Should india talk directly to pakistani army?

[Puchtoon]

Pakistani army is the biggest stakeholder when it comes to india policy but can we bring them to the talking table ?

Some analyst suggested that with india, pak army is reluctant to come to table talks ,why is that?

Please share you views !

 

[IBRIS]

Ghorda ghass nayi khayega, tov vo jiyeh gaa kaiseh.!!

 

[livingdead]

no .. unless we get a military dictator like mushy in power there...

 

[Slayer786]

How can Pakistan army talk with India? There is no such protocol. President talks with President, PM talks with PM and FM talks with FM. And a General talks with a General.
It should be that India can send its General to Pakistan to talk with our COAS or he could be invited by the Indian Commanding General for talks.

 

[Alpha1]

Indians will come up with the same arguments that Pak army controls GoP

 

[livingdead]

How can Pakistan army talk with India? There is no such protocol. President talks with President, PM talks with PM and FM talks with FM. And a General talks with a General.
It should be that India can send its General to Pakistan to talk with our COAS or he could be invited by the Indian Commanding General for talks.

the protocol is one issue.. another is civvy authorities wont like it... back channel diplomacy can work.. we can appoint somebody to talk to secretly.

 

[Durrak]

The level of hatred between two rival forces won't let them come to table talk unless some interest is hidden in it ...

 

[livingdead]

The level of hatred between two rival forces won't let them come to table talk unless some interest is hidden in it ...

hatred does not work at general level, how do they work together in UN forces then?

 

[Durrak]

hatred does not work at general level, how do they work together in UN forces then?

It was general opinion not about India and Pakistan's rivalry ..

If you talk about UN forces somewhere the interest is hidden for the officials ... They are not angels

who will fight for anyone without any beneficial factor which attracts them ..

 

[Slayer786]

If both countries want to solve the problems, then only talks will help. No excuses like hatred or indecision. Both country can benefit so much more with peace. The whole world laughs at us that we are still enemies after 67 years.
Some sacrifices will have to be made on both sides but talking is the first step.
And it could start by back channel way. Which has been done before also. But we need strong leadership for that.

 

[Alpha1]

Germans and french and british and french were bitter enemies for centuries but now they are allies!

 

[Slayer786]

Germans and french and british and french were bitter enemies for centuries but now they are allies!

Yes and now they are selling weapons to us to use against each other and laughing at us at the same time.

 

[livingdead]

Germans and french and british and french were bitter enemies for centuries but now they are allies!

it took so many wars and advancement in society to realize that.. we will take some time too...

 

[Alpha1]

it took so many wars and advancement in society to realize that.. we will take some time too...

Next war will be nuclear so another war is not an option!

 

[Durrak]

Next war will be nuclear so another war is not an option!

There will be no chance of war if both of them work for their own country ... But they are busy in

filling their overloaded khazanay ...