Professor of Sindh university: why all other nationalities people are allowed to work&trade in Sindh

[Irfan Baloch]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1258701789181939712

silly professor should be answered with a single world.
its called globalization and being part of a bigger world community.
be open and prosper or die in stagnation.
nationalism and xenophobia will only make sense if there is something to brag about. with malnourished slavish illiterate population either drowning or begging for water, food and work constantly at the mercy of religious thugs and feudal lords.. there is not much left to complain about because all these outsiders wont find anything to "steal".
the only blessing or good thing that happened to this part of Pakistan is the immigrants from India at the time of partition.

 

[Maula Jatt]

They don't get jobs because they keep electing a MAFIA called PPP which has not done any development. Destroyed education and Police and any private company worth its salt would hire on merit not because some one is Sindhi or pathan or Punjabi. Secondly visit famous areas of Lahore. All are being over taken by Pathans. No Punjabi will be seen complaining. And they should never. Pakistan belongs to all. Who every knows how to do businesses and provide service and make profit in entire Pakistan.

I don't care if they are Pakistani Pashtun, it's their land too just as much as ours, but no afghan allowed, My fear is just like in Islamabad some are afghans who hate our people yet continue to do namak harami by earning from the land that they bad mouth and when you f with em, they start laarping as from Mardan, even though the dude probably has an afghan flag at home

Sorry no afghan should be tolerated in Lahore, anyone showing the afghan flag, identifying as afghan national should be kicked the F out

 

[Aijaz Kolachi]

Kulanch(kolachi) was a bulach tribe and will always be.. IT WILL NEVER BE SINdHI..folks like u are an outsider in karachi and will always remain so...know ur stature and dont transgress.. who ruled it when is irrelative.

You don't even know my background but thanks for revealing your own. And ya state will.decide how to fence you.. its not an intra party issue.

Ethnic origin is irrelevant, Sindhi is an assimilation based identity. They spoke Sindhi as first language.

Well, Talpur are ethnically Baloch. Kalhoro claim Arab descent. Samma were Yadav Rajputs. Soomro too are either Arab or Parmar Rajputs from Rajasthan.

Sindhi is an assimilation based identity, these all dynasties spoke Sindhi as first language and owned Sindh.

I understand thier concerns but I want solution from Sindhi nationalists, that can help our country (which means they can't kick out non Sindhis out of Sindh, only time that happened in Pakistan was probably in Balochistan with Punjabis, we don't want that again) and also alleviate Thier concerns

They have genuine concerns and we need to find a middle ground

I suggest a card for new arrivals to the province

We are satisfied with an confederation like it was promised to representatives of Sindh in 1940 Lahore resolution on which Sindh assembly passed the resolution in 1943 under Saeen GM Syed. But as we know nothing in that resolution was fulfilled since 75 years of the independence of this country.

Every city changes - peshwar was hindko/Punjabi majority now it's associated with Pashtuns

NYC is mutli ethnic, Mumbai is multi ethnic, mambasa is multi ethnic

Every port city that ever existed is multi ethnic cause it's supposed to be like that - I don't know why Sindhi nationalists can't understand it? It's the most normal of changes to happen

Karachi is home to ansaris, Siddiqui, Jutts, Arain, Afridi, kakar, jatoi and soomros - that's normal if you're running a port city

I acknowledge it as historical Sindhi land, thanks for sharing but like every port that ever existed in the world it's made of every ethnicity, there's no need to throw tantrums over it and make it a big issue

And her point was Punjabi and Pashtun in Sindh village's etc, I know that Punjabis have always contributed to Sindh wether by farming or buisness, work hard and learn the language, rarely have caused any issues for local people, than except for xenophobia, I can't understand the issue

No one says Sindhis can't come to other parts of the country, this debate is almost non existent elsewhere in the country

But because Sindh is home to sea access, demographics issues have caused problems I guess

I respect that you understand our perspective. But many of people don't know the history or facts on the ground. Not only Karachi but Hyderabad, Mirpurkhas, Nawabshah, Shahdadpur, Tando Adam and Tando Alhayar has non-Sindhi majority. It's an threat to our demographics and we have seen how hostile the immigrants especially Hindustanis have been to native people.

 

[-blitzkrieg-]

Ethnic origin is irrelevant, Sindhi is an assimilation based identity. They spoke Sindhi as first language.

Lol.. so whatever is beyond you is irrelevant.. stfu.. and know ur okaat..every identity is assimilation based till theres a nationalist in its crowd...I know people of this tribe first hand.. and they speak local dialect of baluchi.