There seems to be a train of thought among some Muslims that the Saudis are just the reluctant organizers of hajj, graciously taking on the responsibility due to their strong moral fiber and out of the goodness of their hearts. Therefore, they find it inappropriate to criticize Saudi incompetence and utter disregard for the lives of pilgrims, despite repeated tragedies and the high cost in human life.
Well the truth is that Hajj is big business. And the Saudis are the almost singular beneficiary of it. This year the Saudis stand to make a cool $8.5 BILLION for the few days of the Hajj event, alone. Add to that the Omrah pilgrims and Saudi Arabia rakes in tens of BILLIONs of $ from the pilgrimage industry every year.
People from poor South asian and African countries sometimes save up for years to be able to afford this trip. Is it too much to expect the Saudi beneficiaries of their hard earned money to prevent these pilgrims to be killed in their hundreds, once every few years?
http://www.economist.com/news/busin...big-businessand-getting-bigger-pennies-heaven
Religious tourism
Pennies from heaven
Pilgrimages are a big business—and getting bigger
From the print edition
This is the way, I believe
MECCANS say they do not need agriculture, for God has given them the pilgrimage as their annual crop. Millions of Muslims are now setting out to take part in this year’s
haj, a trek to Islam’s holiest site, in Saudi Arabia.
The haj, which all Muslims aspire to do at least once in their lifetimes, now brings in $16.5 billion, around 3% of Saudi GDP. Jerusalem, a holy city for all three Abrahamic religions, also draws crowds of pilgrims, and huge numbers of Shia Muslims visit shrines in Iraq. The UN’s World Tourism Organisation estimates that over 300m people go on pilgrimages each year. Countless others visit shrines or sacred places.
The numbers are increasing because the Middle East’s growing middle class means more tourists, three-quarters of whom travel within the region. Abundant tumult is less likely to deter those travelling for religious reasons than ordinary tourists. Shia pilgrims still flock to Karbala and Najaf in Iraq, despite the threat of bombs. “The person who sees their holiday as a cultural experience will be put off by bad security, but the believer will not,” says Kevin Wright, an observer of new tourist markets.
Faith-based tourism in the region dates back to Moses leading his people through Sinai “with God as their tour guide”, jokes Peter Tarlow, a travel consultant who is also a rabbi. In medieval times Venetian traders took Europeans on trips to the Holy Land. Israel has long promoted religious tourism. Yet most countries have been slow to profit from their religious sites.
One exception is
the haj, which has both expanded and gone upmarket. Oil wealth and a rising identification with Islam have made it a huge moneymaker. Posh hotel chains have piled into Mecca, including Raffles, which in 2010 opened the spa-equipped Makkah Palace.
Souvenir shops do such a roaring trade that some only bother to open during the haj. Travel firms in the tourists’ home countries do nicely too. In Egypt packages cost up to 80,000 Egyptian pounds ($11,450), according to Reda Dunia, who runs a travel agency in Cairo.
Some pilgrims grumble about the rising cost of performing their religious duty. Airlines and hotels put up their prices during religious holidays. Nevertheless, says Mr Dunia, Muslims often save for years for their
haj, “so most of them are willing to spend money on the experience.” Some tour operators now offer packages that include leisure pursuits alongside the religion. This helps to boost the price tag and might also persuade agnostics and atheists to visit holy sites just for the cultural experience.
Countries lacking their own religious landmarks are now trying to create them. In June Dubai’s authorities announced plans to build a Holy Koran theme park, with walls depicting stories from the Koran and a garden of plants mentioned in it.
Dubai is betting that the pious are as profitable as the shoppers and fun-seekers that it currently attracts.
From the print edition: Business
