What's new

Pakistani Music labelled "Music of India" on Youtube

. . . .
This debate has occurred so many times on this forum, so let me summarize:

- Indian used to be an adjective for Indus and referred to whole of South Asia.
- Republic of India took the name 'India' and laid exclusive claim to that adjective.
- Pakistanis don't like it but Indians claim they are the only ones who retain the ancestral culture,

Who's right? who's wrong? who knows?
Asking this as a pakistani? Don't you know the answer already?
 
Last edited:
. .
Since when is Urdu a indian language.
Are all indians as stupid as on this PDF?
India or Hindustan didnot exist before 75 years! It was british raj and before that mughal empire. Now i am in no mood to teach ignorant indian here anything. Learn history and you will see how many cultures infused with local culture in indian subcontinent and gave to new thriving cultures which are totally different from its origins.
Let me do you a favor go to dawn.com and see how indians flood the comment sections. Nobody in Pakistan give a damn about India yet politicians in India use Pakistan name for votes. Wion news, arnab which have hue following in india have been saying that civil war is gonna happen in Pakistan in coming days for LAST DECADE. Go to Aljazeera, TRT,DW, RT and see how indians flood the comment section even tho the news is not related to anything remotely Pakistani or indian.
Urdu or Hindustani is a language native to Ganges plain which is comprised of India today. It’s not native to any region comprising today of Pakistan. Mughals and British Raj both were foreigners to regions comprising of Pakistan. While Mughals assimilated into Northern Indian or Hindustani culture, known as Ganga Jamuna tahzeeb later on.
 
.
literally the most inferiority complexed people out there, we on the other hand walk around in kameez, make mosques even if we are 15 people - that's what we are, we have pride

Yes, I wonder why Elon and SpaceX have the stupid priority of getting a few humans to Mars in about six years. 🤔

Bulleh shah murshid was an Arain(Master Race).

Yeah, Bulleh Shah wrote his philosophy and poetry only for Arains. :rolleyes: You seem to be proudly a paindu. You are like the Hindutvadis from India who may travel to the West but carry along their cultural baggage, may do some "big time" college degree and get into high-paying jobs but will remain jaahil.
 
.
Yes, I wonder why Elon and SpaceX have the stupid priority of getting a few humans to Mars in about six years. 🤔
Don't know half the things you are talking about other I usually don't care for - 10% I agree with
Yeah, Bulleh Shah wrote his philosophy and poetry only for Arains. :rolleyes: You seem to be proudly a paindu. You are like the Hindutvadis from India who may travel to the West but carry along their cultural baggage, may do some "big time" college degree and get into high-paying jobs but will remain jaahil.
He was joking around nibba, I am not one and even I gave a love react
Cause I know what he meant, it wasn't a literal thing it was a inside joke/cultural thing that you can't understand
 
.
Don't know half the things you are talking about other I usually don't care for - 10% I agree with

Which are those 10 percent ?

He was joking around nibba, I am not one and even I gave a love react
Cause I know what he meant, it wasn't a literal thing it was a inside joke/cultural thing that you can't understand

Well, I have been reading his posts for long hence my reaction.
 
. .
Murshid means spiritual teacher and bulleh shah’s spiritual teacher was an Arain. He’s said so in his poetry.

He may have said about Arain ancestry of his teacher but do show me where he spoke about "Master race Arain".
 
.
He may have said about Arain ancestry of his teacher but do show me where he spoke about "Master race Arain".
He didn’t say anything about master race. That was me.

Jamahir, I’m intellectually on another playing field when compared to you. My humor and the things I say will not be understood by you because of difference in culture.
 
.
It only shows you have to be more pro- active in international affairs. You guys suck at soft power.
Coke studio and Cricket are only distinguishable things that come to my mind.

Pakistan will always struggle with soft power projection. Colonial 'sports' like cricket are a curse upon the nation.
 
.
Overseas Pakistanis ko soft power ki itni fikar kyon ha?

Overseas Pakistanis do face stereotypes propagated by media munching on Indian consumerism. The monotonous nature of the discussions are lethargic and sometimes even frustrating.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom