it is very hard for a civilian to understand that fighter pilots is trained to fight in the air to defend its Air space or in other words country, He will train as long as he retires and would never get a chance to fight, But we Courses from 40th GDP , 41th GDP, 42nd GDP we had no Dog fight experience and still came out victorious, we learned quickly and these 3 courses were just natural fighters the photo above in the post these are the people.
Combat Commander School CCS is one of the best even the US AF says that and they are right, They play hell into you these 3 courses are the only course in the history of PAF who all got A7, which is like 100% in all aspects.
Now a days kids are getting B5s some times A2 or 3, None of the above got a medal None. WHY?
 
For me the squadron based in East Pakistan was the best. Imagine the odds they were fighting against. Yet they still kept on fighting.
These pilots should have been given the proper credit and reward not those who did nothing and gained glory.
 
I also appreciate the INDIVIDUAL acts of courage by these air warriors especially the Fl Offr Shams ul Haq, who was the top scorer of 14 and a very young pilot.

But still I condemn the so-called DISCIPLINE of these pilots. Discipline does not mean obeying illegal or wrong or illogical orders.

Its not just matter of saying YES SIR to the OC or Base Commander. Its a matter of honor of the nation, a matter of prestige for the ummah.


It was written in the official books of PAF that the runway of the tejgaon airbase in Dhaka was destroyed by a bombing of IAF on the 6th or 7th Dec 1971. I was wondering how was such a precise bombing possible in 1971 by the IAF in the presence of AAA.

At that time I was in high school and I started the search for No.14 Squadron personnel. Luckily I found one and he narrated me a completey different version of the events.

I would not use very hard words, but I would like to descirbe the event in just a few lines.

First the runway was destroyed in broad daylight.

When a large attack formation (more than a dozen) was coming to attack the dhaka air base, a PAF formation was readied by Sq ldr Dilawar Hussain to stop the indian formation. The aircrafts were readied for the take off and started taxiing for the main runway.

On the radio, Dilawar Hussian received a message from Commander to SHUT DOWN the engine. Dilawar was extremely frustrated at this order but quite strangly he obeyed the order and aircrafts were brought back.

The attack started. Many aircraft were strafing at the airfield without taking aim at some specific target just to engage the attention of AAA gunners.

Suddenly Dilawar Hussain, while standing on ground like a falcon in the cage, noted a pair of Su-7s circling above the airfield and taking a position for precision bombing.

These two aircrafts came in and precisely delivered special anti-runway 'Dibber' bombs who threw out the runway 'inside out'.

A few pilots could have changed the course of histroy by not obeying the order of the commander.

Till 6th December, when the No.14 squadron was operational, the conditions were not so bad. When the IAF achieved air supremacy, they started free operations in the skies of East Pakistan. They bombed the hospitals, the Governor House, and did numerous air-ground operations, disrupting communications and supplies.

Before the start of hostilies an early warning, low-level radar was removed from Pakistan and sent to the west. The F-6 squadron did not go to East Pakistan, as was thought. Was it already engineered and planned?

The young fighter pilots seem to be just tools for the old conspiracy-hardened bosses ......

Fall of Dhaka was not just a matter of Paksitan. It was a big defeat to muslims after the fall of Bughdad and Gharnata. It was a third biggest fall. The Pakistani POWs were mocked at and Indians said to them that they had taken revenge of Babur, Jehangir and Aurangzeb and others.

Discipline means obeying only and only and only correct orders. Also in the past, when in WW1 a unit of British Indian Army was taken to Iraq to fight against Turks, some brave soldiers refused to obey order and to fight against muslim brothers.

for this we need to change the selection criteria in ISSB. Instead of selecting YESMEN and gullible guys, we need knowledgeable and brave men.

Discipline means adherence to the faith and loyality to Pakistan, not YES SIR, YES SIR.
 
Last edited:
Combat Commander School CCS is one of the best even the US AF says that and they are right, They play hell into you these 3 courses are the only course in the history of PAF who all got A7, which is like 100% in all aspects.
Now a days kids are getting B5s some times A2 or 3,

10 years at Sargodha, max I saw somebody in CCS was B-6....pilots did perform well in Air Superiority phase but it was the surface attack that brought them down in overall grades......perhaps too many mission / conduct failures or stringent ROEs.....:tsk:
 
Discipline means obeying only and only and only correct orders as exhibited recenlty by some brave soldiers during operations in NWFP. Also in the past, when in WW1 a unit of British Indian Army was taken to Iraq to fight against Turks, some brave soldiers refused to obey order and to fight against muslim brothers.

Discipline means adherence to the faith and loyality to Pakistan, not YES SIR, YES SIR.

Please don’t drag this Ummah thing into this matter....Excuse me, but if you didn’t notice :: There is No Ummah ( except in your own mind ) .....Its either Egypt, or Malaysia , or Pakistan , or Saudi Arabia etc etc ....all are individual countries with their own policies and agendas. In your own country, one cannot bring two ulemaas from two different sects at a single point, how can you even imagine to unite 1.6 billion people from 46 countries. The sooner you realise that Ummah doesn’t exists, the better you will feel...:pop:

I am also not at all proud of fall of Dhaka but doubting the intentions, discipline and courage of the men who gave their life for their country, is not a wise thing to do.....These same YES SIR MEN ( according to you ) carry their lives in hands so that rest can carryon with their lives.......While you are reading this in the comfort of your home , you cant even guess that how many of these ''YES SIR MEN ' are guarding your back in the worst possible living conditions....

I don’t know that what is your standard of brave men ....but trust me....these men will do anything and will go to any extreme to take care of their country against any aggression....:enjoy:
 
I shall not go down to personal levels, just shall tell u some facts about ummah...

In europe, there is no visa among all christian countries. Their currency is the same, euro. They live like a single country. They are not including Turkey in European Union only on the religious ground and it has been stated clearly by European leaders.

The problem is only with muslim countries....and some people in them...

still u know very well that Jordan gave u F-104s in 1971, F-5s came to Pakistan, Iran gave u 90 F-86s after the 1965 war, Indonesia sent its submarine(s) to Pakistan in 1965, Iran let u have the Tempest fighters from UK out of the turn coz in the order book, Iran was ahead of Pakistan and Pakistan,like always, was in dangerous security situation.

Saudi Arabia gives scholarships to students in Pakistani universities for example Engineering Universities....its another story that the scholarship incharge in univeristy puts it in his pockets or gives it to that student who can share it with him.......I know this coz one of my friends did the same thing..............Saudi runs many educational institutes with full scholarships.......not to mention oil concessions from time to time......

its not a very encouraging and hopeful situation like that of Europe, but still u should not condemn the ummah concept.
 
I shall not go down to personal levels, just shall tell u some facts about ummah...

In europe, there is no visa among all christian countries. Their currency is the same, euro. They live like a single country. They are not including Turkey in European Union only on the religious ground and it has been stated clearly by European leaders.

The problem is only with muslim countries....and some people in them...

still u know very well that Jordan gave u F-104s in 1971, F-5s came to Pakistan, Iran gave u 90 F-86s after the 1965 war, Indonesia sent its submarine(s) to Pakistan in 1965, Iran let u have the Tempest fighters from UK out of the turn coz in the order book, Iran was ahead of Pakistan and Pakistan,like always, was in dangerous security situation.

Saudi Arabia gives scholarships to students in Pakistani universities for example Engineering Universities....its another story that the scholarship incharge in univeristy puts it in his pockets or gives it to that student who can share it with him.......I know this coz one of my friends did the same thing..............Saudi runs many educational institutes with full scholarships.......not to mention oil concessions from time to time......

its not a very encouraging and hopeful situation like that of Europe, but still u should not condemn the ummah concept.

shehbazi: you are not listening to X-men and understanding his point. If you want to talk about ummah than take this into consideration it was easy for me to marry a Christian Girl than to marry a Shia girl and I being a muslim.
 
Back
Top Bottom