Remembering non Muslims who chose Pakistan over India.

[Kompromat]

https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=10158591056487663&id=146828502662

We tell the story of non Muslim heroes who chose Pakistan over India during the Pakistan Movement.

Share - Like - Follow Pakistan Defence for more original stories.

 

[My-Analogous]

Non muslims who "chose" to make the move from India to what is known as the modern nation state of Pakistan now or chose to stay there ?

Start Survey in Kashmir, Punjab.and Haryana and they still want to live with us.

 

[padamchen]

Non muslims who "chose" to make the move from India to what is known as the modern nation state of Pakistan now or chose to stay there ?

Technically that still counts as them choosing Pakistan over India.

Like Indian Muslims choosing India over Pakistan.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Baibars_1260]

Eminent Parsis of Pakistan

1. Dorabji Patel ( Link )
2. Bapsi Sidhwa ( Link )
3. Byram Avari ( Link )

 

[gulli]

Start Survey in Kashmir, Punjab.and Haryana and they still want to live with us.

Don't know about Kashmir or Punjab but as a Hariyanvi, we have totally different thoughts as presented by you. Though we will love to have peace equation among both country.

 

[magra]

Eminent Parsis of Pakistan

1. Dorabji Patel ( Link )
2. Bapsi Sidhwa ( Link )
3. Byram Avari ( Link )

Eminent Parsis of India - Dina Wadia (Jinnah's daughter) & Nusli Wadia (Jinnah's grandson)

 

[padamchen]

Eminent Parsis of India - Dina Wadia (Jinnah's daughter) & Nusli Wadia (Jinnah's grandson)

Technically Dina was not a Parsi.

Indian yes. Always.

Cheers, Doc

 

[magra]

Technically Dina was not a Parsi.

Indian yes. Always.

Cheers, Doc

Dina was a Parsi's daughter, Parsi's wife, Parsi's mother.
Just because she had a half a blood of a non-Parsi, how can you say she was not a Parsi.

 

[padamchen]

Dina was a Parsi's daughter, Parsi's wife, Parsi's mother.
Just because she had a half a blood of a non-Parsi, how can you say she was not a Parsi.

Because I am.a Parsi.

And you are not.

Nor was Dina.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Death Professor]

clean the thread, it's getting derailed, and about to get derailed even more, like always.

 

[Baibars_1260]

Eminent Parsis of India - Dina Wadia (Jinnah's daughter) & Nusli Wadia (Jinnah's grandson)

Wish I could reply to you in Urdu, and break my vow. You persist in emotional blackmail.
Yes, these were Parsis connected with Pakistan and stayed behind in India. That was the brutal irony of Partition, and many families were divided, not just those of Jinnah. Can we move on? Those who moved here left behind a whole generation of their heritage, and those who left Pakistan for India left behind hundreds of years of their heritage .
We are discussing those who belonged to Pakistan and chose Pakistan.

 

[magra]

Because I am.a Parsi.

And you are not.

Nor was Dina.

Cheers, Doc

Doc - yeh kya logic hua.

Wish I could reply to you in Urdu, and break my vow. You persist in emotional blackmail.
Yes, these were Parsis connected with Pakistan and stayed behind in India. That was the brutal irony of Partition, and many families were divided, not just those of Jinnah. Can we move on? Those who moved here left behind a whole generation of their heritage, and those who left Pakistan for India left behind hundreds of years of their heritage .
We are discussing those who belonged to Pakistan and chose Pakistan.

If stating truth is amount to blackmailing, then you know you are on thin ground.

 

[padamchen]

Doc - yeh kya logic hua.

This is what it is.

Technically, per the true Zoroastrian orthodoxy, Ruttie ceased to be Mazdayasni too.

It's only over the last 10-15 years that Indian courts have forced their pseudo-secular liberal interpretation of personal faith on to us.

Simply put, we donot even accept Juddin blood as transfusions, and arrange for Zoroastrian donors.

You are saying a half Muslim is a Parsi?

Cheers, Doc

 

[magra]

This is what it is.

Technically, per the true Zoroastrian orthodoxy, Ruttie ceased to be Mazdayasni too.

It's only over the last 10-15 years that Indian courts have forced their pseudo-secular liberal interpretation of personal faith on to us.

Simply put, we donot even accept Juddin blood as transfusions, and arrange for Zoroastrian donors.

You are saying a half Muslim is a Parsi?

Cheers, Doc

Doc - you need to come out of a patriarchal mindset. Parsis need to consider men and women as equal.

If Ruttie ceased to be Parsi due to her marriage to a Muslim, then by your own logic, Dina ceased to be a Muslim due to her marriage to a Parsi.

 

[Baibars_1260]

If stating truth is amount to blackmailing, then you know you are on thin ground.

I will stick to the topic of this thread, but two can play this game of emotional blackmail by stating the truth .
Join me here on this thread :

The Roorkee Internment Camp

The Roorkee Internment Camp The following account is based off a recent interview I had with a 87 year old survivor of the Pakistan Civil War who was interned for two years by the Indian Army from December 1971 to January 1974. To protect the identity of the person certain personal details...

defence.pk

Also :

Why would Pakistanis wish to visit India ?

It has been two years since all road, rail, and air links between India and Pakistan have been severed ( Link ) . The only Pakistanis visiting India are minorities from Pakistan on religious pilgrimage. (We are not discussing a reverse flow of Sikh and Hindu pilgrims from India). There have...

defence.pk