On serious on note people who say PMLN left 92 billion dollar deficit is totally wrong. They left 36 billion dollar deficit as 92 billion dollar was all total.
Right now total debt of Pakistan is 122 billion dollar, which means that PTI added 30 billion deficit in just 3.2 years.
Coming to CAD
PMLN 5 years CAD
1) 2.3 billion dollar CAD in 2014
2) 2.5 billion dollar CAD in 2015
3) 4.6 billion dollar CAD 2016
4) 13.5 billion dollar CAD 2017
5) 19.5 billion dollar CAD in 2018
PTI CAD in 3.2 years and expected
1) 13.5 billion dollar CAD in 2019
2) 4.4 billion collar in 2020
3) 1.8 billion dollar CAD in 2021
4) 2.3 billion CAD in just 2 months and faster than PMLN
PSX value in PMLN was over 100 billion dollar and market was at 53K
Right in PTI era PSX is downgraded and market value less than 40 billion dollar.
In short, except market base exchange rate PTI zero progress in exports and did nothing to reduce imports, which is the reason why Shaukat Tarin entire growth depends on cars sale, which can be done 1000s better by PMLN or PPP.
That is what happens when make excuses and put all the blame on others.
One more thing as finance guys that people who talk PTI had to pay 19 billion dollar CAD is totally BS as our system is cash carry, which means that 19 CAD of 2018 was over in June 30th.
Just think PTI also made Chinese investor annoyed and it took 3 years PTI to admit that yes we made CPEC very slow.
Even look at FDI in these 2 months, which is less than 200 million dollar.
PTI did the biggest blunder by pausing IMF program and now IMF condition will more hard than June 2021 and we will have to swallow that PTI due to incompetence.
What PTI also did a disaster is that they forced negative interest rate, which created a artificial demand just like PMLN.
If you look at entire situation than PPP is best among them because 2010-2011 was the highest inflation ever and still PPP managed far better in terms of external finance performance only and they never forced negative interest rate.
@Norwegian