Pakistan India Border Skirmish 1958 East Pakistan

[Sneaker]

The foreign source of your friend never states it was "state police".
No it isn't you are talking about. Since nowhere in the source it says" state police". It can be some paramilitary which used to guard border or some border patrol police. At least "state police" is not mentioned anywhere in your source.

What the? Tripura wasn't a "state" until 1970... Paramilitaries are referred as soldiers or jawans. Even if they were paramilitary, it is a big thing to take on enemy army that too take down an officer? Speaks highly of paramilitary unit involved.....

 

[Areesh]

I should stick to Pakistani source for the sake of the thread i.e it was BSF who manned that post in 1958

Whatever floats your boat. Bharatis on this thread are fast changing their position like that Indian force of 1958.

What the? Tripura wasn't a "state" until 1970... Paramilitaries are referred as soldiers or jawans. Even if they were paramilitary, it is a big thing to take on enemy army that too take down an officer? Speaks highly of paramilitary unit involved.....

I don't care what Tripura was. I just said no where in the source it is said that it was "state police". Yeah they martyred one brave heart and ran back to where they came from. Surely speaks highly of the unit involved.

 

[QARAMATIANS]

Whatever floats your boat. Bharatis on this thread are fast changing their position like that Indian force of 1958.

Really .. Check the OP he clearly mentioned B.S.F and a Police IG ... We just showed you the mirror.

 

[Areesh]

Really check the OP he clearly mentioned B.S.F and a Police IG ... We just showed you the mirror.

Reality check. I don't go with OP. I go with official account of this incident.

 

[QARAMATIANS]

Reality check. I don't go with OP. I go with official account of this incident.

Then this thread is complete nonsense as its not based on "source" and facts but blogs @mods should purge this misleading thread.

 

[Areesh]

Then this thread is complete nonsense as its not based on "source" and facts but blogs @mods should purge this misleading thread.

Go complain to a mod.

 

[Sneaker]

not scoring a point. I already said. You don't believe in the incident. Good. We would believe in it and would tell our children about it. You don't matter to us. It is just good on your part that you searched and admitted the truth.

Which part of "I don't believe as described" was difficult for you to understand?

 

[Sine Nomine]

EBR had west pakistani soldiers but EPR was an all bangali force yet another fail

i ALREADY TOLD YOU THAT HOW MUCH PATHETIC TROLL YOU ARE "EBR" WAS EAST BENGALI REGIMENT WHICH WAS AN INFATRY REGMNET OF PAKISTAN ARMY.
WHILE "EPR" WAS EAST PAKISTAN RIFLE A PARAMILITARY UNIT TO DEFEND BORDER AREAS.

 

[Md Akmal]

@Khalid Newazi bhai pakistanigo etoi bhalobasen je desher polare bideshi banaiya dilen Whatever happened in that era should be posted on pakistani section on topic a battle did took place near akhaura (i am from comilla) but was not that intense as the article suggests

@ My foot ! I have visited that area sitting on the opposite means viewing from area(Hill top) not remember may be "Bhobanipur ". It is the tip of present Khagrachori District northern side where I went to visit back in 1997. Where one of the BDR member was describing the "Asalong Operation" although he was not there. But the way he was narrating the story, I was feeling as if I fought the war. He could not narrate the name of the officer and the year but he said we the BDR means the EPR fought the war and evicted the Indians from the soils of East Bengal.

@ Now, as per the statement of @chaanmia the war was not that intense but it stills remind the members of EPR/BDR?Border Guards of Bangladesh. This lone incident demoralize the Indians so much that during the rest of the Pakistan days they never never dared to attacked the then East Pakistan and finally they conspired to dismember Pakistan and succeeded..

 

[Sine Nomine]

@ My foot ! I have visited that area sitting on the opposite means viewing from area(Hill top) not remember may be "Bhobanipur ". It is the tip of present Khagrachori District northern side where I went to visit back in 1997. Where one of the BDR member was describing the "Asalong Operation" although he was not there. But the way he was narrating the story, I was feeling as if I fought the war. He could not narrate the name of the officer and the year but he said we the BDR means the EPR fought the war and evicted the Indians from the soils of East Bengal.

@ Now, as per the statement of @chaanmia the war was not that intense but it stills remind the members of EPR/BDR?Border Guards of Bangladesh. This lone incident demoralize the Indians so much that during the rest of the Pakistan days they never never dared to attacked the then East Pakistan and finally they conspired to dismember Pakistan and succeeded..

As i know sir and i narrate from a Person who was working at Pakistan Foreign Office back in those days,now very old
"At start India tried her best to occupy those parts on both East and West Pakistan which were of value in future,hilltops,water ways , rivers flowing along borders and those usable lands which were in area not of any economical use.West was largely accessible due to nature of Terrain but East was a tough Terrain,India Tried to capture land many times in East before 1965 but Govt strictly ordered EPR to simply not tolerate any thing like such and respond quickly otherwise man in charge will be held responsible"

 

[Khalid Newazi]

@Khalid Newazi bhai pakistanigo etoi bhalobasen je desher polare bideshi banaiya dilen Whatever happened in that era should be posted on pakistani section on topic a battle did took place near akhaura (i am from comilla) but was not that intense as the article suggests

Those were Bangladeshi soldiers (the one's that took part in the operation), they were born here, so were their parents and their parents before them, we were just under a country with a different name. It's where it should be. Also Major Tufail Muhammad was born in India (before the separation), thus making it even better. Also, the Indians attacked Bangladesh not West Pakistan.

Epic Fail


A police IG was inspecting the Post manned by infantry soldiers instead of colonel

Yes, they do.

 

[chaanmia]

nobody is giving no credit for something. Yes he died in 1958 in east pak border skirmishes while defending pakistan of that time. He was from punjab regiment and was born in burewala in punjab pakistan. (read the second source)

contrary to yr state propaganda we did had sizeable presence there and fought for her defence and he is presented as an example.

Also u were never high in numbers then us. Stop that half a century old propaganda of Mujib.

If we were not the majority then just tell me how Sheikh Mujibur Rahman won the election without winning a single seat in the west? think much?

 

[Sine Nomine]

If we were not the majority then just tell me how Sheikh Mujibur Rahman won the election without winning a single seat in the west? think much?

Simple Ans kid Population of Pakistan 200 million today check out BD"S.Also East Pakistan was single territory with one goon Party while west was divided into Four Provinces with many parties.

 

[punit]

Simple Ans kid Population of Pakistan 200 million today check out BD"S.Also East Pakistan was single territory with one goon Party while west was divided into Four Provinces with many parties.

AND THAT SOME HOW MAKES east pakistanis not eligible to become PMof United pakistan !!!

 

[Areesh]

Which part of "I don't believe as described" was difficult for you to understand?

you guys first completely negated the incident. It was only later admitted that it did happened but only don't agree with Pakistani version of event.