What's new

Sultana, a descendant of the Mughal emperor, wants ownership of the Red Fort

bluesky

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 14, 2016
Messages
16,515
Reaction score
-4
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Japan
Sultana, a descendant of the Mughal emperor, wants ownership of the Red Fort
Inquilab Desk | Release time: January 1, 2022, 10:59 p.m.

1641076252677.png

Claiming to be the heir of the Mughal dynasty, a poor elderly woman living in Calcutta, India,

demanded the return of ownership of the Red Fort, once used by the emperors as a beautiful palace. The woman, named Sultana Begum, lived in a two-room hut in a slum on the outskirts of Kolkata. She is fighting for survival on a nominal pension. -AFP

Sultana Begum has marriage documents with Mirza Mohammad Bedar Bakht, the great-grandson of Bahadur Shah Jafar, the last Mughal ruler of India. Bedar Bakht's death in 1980 plunged her into a difficult struggle. It has been almost 10 years since she applied to the authorities for recognition of royalty and compensation accordingly. There is no solution yet.

The 60-year-old said, "Do you think the descendants of the emperors who built the Taj Mahal should now be living in abject poverty?"

Sultana Begum has filed a case in an Indian court seeking her recognition. Begum has claimed that she is the legal owner of the red fort built in the 17th century. Located in New Delhi, this historic fort was once the center of power of the Mughal Empire. Sultana Begum said, "I hope the government will give me justice. When someone owns something, it should be returned to him. '

According to Sultana Begum, the social workers said that their identities could be identified with the descendants of the last emperor of India, Bahadur Shah Jafar. Sultana Begum has said in the case filed in the court that the Indian government is holding illegal occupation of the Red Fort. She commented that ownership should be returned to her.

Last week (the last week of December), the Delhi High Court dismissed Sultana Begum's plea as a "waste of time". But about her claims to be a descendant of the Mughal Empire; The court did not comment on whether it was valid. Instead, the court said, Sultana Begum's legal team failed to argue why no such case had been filed by her descendants in the 150 years since Emperor Jafar's deportation. However, Sultana Begum's lawyer said that the proceedings of this case will continue. He said he had decided to appeal the order to a higher bench of the court.

Sultana hopes for justice: Sultana Begum is living an uncertain life. She was forced to move to a slum even before she became a widow. She still lives in that slum. The government of the country will recognize her as the legitimate owner of the Red Fort; Sultana Begfum still sees that hope. When she was married to 32-year-old Mirza Mohammad Bedar Bakht; She was only 14 then. She said, "Poverty, fear and lack of resources have pushed her to the brink of extinction." Begum lives in a small hut with one of her grandchildren. Share the kitchen with neighbors. Uses water from roadside tube wells.

For the past few years, she has been running a small tea shop next to his house in the slum. But it was also demolished during the road expansion. She is currently living on a monthly pension of Tk 6,000. Sultana still hopes that the Indian government will recognize her as the imperial heir and the legitimate owner of the Red Fort. "I hope to get what I deserve today, tomorrow, or in 10 years," he said. By the grace of God, I will get it back ... I am sure there will be justice. '

The last consequence of Emperor Bahadur Shah Jafar: After the conquest of India by the East India Company, a commercial enterprise of the British banians, the boundaries of the capital of the Mughal Empire narrowed. Emperor Jafar made his debut in the Mughal Empire in 1838. Twenty years later, in 1857, there was a mass revolt in the Indian Army (sepoy revolt); Which is now recognized as India's first war of independence. At the start of the failed rebellion, the soldiers declared 72-year-old Zafar as their leader. The Mughal ruler was also known as a famous Urdu poet.

Within a month, British troops besieged Delhi and ruthlessly suppressed the revolt. Despite the surrender of members of the royal family, 10 surviving sons of Emperor Jafar were executed. Zafar went into exile in neighboring Myanmar in a bullock cart and died in captivity five years later.

Symbol of India's independence: Many years after the uprising, many of the buildings of the Red Fort were demolished and were in a state of disrepair before the colonial authorities ordered the renovation of the fort in the early twentieth century. The Red Fort later became a 'powerful symbol' of liberation from British rule for the Indians. India's first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru hoisted the national flag at the fort on the first day after the country's independence in 1947. Now every year the first national flag is hoisted at the Red Fort on India's Independence Day.

 
Last edited:
Sultana, a descendant of the Mughal emperor, wants ownership of the Red Fort
Inquilab Desk | Release time: January 1, 2022, 10:59 p.m.

View attachment 805175
Claiming to be the heir of the Mughal dynasty, a poor elderly woman living in Calcutta, India,

demanded the return of ownership of the Red Fort, once used by the emperors as a beautiful palace. The woman, named Sultana Begum, lived in a two-room hut in a slum on the outskirts of Kolkata. He is fighting for survival on a nominal pension. -AFP

Sultana Begum has marriage documents with Mirza Mohammad Bedar Bakht, the great-grandson of Bahadur Shah Jafar, the last Mughal ruler of India. Bedar Bakht's death in 1980 plunged him into a difficult struggle. It has been almost 10 years since he applied to the authorities for recognition of royalty and compensation accordingly. There is no solution yet. The 6-year-old said, "Do you think the descendants of the emperors who built the Taj Mahal are now living in abject poverty?"

Sultana Begum has filed a case in an Indian court seeking her recognition. Begum has claimed that she is the legal owner of the red fort built in the 17th century. Located in New Delhi, this historic fort was once the center of power of the Mughal Empire. Sultana Begum said, "I hope the government will give me justice. When someone owns something, it should be returned to him. ' According to Sultana Begum, the social workers said that their identities could be identified with the descendants of the last emperor of India, Bahadur Shah Jafar. Sultana Begum has said in the case filed in the court that the Indian government is holding illegal occupation of the Red Fort. He commented that ownership should be returned to him.

Last week (the last week of December), the Delhi High Court dismissed Sultana Begum's plea as a "waste of time". But he claims to be a descendant of the Mughal Empire; The court did not comment on whether it was valid. Instead, the court said, Sultana Begum's legal team failed to argue why no such case had been filed by her descendants in the 150 years since Jafar's deportation. However, Sultana Begum's lawyer said that the proceedings of this case will continue. He said he had decided to appeal the order to a higher bench of the court.

Sultana hopes for justice: Sultana Begum is living an uncertain life. She was forced to move to a slum even before she became a widow. He still lives in that slum. The government of the country will recognize him as the legitimate owner of the Red Fort; Sultana still sees that hope. Begum when she was married to 32-year-old Mirza Mohammad Bedar Bakht; He was only 14 then. She said, "Poverty, fear and lack of resources have pushed her to the brink of extinction." Begum lives in a small hut with one of her grandchildren. Share the kitchen with neighbors. Uses water from roadside tube wells.

For the past few years he has been running a small tea shop next to his house in the slum. But it was also demolished during the road expansion. He is currently living on a monthly pension of Tk 6,000. Sultana still hopes that the Indian government will recognize her as the imperial heir and the legitimate owner of the Red Fort. "I hope to get what I deserve today, tomorrow or in 10 years," he said. By the grace of God, I will get it back ... I am sure there will be justice. '

The last consequence of Emperor Bahadur Shah Jafar: After the conquest of India by the East India Company, a commercial enterprise of the British banians, the boundaries of the capital of the Mughal Empire narrowed. Emperor Jafar made his debut in the Mughal Empire in 1838. Twenty years later, in 1857, there was a mass revolt in the Indian Army (sepoy revolt); Which is now recognized as India's first war of independence. After the rebellion failed, the soldiers declared 72-year-old Zafar, their leader, to be their leader. The Mughal ruler was also known as the famous Urdu poet.

Within a month, British troops besieged Delhi and ruthlessly suppressed the revolt. Despite the surrender of members of the royal family, 10 surviving sons of Emperor Jafar were executed. Zafar went into self-imposed exile in neighboring Myanmar in a bullock cart and died in captivity five years later.

Symbol of India's independence: Many years after the uprising, many of the buildings of the Red Fort were demolished and were in a state of disrepair before the colonial authorities ordered the renovation of the fort in the early twentieth century. The Red Fort later became a 'powerful symbol' of liberation from British rule for the Indians. India's first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru hoisted the national flag at the fort on the first day after the country's independence in 1947. Now every year the first national flag is hoisted at the Red Fort on India's Independence Day.

Provide her some food. What will she do of Redfort?Sorry to see Mughal descendant in pathatic condition.
 
Sultana, a descendant of the Mughal emperor, wants ownership of the Red Fort
All the people of this south Asian sub-continent were the subjects of the Mughal Dynasty. Our forefathers were the subjects of this legitimate dynasty.

The people and the govts of the three countries have obligation to uphold that family's prestige by compensating them, if not the Red Fort. They should be able to live a better life and their descendants must be given the opportunity to become educated.

A few decades ago, I was reading a Kolkata magazine Ultoroth Puja edition. I encountered a feature about Bedar Bakht, a Mughal descendant and the husband of Sultana Begum. After coming back from Rangoon he was penniless without land, privilege or money to support himself. So, with a biting shame in mind he used to beg near the tomb of Emperor Humayun in Delhi in order to survive.

He came back after the 1947 independence. I feel very pain whenever I remember his life, and the same is continuing.
 
Last edited:
Why should only India have to pay for Mughal descendents, Pakistan and Bangladesh were also an equal part of the erstwhile empire.
This lady should ask compensation from all three nations.
Although the world has changed, there are no more kings and queens in the sub continent, so no country have any responsibility to pay for any royal descendents...!
 
The people and the govts of the three countries have obligation to uphold that family's prestige by compensating them, if not the Red Fort. They should be able to live a better life and their descendants must be given the opportunity to become educated.

Compensation? By whom?

If the Mughals have any claims to make it should be with the British. The best thing for India after independence was to eliminate kingdoms altogether. No more rajas, ranis, or nawabs. Something Pakistan failed to do and problems are there to see.
 
Compensation? By whom?

If the Mughals have any claims to make it should be with the British. The best thing for India after independence was to eliminate kingdoms altogether. No more rajas, ranis, or nawabs. Something Pakistan failed to do and problems are there to see.
Present-day India is the successor of British India. So, Delhi should pay the compensation.
 
Sultana, a descendant of the Mughal emperor, wants ownership of the Red Fort
Inquilab Desk | Release time: January 1, 2022, 10:59 p.m.

View attachment 805175
Claiming to be the heir of the Mughal dynasty, a poor elderly woman living in Calcutta, India,

demanded the return of ownership of the Red Fort, once used by the emperors as a beautiful palace. The woman, named Sultana Begum, lived in a two-room hut in a slum on the outskirts of Kolkata. She is fighting for survival on a nominal pension. -AFP

Sultana Begum has marriage documents with Mirza Mohammad Bedar Bakht, the great-grandson of Bahadur Shah Jafar, the last Mughal ruler of India. Bedar Bakht's death in 1980 plunged her into a difficult struggle. It has been almost 10 years since she applied to the authorities for recognition of royalty and compensation accordingly. There is no solution yet.

The 60-year-old said, "Do you think the descendants of the emperors who built the Taj Mahal should now be living in abject poverty?"

Sultana Begum has filed a case in an Indian court seeking her recognition. Begum has claimed that she is the legal owner of the red fort built in the 17th century. Located in New Delhi, this historic fort was once the center of power of the Mughal Empire. Sultana Begum said, "I hope the government will give me justice. When someone owns something, it should be returned to him. '

According to Sultana Begum, the social workers said that their identities could be identified with the descendants of the last emperor of India, Bahadur Shah Jafar. Sultana Begum has said in the case filed in the court that the Indian government is holding illegal occupation of the Red Fort. She commented that ownership should be returned to her.

Last week (the last week of December), the Delhi High Court dismissed Sultana Begum's plea as a "waste of time". But about her claims to be a descendant of the Mughal Empire; The court did not comment on whether it was valid. Instead, the court said, Sultana Begum's legal team failed to argue why no such case had been filed by her descendants in the 150 years since Emperor Jafar's deportation. However, Sultana Begum's lawyer said that the proceedings of this case will continue. He said he had decided to appeal the order to a higher bench of the court.

Sultana hopes for justice: Sultana Begum is living an uncertain life. She was forced to move to a slum even before she became a widow. She still lives in that slum. The government of the country will recognize her as the legitimate owner of the Red Fort; Sultana Begfum still sees that hope. When she was married to 32-year-old Mirza Mohammad Bedar Bakht; She was only 14 then. She said, "Poverty, fear and lack of resources have pushed her to the brink of extinction." Begum lives in a small hut with one of her grandchildren. Share the kitchen with neighbors. Uses water from roadside tube wells.

For the past few years, she has been running a small tea shop next to his house in the slum. But it was also demolished during the road expansion. She is currently living on a monthly pension of Tk 6,000. Sultana still hopes that the Indian government will recognize her as the imperial heir and the legitimate owner of the Red Fort. "I hope to get what I deserve today, tomorrow, or in 10 years," he said. By the grace of God, I will get it back ... I am sure there will be justice. '

The last consequence of Emperor Bahadur Shah Jafar: After the conquest of India by the East India Company, a commercial enterprise of the British banians, the boundaries of the capital of the Mughal Empire narrowed. Emperor Jafar made his debut in the Mughal Empire in 1838. Twenty years later, in 1857, there was a mass revolt in the Indian Army (sepoy revolt); Which is now recognized as India's first war of independence. At the start of the failed rebellion, the soldiers declared 72-year-old Zafar as their leader. The Mughal ruler was also known as a famous Urdu poet.

Within a month, British troops besieged Delhi and ruthlessly suppressed the revolt. Despite the surrender of members of the royal family, 10 surviving sons of Emperor Jafar were executed. Zafar went into exile in neighboring Myanmar in a bullock cart and died in captivity five years later.

Symbol of India's independence: Many years after the uprising, many of the buildings of the Red Fort were demolished and were in a state of disrepair before the colonial authorities ordered the renovation of the fort in the early twentieth century. The Red Fort later became a 'powerful symbol' of liberation from British rule for the Indians. India's first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru hoisted the national flag at the fort on the first day after the country's independence in 1947. Now every year the first national flag is hoisted at the Red Fort on India's Independence Day.


India is a democratic republic and a modern nation state. This era of nawabs, sultans, chogyals, chieftains, princely states,etc. is over. Someone send her the memo and ask her to come to the 21st century.
Present-day India is the successor of British India. So, Delhi should pay the compensation.

We will pay her squat. The nation owes her nothing.
 
India owes Agra Tajmahal and Delhi Red Fort to the Mughal dynasty. Do you want to deny the history?

Mughals were themselves foreigners (Chagatai Turks of current Uzbekistan) and were unwanted in the subcontinent. Mughals claiming properties in India, is like British, French, Belgians, Dutch, Japanese, etc. claiming their properties in the countries they colonized or occupied.

The world has moved on from the age of colonization and empires. Time to live in the 21st century and take it forward. Those who fail to come out of the past and adapt to the new ways, vanish into history.

The government at best can enroll her family members in some skill development scheme so that the younger ones can learn to work and earn their own living like honest people. If she wants to be treated like royalty, that is not happening.
 
Last edited:
Mughals were themselves foreigners (Chagatai Turks of current Uzbekistan) and were unwanted in the subcontinent. Mughals claiming properties in India, is like British, French, Belgians, Dutch, Japanese, etc. claiming their properties in the countries they colonized or occupied.
Mughal Emperors were not foreigners, their forefathers were. It is the same with Aryans who came and settled mostly in northern and NW India. The people who migrated to then India have settled in India, and they are as Indians as the Sudras the native Indians. It is the same with Mughal Emperors.

By your weird logic, President Kennedy was Irish and President Trump is a German. Not only that, Queen Elizabeth of the UK is also a German.
 
Last edited:
Mughal Emperors were not foreigners, their forefathers were. It is the same with Aryans who came and settled mostly in northern and NW India. The people who migrated to then India have settled in India, and they are as Indians as the Sudras the native Indians. It is the same with Mughal Emperors.

By your weird logic, President Kenedy was Irish and President Trump is a German. Not only that Queen Elizabeth of the UK is also a German.

We are not giving her a squat.

All royal properties are the property of the Government of the Republic of India. Princes and kings and nawabs whatever they were aren't allowed to retain their ancestral properties or claim titles in today's society.

She can accept a government skill development scheme for her younger family members to get a job like any other person living in India, or she can take a hike.

Wants to take the Red Fort... :rofl: :rofl:.
 
Back
Top Bottom