Sindudesh has signifcant support in Sindh.

[Sinnerman108]

Prime failure of PTI is inability to break shackles or bring education to thecountry

It was a total failure and now you see the results

PTI didnt do anything just to keep the elite happy/on one page

It is PTI failure how ?

Education is a chapter in provincial governance , not federal.

How about talking about people who have ruled sidh since last 75 years or so, and not given a penny worth back ?

 

[Sinnerman108]

So basically PTI will wash hands?
Revolutions dont happen like this

PTI had federal govt on its hands it could have done alot

Noone stopped PTI to bring basic human rights reforms to sindh/punjab where people are still in bonded labour

You may want to check the last 3 years,
every time PTI tried to even do something about anything, they were threatened out.

for your information, sindh refused to accept curriculum that other 3 provinces follow.
Even the Karachi metro transport project was treated the same way.

Sindh government can't keep crying, while not letting anyone help.

 

[SaadH]

For the last few years at least, if you drive through interior Sindh, not even too deep, just on the main bloody highway N5 you will regularly find Sindudesh flags flying around on houses or on streets. These flags are both new and years old.

I have even seen a few sizeable gatherings of Sindudesh supporters.

Look what a shithole the finanical capital of Pakistan is under PPP. Now just imagine what some random villages' conditions will be like? The murders, torture, and slavery in this feudal system are an open secret.

The attacks by SRA while conveniently supported by India, are a possible because of grassroots support caused by PPP's amazing governance of Sindh, with blessings of they-who-must-not-be-named.

It's like you and your kids lives are a joke to them.

Doesn't matter, Sindhis are now a minority in Sindh...

 

[Muhammad Saftain Anjum]

Lagta hai muje hi Politician banna pare ga.
Warna PPP/PTI/PML-N tu mulk ki khaber lene se rahe.

 

[RealNapster]

Sindhi nationalism is very strong in interior sindh but a lot of Sindhis are pro Pakistan. Even some of the supporters of sindhudesh and waving their flags, their still pro Pakistan but do it to support Sindhi nationalism as well. Ppp has been playing with Sindhi nationalism to get votes but majority Sindhi nationalist are still pro Pakistan.
In my area of sindh at least (it’s not ppp run it’s pmln f and harshly anti zardari area) the Sindhi nationalists do not hate other ethnic groups and are pro Pakistan.

Sindhudesh flag is more like a flag of resistance against being exploited. Like we seen it be waved when Sindhis raided Bahria town Karachi because they waved it to show their resistance against malik raiz who used his connections to basically steal the land from Sindhis who have been living in it for centuries.

Even 3000 Sindhis want Sindhu desh enough to take arms for it, we have a big big problem. As when you (as a state) kill among these 3000, each kill will multiply it's foot soldier by 5.

 

[Aijaz Kolachi]

Doesn't matter, Sindhis are now a minority in Sindh...

That is why there is a resentment against immigrants by natives in Sindh and it fuels anti-Pakistan sentiment among Sindhis. Which Jeay Sindh groups gather support from and PPP ones from the moderate Sindhi nationalists.

 

[TheSnakeEatingMarkhur]

For the last few years at least, if you drive through interior Sindh, not even too deep, just on the main bloody highway N5 you will regularly find Sindudesh flags flying around on houses or on streets. These flags are both new and years old.

I have even seen a few sizeable gatherings of Sindudesh supporters.

Look what a shithole the finanical capital of Pakistan is under PPP. Now just imagine what some random villages' conditions will be like? The murders, torture, and slavery in this feudal system are an open secret.

The attacks by SRA while conveniently supported by India, are a possible because of grassroots support caused by PPP's amazing governance of Sindh, with blessings of they-who-must-not-be-named.

It's like you and your kids lives are a joke to them.

They attacked coast gaurd yesterday in Karachi with IED.

 

[ARMalik]

For 75 years this is what these Generals have done to Pakistan. They created MQM to counter Sindh nationalist parties. They created religious and ethinic parties to counter one another in Sindh, in Baluchistan. They created iJi to counter PPP. They created Nawaz Sharif. They created Zardari. THE LIST IS ENDLESS. WHO IS GOING TO STOP THESE GENERALS FROM CONTINUOUSLY CREATING DESTABILIZATION IN PAKISTAN ?? Who appointed them to be the Judge, Jury and the executioner??

My earnest prayer to God from the bottom of my heart is that I pray that God punishes these people severely, and free our people from the clutches of the Evil. AMEEN !

 

[Amaa'n]

I will be honest here it's been a while since I traveled into remote areas of Sindh or Balochistan. my last visit was back in 2019. I have become a paper-pusher lately... as Khan sb said, 'mujhe office mein betha dia, ab mera wazaan barh giya hai'

I traveled extensively to project sites in Khuzdar, Lasbela, and interior sindh b.w the period of 2012 - 2018.

Traveling out of Hyderabad or at times Karachi, we would take N55, at Sehwan turn west, driving around 'Manchar jheel' and through the unmarked roads enter Khuzdar.

As you exit Sehwan and on other side, Hyderabad...all you would find are the flags of Sindhi Nationalists, now banned militant organization JSQM and SRA, painted on the walls. Every now and then they would hold protests or rallies but nothing in significant or a large crowd.

In Dadu or Moro region i did not witness this all lot, not sure why but then as you go towards Naushahro feroze, Bhria Road, Padidan, Bandhi you will start seeing the flags hoisted and painted on the walls.

Back in 2012-2015, (post killing of JSQM Chairman Bashir Qureshi) support had died down significantly . There was barely any shutdown of the national highways (N5 or N55)
but I remember that towards 2018 things started to pick up the pace again....there were gatherings, protests, flags etc.

I guess we dropped our guard down and allowed them to gather up again. Credit for this goes to Zardari sb who played on the other side of fence and allowed shafi barfat to hold protests in Sindh recently.... by 2020 things were back on track for these militant groups. By end of 2020 BLA announced support for SRA and they carried out their first grenade attack in Ghotki on Rangers vehicles in march 2021, followed by another attack in Karachi.

This is not exhaustive list but some of the areas where i witnessed significant support for Nationalists:

For the last few years at least, if you drive through interior Sindh, not even too deep, just on the main bloody highway N5 you will regularly find Sindudesh flags flying around on houses or on streets. These flags are both new and years old.

I have even seen a few sizeable gatherings of Sindudesh supporters.

Look what a shithole the finanical capital of Pakistan is under PPP. Now just imagine what some random villages' conditions will be like? The murders, torture, and slavery in this feudal system are an open secret.

The attacks by SRA while conveniently supported by India, are a possible because of grassroots support caused by PPP's amazing governance of Sindh, with blessings of they-who-must-not-be-named.

It's like you and your kids lives are a joke to them.

@Foxtrot Alpha has done great work on them, he can give us a better insight.

You are Indian?

It will be irrelevant if what he states is true....

 

[Amaa'n]

That is why there is a resentment against immigrants by natives in Sindh and it fuels anti-Pakistan sentiment among Sindhis. Which Jeay Sindh groups gather support from and PPP ones from the moderate Sindhi nationalists.

I have yet to come across a Nationalist come Militant who had a strong academic background. most of the support is from far flung areas where potable water is hard to come by let alone education.

again I can be wrong but Militancy in Sindh has yet to mature unlike Balochistan, where you will find students / grads picking up weapon to fight against the state.....

 

[Umair Nawaz]

If our armed forces cant prosecute the Zardari family then they can be assassinated too. Just an idea.

 

[Faqirze]

You haven't heard of much militant attacks from Sindhi separatists because they don't have a fighting spirit like the Balochis and Pashtuns do and are quite passive in nature. As long as the feudal system persists and inner Sindh stays underdeveloped, there will be resentment out there. But I don't see much happening anytime soon considering politics over here are largely controlled by politicians who hail from feudal families.

 

[jupiter2007]

For 75 years this is what these Generals have done to Pakistan. They created MQM to counter Sindh nationalist parties. They created religious and ethinic parties to counter one another in Sindh, in Baluchistan. They created iJi to counter PPP. They created Nawaz Sharif. They created Zardari. THE LIST IS ENDLESS. WHO IS GOING TO STOP THESE GENERALS FROM CONTINUOUSLY CREATING DESTABILIZATION IN PAKISTAN ?? Who appointed them to be the Judge, Jury and the executioner??

My earnest prayer to God from the bottom of my heart is that I pray that God punishes these people severely, and free our people from the clutches of the Evil. AMEEN !

It’s a long list, you have only mentioned few things and the stuff in Publicly known. They so much behind the scenes that public doesn’t know. These wolfs are hiding in flock of sheeps.

 

[ARMalik]

It’s a long list, you have only mentioned few things and the stuff in Publicly known. They so much behind the scenes that public doesn’t know. These wolfs are hiding in flock of sheeps.

No doubt the list is much much bigger. What Ayub Khan did to Fatima Jinnah, 1971 partition, Execution of Bhutto, execution of BB, the disastrous 9/11 terror war and so forth. THEY HAVE DONE TOO MUCH DESTRUCTION TO THIS COUNTRY.

 

[War Thunder]

Remove Zordari, Bilawal and any traces for their corrupt thug mafia in Sindh and you fix everything wrong with Sindh with one blow.