A New Kind of Church Crowd
So, the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia (ROCOR) a group started by folks who fled Russia after the 1917 revolution is suddenly getting a lot of new faces. We’re talking guys from all over: ex-Protestants, former atheists, even some who just felt lost. A 2023 report from the Orthodox Studies Institute says conversions to Orthodox churches jumped 80% since before COVID, and 60% of these newbies are men. That’s up from 54% in 2019. Pew Research backs this up: 64% of Orthodox Christians in the U.S. are now guys, compared to 46% back in 2007. That’s a big shift.
Take Father Moses McPherson in Georgetown, Texas. His Church of the Mother of God has tripled in size in just 18 months, with 75 new baptisms recently. Most of these folks? Young dudes. Theodore, a software engineer, is one of them. He’s got a good job, a happy marriage, but still felt something was missing. He told me society shames guys for wanting traditional roles like being the provider while his wife stays home. He sees that as “toxic” nonsense and found a home in Orthodoxy, where those old-school values feel celebrated.
What’s So “Manly” About It?
Here’s the deal: these guys are drawn to Orthodoxy because it feels hardcore. Think standing for hours during services (no cozy pews here), fasting for weeks sometimes 40 days straight and diving into a faith that demands discipline. It’s not your typical Sunday morning with a coffee bar and a rock band. Emmanuel Castillo, a 32-year-old ex-wrestler, put it bluntly: his old Protestant church felt like “Saturday night at a bar” with its loud music and chill vibes. He wanted something deeper, tougher. He found it in Orthodoxy’s ancient roots, which he says go back to the earliest Christians.
Emmanuel’s story is wild. He started reading the Bible while guarding al-Qaeda prisoners at Guantanamo Bay. That’s where he first felt a pull toward faith. But it was Orthodoxy’s vibe strict, serious, with priests who feel like “father figures” that sealed the deal. He says they’re strong in every way: spiritually, mentally, even physically.
Then there’s Father Moses himself. This guy’s a former roofer who’s all about that tough-guy life. He posts YouTube videos lifting weights to heavy metal, poking fun at “unmanly” stuff like skinny jeans or eating soup (yeah, soup don’t ask). He’s got this whole “be a real man” shtick, pushing big families, saying no to contraception, and calling out things like masturbation as weak. For him, Orthodoxy is about balance tough but grounded, not some touchy-feely worship session.
Why Now? Blame the Culture
This isn’t just about church. It’s about what’s happening in the world. A lot of these guys are part of the “anti-woke” crowd, fed up with what they see as a culture gone soft—think feminism, secularism, or churches that feel more like community centers. Elissa Bjeletich Davis, a Greek Orthodox podcaster, says some of these converts see Orthodoxy as this “military, rigid, masculine” thing, almost like they’re channeling old-school Puritans.
Russia plays a big role in this too. Vladimir Putin’s out there quoting the Bible, diving into icy rivers for Epiphany, and pitching Russia as the last stand for Christian values. Some American guys eat that up. They see Russia as this tough, traditional place fighting the “decadent” West. Patriarch Kirill, the head of the Russian Orthodox Church, even called the Ukraine war a “Holy War” against Western values. Now, some ROCOR priests, like Father John Whiteford, say that’s been twisted out of context, but the vibe still pulls guys in.
The pandemic didn’t help or maybe it did, depending on how you look at it. When COVID hit, a lot of churches shut down, but some ROCOR parishes stayed open, defying lockdowns. That drew guys like Buck Johnson, a 25-year firefighter and podcast host. Buck, covered in tattoos, wasn’t sure he’d fit in, but he found a community that didn’t care about his ink and stood firm on its beliefs. That kind of backbone resonated with him.
The internet’s a big player too. YouTube, podcasts, X posts they’re spreading Orthodoxy to guys who’d never step foot in a church otherwise. Matthew Ryan, a 41-year-old science teacher, stumbled across Orthodoxy after a YouTube comment about good and evil led him to a video of a Protestant visiting an Orthodox church. He was an atheist before, but the history, structure, and realness of it hooked him.
The Flip Side: Not Everyone’s Thrilled
Not everyone’s on board with this trend. Some Orthodox folks worry these new guys are missing the point. Elissa Davis says some converts treat Orthodoxy like it’s this macho, authoritarian club, not a faith about humility and serving others. Lena Zezulin, a lifelong ROCOR member, has bigger concerns. She’s seen far-right types think white nationalists show up at ROCOR churches, drawn to the conservative stance and Putin fandom. A 2022 NPR report flagged this too, noting how some parishes have become magnets for extreme ideologies.
Lena’s story hits hard. Her parents helped start a ROCOR parish that welcomed all kinds of people, even non-Christians. But she left for a different Orthodox church (the Orthodox Church in America) when her priest wouldn’t condemn Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. That’s a real tension ROCOR’s ties to Russia can make things messy, especially when politics creep in.
Then there’s the risk of cherry-picking. Some guys love Orthodoxy’s tough-guy image but skip over its call to be humble or serve others. Zachary Garris, writing for American Reformer, gets it he sees why men want tradition but thinks Orthodoxy’s focus on icons and rituals can overshadow the Bible. He’s pushing for a “masculine Protestantism” instead, rooted in scripture.
What’s It All Mean?
This whole thing is part of a bigger picture. Young guys are searching for meaning in a world that feels like it’s spinning out of control tech overload, secular vibes, and a culture that sometimes seems to dunk on traditional masculinity. Orthodoxy’s got this edge: it’s growing, it’s younger (average age 42), and it’s holding steady while other churches shrink. Trevin Wax points out that Orthodoxy’s small only 676,000 people in the U.S. but it’s punching above its weight.
For guys like Emmanuel, Orthodoxy’s priests are like Jesus: strong but sacrificial, not “soft” like some modern pastors. But there’s a risk here turning a 2,000-year-old faith into a meme about being a “real man” can miss the deeper point. Orthodoxy’s supposed to be about love, humility, and wrestling with your soul, not just flexing your biceps.
Wrapping It Up
So yeah, young American guys are joining Russian Orthodox churches, chasing this “absurd manliness” that feels like an antidote to a world they don’t vibe with. It’s about discipline, tradition, and a faith that doesn’t bend to modern trends. But it’s also messy some are drawn to the wrong stuff, like far-right politics or a macho fantasy that doesn’t quite fit the gospel. As ROCOR plans new churches to handle this wave of converts, they’ve got a challenge: keep the faith’s heart intact while welcoming guys who might be here for more than just spiritual growth. It’s a wild ride, and it’s only getting started.
So, the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia (ROCOR) a group started by folks who fled Russia after the 1917 revolution is suddenly getting a lot of new faces. We’re talking guys from all over: ex-Protestants, former atheists, even some who just felt lost. A 2023 report from the Orthodox Studies Institute says conversions to Orthodox churches jumped 80% since before COVID, and 60% of these newbies are men. That’s up from 54% in 2019. Pew Research backs this up: 64% of Orthodox Christians in the U.S. are now guys, compared to 46% back in 2007. That’s a big shift.
Take Father Moses McPherson in Georgetown, Texas. His Church of the Mother of God has tripled in size in just 18 months, with 75 new baptisms recently. Most of these folks? Young dudes. Theodore, a software engineer, is one of them. He’s got a good job, a happy marriage, but still felt something was missing. He told me society shames guys for wanting traditional roles like being the provider while his wife stays home. He sees that as “toxic” nonsense and found a home in Orthodoxy, where those old-school values feel celebrated.
What’s So “Manly” About It?
Here’s the deal: these guys are drawn to Orthodoxy because it feels hardcore. Think standing for hours during services (no cozy pews here), fasting for weeks sometimes 40 days straight and diving into a faith that demands discipline. It’s not your typical Sunday morning with a coffee bar and a rock band. Emmanuel Castillo, a 32-year-old ex-wrestler, put it bluntly: his old Protestant church felt like “Saturday night at a bar” with its loud music and chill vibes. He wanted something deeper, tougher. He found it in Orthodoxy’s ancient roots, which he says go back to the earliest Christians.
Emmanuel’s story is wild. He started reading the Bible while guarding al-Qaeda prisoners at Guantanamo Bay. That’s where he first felt a pull toward faith. But it was Orthodoxy’s vibe strict, serious, with priests who feel like “father figures” that sealed the deal. He says they’re strong in every way: spiritually, mentally, even physically.
Then there’s Father Moses himself. This guy’s a former roofer who’s all about that tough-guy life. He posts YouTube videos lifting weights to heavy metal, poking fun at “unmanly” stuff like skinny jeans or eating soup (yeah, soup don’t ask). He’s got this whole “be a real man” shtick, pushing big families, saying no to contraception, and calling out things like masturbation as weak. For him, Orthodoxy is about balance tough but grounded, not some touchy-feely worship session.
Why Now? Blame the Culture
This isn’t just about church. It’s about what’s happening in the world. A lot of these guys are part of the “anti-woke” crowd, fed up with what they see as a culture gone soft—think feminism, secularism, or churches that feel more like community centers. Elissa Bjeletich Davis, a Greek Orthodox podcaster, says some of these converts see Orthodoxy as this “military, rigid, masculine” thing, almost like they’re channeling old-school Puritans.
Russia plays a big role in this too. Vladimir Putin’s out there quoting the Bible, diving into icy rivers for Epiphany, and pitching Russia as the last stand for Christian values. Some American guys eat that up. They see Russia as this tough, traditional place fighting the “decadent” West. Patriarch Kirill, the head of the Russian Orthodox Church, even called the Ukraine war a “Holy War” against Western values. Now, some ROCOR priests, like Father John Whiteford, say that’s been twisted out of context, but the vibe still pulls guys in.
The pandemic didn’t help or maybe it did, depending on how you look at it. When COVID hit, a lot of churches shut down, but some ROCOR parishes stayed open, defying lockdowns. That drew guys like Buck Johnson, a 25-year firefighter and podcast host. Buck, covered in tattoos, wasn’t sure he’d fit in, but he found a community that didn’t care about his ink and stood firm on its beliefs. That kind of backbone resonated with him.
The internet’s a big player too. YouTube, podcasts, X posts they’re spreading Orthodoxy to guys who’d never step foot in a church otherwise. Matthew Ryan, a 41-year-old science teacher, stumbled across Orthodoxy after a YouTube comment about good and evil led him to a video of a Protestant visiting an Orthodox church. He was an atheist before, but the history, structure, and realness of it hooked him.
The Flip Side: Not Everyone’s Thrilled
Not everyone’s on board with this trend. Some Orthodox folks worry these new guys are missing the point. Elissa Davis says some converts treat Orthodoxy like it’s this macho, authoritarian club, not a faith about humility and serving others. Lena Zezulin, a lifelong ROCOR member, has bigger concerns. She’s seen far-right types think white nationalists show up at ROCOR churches, drawn to the conservative stance and Putin fandom. A 2022 NPR report flagged this too, noting how some parishes have become magnets for extreme ideologies.
Lena’s story hits hard. Her parents helped start a ROCOR parish that welcomed all kinds of people, even non-Christians. But she left for a different Orthodox church (the Orthodox Church in America) when her priest wouldn’t condemn Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. That’s a real tension ROCOR’s ties to Russia can make things messy, especially when politics creep in.
Then there’s the risk of cherry-picking. Some guys love Orthodoxy’s tough-guy image but skip over its call to be humble or serve others. Zachary Garris, writing for American Reformer, gets it he sees why men want tradition but thinks Orthodoxy’s focus on icons and rituals can overshadow the Bible. He’s pushing for a “masculine Protestantism” instead, rooted in scripture.
What’s It All Mean?
This whole thing is part of a bigger picture. Young guys are searching for meaning in a world that feels like it’s spinning out of control tech overload, secular vibes, and a culture that sometimes seems to dunk on traditional masculinity. Orthodoxy’s got this edge: it’s growing, it’s younger (average age 42), and it’s holding steady while other churches shrink. Trevin Wax points out that Orthodoxy’s small only 676,000 people in the U.S. but it’s punching above its weight.
For guys like Emmanuel, Orthodoxy’s priests are like Jesus: strong but sacrificial, not “soft” like some modern pastors. But there’s a risk here turning a 2,000-year-old faith into a meme about being a “real man” can miss the deeper point. Orthodoxy’s supposed to be about love, humility, and wrestling with your soul, not just flexing your biceps.
Wrapping It Up
So yeah, young American guys are joining Russian Orthodox churches, chasing this “absurd manliness” that feels like an antidote to a world they don’t vibe with. It’s about discipline, tradition, and a faith that doesn’t bend to modern trends. But it’s also messy some are drawn to the wrong stuff, like far-right politics or a macho fantasy that doesn’t quite fit the gospel. As ROCOR plans new churches to handle this wave of converts, they’ve got a challenge: keep the faith’s heart intact while welcoming guys who might be here for more than just spiritual growth. It’s a wild ride, and it’s only getting started.
Last edited:
