What's new

Philippines hits China over ‘10-dash line’ map

Problem is that in this atlas 1904, chinese stated by words that there is last point of China territory, is at Hanan Islands. :enjoy:

That map doesn't state such thing of "last point of China territory".
 
That map doesn't state such thing of "last point of China territory".

study more, kid.

textbook.jpg

In ancient Chinese bibliographic documents, China’s territorial areas extend to Hainan Island as the ending point in the south.

In China’s geographical textbook published in 1906, the southernmost point of China is Ya Zhou coastline in Qiongzhou (Hai nan) Island at the latitude of 18013’ N.
 
Last edited:
China, your territory is only extended into Paracel. You don't even rule all Spratly as the other contestants also have de facto islands there. So this 10 dash line map is only a delusion picture that you can only dream about it. Except, you invade the other countries de facto territories and become an aggressor yourselves (are you the next WW2 Japan or German? so think about that, if you say yes, then everything will be easier).

I don't care about the historical bullshit claim from either yours, Vietnam, or even Philippine. What people care is only the de facto territories that you have. So take over the other claimants islands in Spratley, and you're an aggressor. But without those islands, your map is only a joke, as you don't even rule all over the territory in your map.

Indonesia can even draw a map that we have the entire Earth, but it also a joke as we don't rule over the entire planet.
 
Last edited:
study more, kid.

textbook.jpg

In ancient Chinese bibliographic documents, China’s territorial areas extend to Hainan Island as the ending point in the south.

In China’s geographical textbook published in 1906, the southernmost point of China is Ya Zhou coastline in Qiongzhou (Hai nan) Island at the latitude of 18013’ N.

How about you find a clearer picture and try to 'translate' it to me again, hmm?
 
China, your territory is only extended into Paracel. You don't even rule all Spratly as the other contestants also have de facto islands there. So this 10 dash line map is only a delusion picture that you can only dream about it. Except, you invade the other countries de facto territories and become an aggressor yourselves (are you the next WW2 Japan or German? so think about that, if you say yes, then everything will be easier).

I don't care about the historical bullshit claim from either yours, Vietnam, or even Philippine. What people care is only the de facto territories that you have. So take over the other claimants islands in Spratley, and you're an aggressor. But without those islands, your map is only a joke, as you don't even rule all over the territory in your map.

Indonesia can even draw a map that we have the entire Earth, but it also a joke as we don't rule over the entire planet.
Than urge your government to do so.
 
'It is precisely such ambitious expansionism that is causing the tensions in the South China Sea,' Department of Foreign Affairs spokesman Charles Jose says

Published Jun 25, 2014

china-map-carousel%20(1).jpg


NEW MAP. A new Chinese map shows a 10-dash line to claim virtually the entire South China Sea. Screen grab from news.xinhuanet.com/Image edited by Rappler

In an interview on ANC, Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) spokesperson Charles Jose said the publication of the new map “shows China's unreasonably expansive claim that is clearly contrary to international law,” particularly the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).

“It is precisely such ambitious expansionism that is causing the tensions in the South China Sea,” he added. (READ: Philippines' top diplomat hits China for 'expansion agenda')

Communications Secretary Herminio Coloma Jr, for his part, said the publication of the map “does not promote the cause of regional stability.”

The government made these statements after China's state-run Xinhua News published a photo taken on Monday, June 23, that “shows a newly issued vertical atlas of China by Hunan map publishing house.”

“Islands in the South China Sea share the same scale with the mainland and are better shown than traditional maps,” the photo caption on Xinhua said.

Studying new protest
The Philippines is studying the need to file a new protest against China over the 10-dash line map, Jose said in a text message to Rappler.

The Southeast Asian country, in any case, has “already registered with the United Nations our objection to China's 9-dash line claim.”

“We should also take note that no other country recognizes China's – well, previously – 9-dash line claim. So publishing a new map does not make the territories that they claim, theirs,” Jose told ANC.

The Philippines has also filed a historic case against China over its 9-dash line.

In its case before an arbitral tribunal at the Permanent Court of Arbitration, the Philippines argues that the 9-dash line contradicts UNCLOS, the so-called Constitution for the Oceans.

The UNCLOS mandates a 200-nautical mile exclusive economic zone (EEZ) from a coastal state's baselines, or edges, within which the state can exclusively use marine resources. China's 9-dash line encroaches on the Philippines' EEZ.

Philippine news outlets have reported on China's 10-dash line map since as early as July 2013.

In a note verbale dated June 7, 2013, the DFA told the Chinese Embassy in the Philippines that it “protests the reference to those dash lines as China's national boundaries,”according to a report by GMA News in 2013.

Chinese maps used vs China
China, for its part, has used its ancient maps to prove its claim over the South China Sea.

Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio of the Philippine Supreme Court, however, has used China's favorite pieces of evidence against the Asian giant itself. (READ: Top Philippine judge uses Chinese maps vs China)

In a speech at the De La Salle University in Manila, Carpio said China's ancient maps dating back to 960 AD show that its territory “never included” the Spratly Islands and Scarborough Shoal in the West Philippine Sea.

“There is not a single ancient Chinese map, whether made by Chinese or foreigners, showing that the Spratlys and Scarborough Shoal were ever part of Chinese territory. To repeat, in all these ancient Chinese maps, the southernmost Chinese territory has always been Hainan Island,” Carpio said.

Vietnam, another country that claims parts of the South China Sea, slams China for its 9-dash line. (READ: 'Brave, patriotic' Vietnam challenges China)

In an interview with Rappler, Vietnamese Ambassador to the Philippines Truong Trieu Duong criticized the 9-dash line as a “newly born idea” that “has been rejected by almost all countries, all claimants.”

Philippines hits China over ‘10-dash line’ map



This is what we call progress :lol:

From 9-dash LIE to 10-dash LIE! another recent invention based on Chinese greed tsk tsk
This just shows that their 9-imaginary dash line is wrong, They themselves corrected it with another wrong map, tadaaaa. . . 10-dash line. By the way it used to be 11-dash line. It really seems they don't know what they're doing. I hope those judges at UN arbitration will recognize these comedy. :rofl::omghaha:
 

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom