Week-long closure incurs Rs120bn loss
KARACHI, Oct 20: Businessmen and economists conservatively estimate a total loss of over $2 billion (Rs120 billion) because of a virtual business closure in Karachi for more than a week that came to a close on Saturday.
The businesses were closed early this week because of the Eid and then a bloodbath in the early hours of Friday which claimed 140 lives and left as many as many 500 injured, many of them maimed for life, and plunged the city in a state of mourning and also brought the entire business life to a standstill.
During this week, banks remained closed on Monday and Tuesday, and when bank branches opened on Wednesday, they did a small amount of business because trade and industry did not open. On Thursday, the government closed the educational institutions.
The city, except for Sharea Faisal, was functional, but economic activity remained suspended.
People of the city unilaterally decided to treat Oct 18 as a public holiday on their own; otherwise there was no tension or disruption of any sort anywhere during the day, a lady who travelled through the city on the day told Dawn.
Most of shopping centres pulled down shutters and hardly any public transport was seen on the roads.
Friday dawn saw a trail of blood on the road which connects airport with the metropolis, and most of the people preferred staying indoors.
The city was in a state of shock; and a pall of gloom eclipsed areas where bodies of victims came for burial.
Most of the public transport was off the roads; offices and business centres were closed and even vegetables and fruits were not available on streets.
Then came the last day of the week, Saturday, when the city started limping back to normalcy. Public transport made some appearance, shopkeepers were seen opening their shops and the city started receiving some vegetable supplies from the Punjab and Balochistan, but not from Sindh according to leaders of the wholesale market on Superhighway.
Quantification of the spill-over effect of Karachis business closure to other parts of the country is difficult, but a rough estimate puts it anywhere from four to five billion dollars.
The overall economic loss from a full week business closure in Karachi comes to six to seven billion dollars (Rs360 to Rs420 billion).
The most hard hit are the poorer sections of the city, a market analyst said. Those who suffer are farmers and small traders who supply vegetables and fruits regularly from all the three provinces to this huge market of almost 20 million.
The week-long suspension in supplies means building up of a huge inventory of perishables in the fields for which small farmers do not have storage facilities. Then port operations also suffered and many traders and industrialists were not able to get their export orders served in time. They also failed to get their imported consignments in time which disturbed their production and delivery schedule.
About 250 to 300 trucks of vegetables have come from Punjab and Balochistan, said Haji Shahjehan who pointed out that daily arrival on a normal day is 800 to 1,000 trucks.
He warned that tomatoes will continue to be costly at Rs75 to Rs80 a kg for consumers as these are being imported from India via the Punjab. Tomato harvest in Sindh is still two weeks away.
Leaders of the main vegetable and fruit market on Superhighway are worried over reports of continued disturbances in Sindh hinterland where reports of Friday bloodbath reminded many people, particularly the political activists of the 1983 army crackdown in rural areas.
Traders in Karachi and other parts of the country look with fear and suspicion the coming days and weeks.
They are more worried after former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto expressed apprehensions in a press conference on Friday of more attacks on her life in the coming days.
Business leadership took prompt notice of the Friday blasts that turned a carnival of hundreds and thousands of political supporters of a reception rally into a mob of angry mourners.
The leaders of the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry deplored the worst terrorist attack in the history of the country.
Such acts of brutal terrorism in Karachi are bound to create a sense of insecurity and uncertainty, which will adversely affect business and investment climate, not only in the city, but all over the country as a whole, said Tanvir Ahmad Sheikh, President of the FPCCI with his seven vice presidents in a joint statement.
The FPCCI presidents advice is that police personnel and security system needed urgent modernisation and re-organisation.
Also to take notice of the ugly incident are Karachi business leaders Siraj Kassim Teli, Tahir Khaliq, Haroon Farooki, M. Zubair Motiwala, Anjum Nisar, Shamim Shamsi, Iftikhar Sheikh and Haroon Agar who called attack on Benazir Bhutto a conspiracy against democracy.
Karachi Stock Exchange is the only business house that remained unaffected by the early Friday morning bomb blast and killing of 140 persons.
Stock brokers showed more than 32 per cent growth in business on Friday when the entire business of the country was either closed or was in a state of shock. No plausible explanation was given by any businessman on this odd behaviour of the stock brokers.
A market analyst, however, said that stock market operations are manipulated by hardly a dozen persons. There are stock brokers who have interests in banking, financial services, real estate and commodity business. Their job is to keep the government and international bankers in a good mood by showing positive results even on a day when 160 million people were in a state of shock and mourning.
Week-long closure incurs Rs120bn loss -DAWN - Business; October 21, 2007