Shame on you India, it was mutton not beef

[Joe Shearer]

Eye for an Eye

The rule of law. Not this primitive animal reaction. So much for the veneer of civilisation imparted by learning English. The rest is the same ugly stuff.

 

[Tipu7]

mutton not beef --- How does that matter?

There is bit difference.
Killing on beef is....... " Indian mob get angry when a Muslim arguably killed a cow and eat it to hurt Hindu feelings"
Killing on mutton....." Indian mob killed Muslim just on a rumor that a Muslim killed a cow which in reality he didn't."

My point is, that killing by mob just on a rumor is beyond ridiculous. Although there is no justification for either case, but issue turn worse when some one might kill you on just a rumor........pick the point

 

[Xenophon]

India is not the country of your forefathers!!Your forefathers' country was British Indian Empire or simply the British Raj which broke up into the present day Pakistan,Bangladesh,Myanmar(got separated in 1937)and India.So,technically speaking you don't have any right to speak on the internal matters of India which is a completely different country!!

So why is Akber , ashoka , shiva je , tipu etc . india's hero ? They were there even before British india .


And for that "technically speaking " thing . pata ni ye technical logic kahan chali jati ha while calling an animal your mother , consider her urine holy , while drinking that urine or putting dung on your forehead.

 

[SipahSalar]

Even if it was beef, you cant kill him!!!

 

[Joe Shearer]

Incident like this is blackspot on humanity in any part of the world. That's why people should not take seriously any religion.
Such incident is bound to happen, already happening and happened in past too in whole world.

Y E S !

 

[Peaceful Civilian]

B Usually though Muslims are known to indulging in killing of cows to insult Hindus.

Muslim should not slaughter cow in Hindu areas but I am talking about this particular incident.
This is wrong, because he didn't break law . Mob attacked him just based on rumors even let assume if he eat beef, Do you believe killing him is solution or drag him in court??

 

[Joe Shearer]

There is bit difference.
Killing on beef is....... " Indian mob get angry when a Muslim arguably killed a cow and eat it to hurt Hindu feelings"
Killing on mutton....." Indian mob killed Muslim just on a rumor that a Muslim killed a cow which in reality he didn't."

My point is, that killing by mob just on a rumor is beyond ridiculous. Although there is no justification for either case, but issue turn worse when some one might kill you on just a rumor........pick the point

Sorry.

There is NO difference. Killing a cow and eating it to hurt Hindu feelings DOES NOT JUSTIFY A BREACH OF THE LAW. It DOES NOT JUSTIFY ASSAULT, FORGET ABOUT MURDER.

"The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangha (RSS) has said that it should not be dragged into the Dadri lynching case and added that the people responsible for the crime should be punished."
In an interview to an English daily, RSS's All India Prachar Pramukh Manmohan Vaidya said that the incident could have happened because of fringe elements. He said it is an isolated incident and should be seen in isolation.
Vaidya said one should wait till a proper inquiry is conducted instead of levelling allegations.
Don't drag us in Dadri lynching case, says RSS | Business Standard News

Well, much though I hate them as an institution, he has a point - they have a point.

Blame it on the Muslim community which has a terrible reputation as a trouble making bunch. This time perhaps the man was innocent and did not kill a cow, so? The culprits will be punished, no? Usually though Muslims are known to indulging in killing of cows to insult Hindus.

How dare you condemn an entire community?

 

[Tipu7]

Sorry.

There is NO difference. Killing a cow and eating it to hurt Hindu feelings DOES NOT JUSTIFY A BREACH OF THE LAW. It DOES NOT JUSTIFY ASSAULT, FORGET ABOUT MURDER.

For some it might.
Do take time to read comments on official pages of times of India and Hindu.
Both related to current and past incident. You will understand a lot

 

[Samudra Manthan]

Muslim should not eat cow in Hindu areas but I am talking about this particular incident.
This is wrong, because he didn't break law . Mob attacked him just based on rumors even let assume if he eat beef, Do you believe killing him is solution or drag him in court?? I'll go with second choice.

Mob attacked him because it is so believable that Muslims would do such a thing. How did they earn such a reputation in the first place. If your communities reputation is so bad, who is responsible for it?

If the justice delivery mechanism in India was not to sclerotic then people would not have taken the law in their hand, but the truth of the matter is under secularism, Westernized Indian elites have gone on to formulate laws which has no bearing with justice or with the countries sociocultural background. Cow is sacred for Hindus. It is time Muslims and other idiots got that in their heads. This is India and not some godless commie country.

 

[Koovie]

1. Why are you addressing India as a whole?

2. Does it fu**ing matter what he ate?!

 

[Tipu7]

Mob attacked him because it is so believable that Muslims would do such a thing. How did they earn such a reputation in the first place. If your communities reputation is so bad, who is responsible for it?

If the justice delivery mechanism in India was not to sclerotic then people would not have taken the law in their hand, but the truth of the matter is under secularism, Westernized Indian elites have gone on to formulate laws which has no bearing with justice or with the countries sociocultural background. Cow is sacred for Hindus. It is time Muslims and other idiots got that in their heads. This is India and not some godless commie country.

One who were in mob
were of your type and mentality.......

 

[Rasengan]

Dream on. You were right to call it fantastic; now look up the word. It's only a pack of bigots, the ideological equivalent of the people who demanded Pakistan, who support the Two Nation Theory and are responsible for our present troubles. They will be history. And don't peer too hard into the tea leaves. It might show you visions that give you nightmares.

Cato advocated a famous proverb which can describe your message perfectly well:"Anger at lies can last for ever, although anger at truth will never last". Please visit the good doctor in the evening for the purchase of prescription drugs to calm your high blood pressure. Those ruffians and bigoted individuals are increasing in your society where old men are hacked to death by a lynching mob. This topic is not centered on Pakistan, however I am ecstatic and extremely grateful that our forefathers supported the ideological philosophy of the Two Nation Theory, because we Muslims don't have the misfortune of becoming downtrodden by Hindu nutters. Like Bertrand Russell said:"Men are born ignorant and not stupid. However they are made stupid by education". When the educated masses of India elected a criminal as their Prime Minister, then the issue of secularism and social harmony was flushed down the latrine. Personally there is no need for me to dream, because the lynching of a old defenseless man was a reality Please continue these incidences and inflame the seed of hatred which would lead to anarchy on a destructive scale.

 

[Joe Shearer]

Drawing cartoons is forbidden. It's against law and punishable.

Where? There is no such law in India or in the UK.

In India is there any law of banning food? Beef?

Yes. Some states have that. There is no nation-wide law. Kashmir has a ban, for instance. Engineer Rashid broke that ban.

Then killing on hoax by mobs? And in reality rule was never broken?

What are you arguing? Even if the rule was broken, killing the rule-breaker is murder. What exactly are you trying to say? Do you understand it yourself?

So is burning of geeta. Indians have burnt Quran several times, any incident in Pakistan.?

What about the burning of the Geeta? There is no law against it, and there has been no reaction against its burning.

So is genocide of minorities. Dozens of genocides in India? None in Pakistan.

Please don't talk rubbish.

Your country do all this S H I T.

And please drag your sorry ar*e out of this conversation. You are not contributing in any useful way.

 

[Samudra Manthan]

How dare you condemn an entire community?

Who are you? You are one diseased old man with inherent hatred for everything this country stands for. Its people, its civilization, its religion, its values. You are the kind that believes Muslims tyrants came to India to emancipate it from its cruel upper caste. You are the kind of rascal that believes that British ushered in egalitarianism in India. You who condemn India as a barbaric place which was civilized by British and Mughals, how dare you dare to question me?

One who were in mob
were of your type and mentality.......

Yes, most likely. They are the ones who speak what they think and do not have the habit of speaking from both sides of their mouth unlike Pakistanis.

 

[Joe Shearer]

For some it might.
Do take time to read comments on official pages of times of India and Hindu.
Both related to current and past incident. You will understand a lot

Everybody is free to comment. They are also free to keep to the law of the land. They are not free to violate the law. Their comments don't matter a ****. Their behaviour does.