PLA Navy patrols Bashi Channel between Taiwan and Philippines

[Zero_wing]

One there were one its been give to the MECO office to deliver to the family of the dead poacher but they refuse so well it can be help if they refuse sir the NBI is investigating it so they going some ballistic test on the weapons of the ship and shady wow guy coming from one of the shadiest governments who hides evidence on killings of millions of people just called my government shady man that is so funny a criminal calling person a criminal

 

[gambit]

Last time. UNCLOS cannot abrogate China's pre-existing maritime rights.

Go read the section on historic claims in UNCLOS.

Why can't you guys understand something so simple. UNCLOS clearly states it is not retroactive. If it were, China would never have signed and ratified it.

UNCLOS can never take pre-existing maritime territory away from China. Do you get it now?

Again...You distorted your source. CNAS may be a real organization and have a respectable reputation, but in no way in that article did CNAS approved China's historical claims to the entirety of the South China Sea region. If it was that easy, there would never be an international dispute in the first place.

As usual, you may brought on sources to give yourself a facade of being fair and impartial, but anyone who actually read your sources will recognize your deliberate mislead.

 

[Zero_wing]

Again...You distorted your source. CNAS may be a real organization and have a respectable reputation, but in no way in that article did CNAS approved China's historical claims to the entirety of the South China Sea region. If it was that easy, there would never be an international dispute in the first place.

As usual, you may brought on sources to give yourself a facade of being fair and impartial, but anyone who actually read your sources will recognize your deliberate mislead.

I guess is trying to make an idiotic issue to a smart one

 

[gambit]

Its what Chinese domestic law is claiming, No reason for Philippines to adhere to it, you conveniently missed quoting the word "Chinese", and quoted it out of context wonder why.

Because he thinks that no one will actually read his sources. Like I said, he brought on sources only to give the facade of being fair, not that he actually reads them and verify the contents within.

 

[Martian2]

UNCLOS Article 15 on "historic title"

https://www.un.org/depts/los/convention_agreements/texts/unclos/part2.htm

"Article15

Delimitation of the territorial sea between States

with opposite or adjacent coasts

Where the coasts of two States are opposite or adjacent to each other, neither of the two States is entitled, failing agreement between them to the contrary, to extend its territorial sea beyond the median line every point of which is equidistant from the nearest points on the baselines from which the breadth of the territorial seas of each of the two States is measured. The above provision does not apply, however, where it is necessary by reason of historic title or other special circumstances to delimit the territorial seas of the two States in a way which is at variance therewith."

----------

China's 1948 nine-dash line map falls within historic title exception under Article 15 of UNCLOS

 

[Pinoy]

where is the pinoy president's signed and sealed letter of apology?

where is the pinoy government's acceptance for a joint investigation is there is nothing for you to hide?

where is the "ramming" evidence?
where is the vid?

if there is nothing for you to hide where are all these crucial evidences claimed by your incapable and shady government?

So much for the apology. If Taiwan don't accept the deepest sincere apology that our government gave to them then FINE, who the HELL they think they are? LMAO!

Obviously China is trying to incite Taiwan for their own advantage.

The matter is still under investigation. So If you can't wait just CRY OUT LOUD LMAO!

 

[shuttler]

Again...You distorted your source. CNAS may be a real organization and have a respectable reputation, but in no way in that article did CNAS approved China's historical claims to the entirety of the South China Sea region. If it was that easy, there would never be an international dispute in the first place.

As usual, you may brought on sources to give yourself a facade of being fair and impartial, but anyone who actually read your sources will recognize your deliberate mislead.

show us where is the CNA's disapproval of China's historical claims!

 

[gambit]

UNCLOS Article 15 on "historic title"

https://www.un.org/depts/los/convention_agreements/texts/unclos/part2.htm

"Article15

Delimitation of the territorial sea between States

with opposite or adjacent coasts

Where the coasts of two States are opposite or adjacent to each other, neither of the two States is entitled, failing agreement between them to the contrary, to extend its territorial sea beyond the median line every point of which is equidistant from the nearest points on the baselines from which the breadth of the territorial seas of each of the two States is measured. The above provision does not apply, however, where it is necessary by reason of historic title or other special circumstances to delimit the territorial seas of the two States in a way which is at variance therewith."

In order for the highlighted to be effective, China must have equally historical agreements with neighboring countries. Sorry, but intimidation does not count.

 

[shuttler]

So much for the apology. If Taiwan don't accept the deepest sincere apology that our government gave to them then FINE, who the HELL they think they are? LMAO!

Obviously China is trying to incite Taiwan for their own advantage.

The matter is still under investigation. So If you can't wait just CRY OUT LOUD LMAO!

Apology can be done in different forms. The formal apology for the head of state of a country is regarded as most important （and of course the wording in the apology matters too）. So far the Pinoy President has not shown his sincerity!

Our governmemt has been keeping a low profile on the matter. We are playing an observation role.

What is the Pinoy government hiding from the world?

 

[Martian2]

In order for the highlighted to be effective, China must have equally historical agreements with neighboring countries. Sorry, but intimidation does not count.

China's undisputed 50-year historic title to South China Sea

50 years of acquiescence to China's 1948 map counts as historic title. Look up "implicit waiver" in a law book.

In the United States, you only need ten years for an easement under common law. Fifty years is rock solid historic title.

 

[shuttler]

In order for the highlighted to be effective, China must have equally historical agreements with neighboring countries. Sorry, but intimidation does not count.

History is history unique to a place or country
what are the historical agreements with other country needed for america to prove its territory?
We are being intimated and bullied by our neighbours and usa. Get the facts straight!

 

[Sonyuke_Songpaisan]

And your nation is failure of humanity so tell me how many need to die to preserve mao power i mga gago pala kayo eh! palibhasa hindi kayo tao

Fail country. a country that is proud of being the servant of west shamless

 

[Zero_wing]

History is history unique to a place or country
what historical agreement is needed for america to prove its territory?
We are being intimated any bullied by our neighbours and usa. Get the facts straight!

Wow the world largest military with a nuke arsenal is (bullying and stealing) being bullied by its neighbors and US why not add the world to your list!

 

[Pinoy]

Apology can be done in different forms. The formal apology for the head of state of a country is regarded as most important （and of course the wording in the apology matters too）. So far the Pinoy President has not shown his sincerity!

Our governmemt has been keeping a low profile on the matter. We are not sending any military ship for the assist.

What is the Pinoy government hiding from the world?

Actually I think it is not an apology they want. It is international recognition as a sovereign state and a territory with international influence. We've gone extra mile for them. Too much is enough. The problem is their media and politicians.

Insincere Taiwanese leader politicizing poacher

 

[Zero_wing]

Fail country. a country that is proud of being the servant of west shamless

Wow sounds to me your in to **** video you can't even back that up face it buddy your just puppet a drone of the party elite why they are getting richer your getting poorer same in the brain really. Your comments like the majority of chinese Imperialist comments here are nothing more than racist arrogance its cultural thing with you people to make comment like that well it does not make you superior it just makes you look ignorant and dumb.