Op-Ed: India, stop supporting Bangladesh until they cease ethnic cleansing against minorities

[Saiful Islam]

You are kidding me?

Chakmas have been wiped out almost from their land by illegally dumping Rohingyas and other Bangladeshis there.

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/genocide-of-indigenous-people-in-bangladesh-by-muslims.202282/

The CHT tribal leader opted for Pakistan.

Nuff said.

Now enjoy our hench-lady sticking it to you while you rage. Lasting legacy of your "independence".

Just love how she totally slapped BD military generals (replacing where needed) and has them licking her boots now, while she licks ours.

Hope the kangaroo courts against all opposition continues as well. BD people are greatly supporting it. Time to bulldoze so better tribute to India (like next to free transit while we keep all the Teesta water) can be delivered for win-win

One thing I like about you, at least you admit all the flaws in the current regime and state that it is India's doing.
Good on you fella.

 

[Mage]

10 pilkhanas daily....as a minimum. It will be time for that when a non-SHW or non-BAL takes charge in the next cpl decades. So please go ahead and accomplish that and you can verify what happens for yourself.

What a logic. Hasina wasn't always in power in BD you know. And you guys had nothing to do with Pilkhana which you are so proud of. Please show some proof that India was behind it.

Like I said Hasina wasn't always in power and she won't always be in power. And if an anti-India party comes to power it won't be pleasant for India. But even then India-Bangladesh relation will probably be better than India-Pakistan relation. Look at Khaleda's term. We didn't have a hostile relation exactly even then. Relation between Bangladesh and India may not be friendly in the future. But I see little possibility of it becoming hostile.

And most importantly why should Indians care more for Bangladeshi Hindus compared to Indian Muslims? Indian Muslims are your own people.

 

[Nilgiri]

What a logic. Hasina wasn't always in power in BD you know. And you guys had nothing to do with Pilkhana which you are so proud of. Please show some proof that India was behind it.

Thats a conversation you should have with people in your country across the polarized divide first. There are quite a lot on this forum already. Once there is a united front on who is to blame, we can go from there.

Till then I will make my own assertions on which is more likely given there is no real conclusive evidence on either side. Its no water off my back, but it sure sets BD's against each other like nothing else with minimal effort - and that is welcomed by me and India in general.

Look at Khaleda's term. We didn't have a hostile relation exactly even then. Relation between Bangladesh and India may not be friendly in the future. But I see little possibility of it becoming hostile.

I'm not saying the open enmity is likely scenario. I'm just saying what happens in that very unlikely scenario. The way things are polarising now, its very likely that non-SHW or non-BAL takeover will prompt it to a large degree, from BD people themselves on both sides. But SHW has been quite methodical...so much so that the usual quarters (jamati and co) have largely gone quiet now on this forum compared to before when some revolution was just around the corner eternally.

Anyway those early replies are directed to certain BD trolls, not you...so don't take them too seriously.

 

[Mage]

Thats a conversation you should have with people in your country across the polarized divide first. There are quite a lot on this forum already. Once there is a united front on who is to blame, we can go from there.

Till then I will make my own assertions on which is more likely given there is no real conclusive evidence on either side. Its no water off my back, but it sure sets BD's against each other like nothing else with minimal effort - and that is welcomed by me and India in general.

Some people believe earth is flat. There is something like "flat earth society" iirc. That doesn't mean the people are polarized in that matter. You will find more people believing earth is flat in those places. Similarly this is pretty much an anti-India site. So you will naturally find more people believing anti India conspiracies here. That doesn't make the country polarized. Govt is trying to punish those involved in Pilkhana tragedy. And most people are alright with that.

 

[Bilal9]

It is indeed astounding.

India's behavior towards BD is better than US towards Mexico, China towards Vietnam, Russia towards Ukraine, Saudi towards Yemen, Australia towards Nauru, and Morocco towards SADR. And yet, in none of the smaller states in the aforementioned equation will you find as many malcontents as Bangladeshis who have a perennial grudge against India.

And we are to believe that it has nothing to do with religion. These malcontents have not read a word of either their own Constitution nor India's. They do not recognize two secular countries and instead see a Hindu country and a Muslim country instead.

No point beating around the bush. That is the crux of the matter. And unless they realise otherwise, nothing will satisfy them.

Instead of calling us malcontents maybe the question should be asked to religious nut jobs in India on why Bangladeshis hold negative views of India - and your post reeks of severe patronising attitude. First order would be to correct that.

Also realize that Bangladesh doesn't need India, India needs us, whether as a market or for hedge against China.

Tone down the dadagiri first, then equalize trade, then maybe we can talk.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

Yet You are the 4th in intolerance. Go cry somewhere else. No one except INDIAN RSS Thugs believe your claim.

He himself is a RSS thug.

 

[Jacob Martin]

Instead of calling us malcontents maybe the question should be asked to religious nut jobs in India on why Bangladeshis hold negative views of India - and your post reeks of severe patronising attitude. First order would be to correct that.

Modi came to power in 2014, what were your views on India before that? Now you can sit here and lie that you didn't hate India at that time, but that would be just that - a lie. Fact of the matter is, in your mind you have decided that "Muslim" Bangladesh can never be friends with "Hindu" India, and nothing can change that view.

Also realize that Bangladesh doesn't need India, India needs us, whether as a market or for hedge against China

That would be correct if not for the small fact that 10% of your population lives and works in India. They do so because they have no prospects in BD. So after you have stopped your Cinderella-at-the-ball routine, fancying that everyone wants to dance with you, consider the fact that had it not been for India accommodating these people, your country would have collapsed by now.

I know there is no gratitude in International relations, but surely that does not mean you spin stories to comfort yourself.

Tone down the dadagiri first, then equalize trade, then maybe we can talk

As I said in my initial post, the dadagiri you talk about is nothing compared to other such equations around the world where a small state exists in close proximity and at the total mercy of a much larger state. Had religious chauvinism not blinded you, this obvious fact would not have escaped notice.

 

[darksider]

You are kidding me?

Chakmas have been wiped out almost from their land by illegally dumping Rohingyas and other Bangladeshis there.

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/genocide-of-indigenous-people-in-bangladesh-by-muslims.202282/

What Bangladesh need land not chakmas.
India can give chakmas land and refuge.
Indians should not point fingers on others what you guys doing in kashmir for land is not hidden. Even bhartis on pdf openly say india want only land not Kashmiris.
So be quite.

 

[Michael Corleone]

india is giving to bangladesh? what, other than C**kblocks? lmao hilarious thread.... bangladesh is not india nor pakistan.... there is no concept of minority here.... if you're a bangladeshi... youre a bangladeshi... nothing else.....

 

[Loafer]

What Bangladesh need land not chakmas.
India can give chakmas land and refuge.
Indians should not point fingers on others what you guys doing in kashmir for land is not hidden. Even bhartis on pdf openly say india want only land not Kashmiris.
So be quite.

Pakistan has 6 times land than punny Bangladesh. Pakistan should absorb all Rohingyas in the interests of humanity.

 

[Zabaniyah]

I am starting to think that these folks only do these events for the money.

It is interesting how the power and corruption of money can cloud the purity of a cause. Be it Muslim, Hindu or otherwise. Or maybe they aren't in track with the times?

The Hindus of Bangladesh as of right now are in a position better than they ever were before. And that is a fact. If they are still not satisfied (for which there is enough reason for suspicion), then they are being greedy.

Yet You are the 4th in intolerance. Go cry somewhere else. No one except INDIAN RSS Thugs believe your claim.

You'd be surprised how many folks will buy it

No point beating around the bush. That is the crux of the matter. And unless they realise otherwise, nothing will satisfy them.

Really? I think you lot are trying too hard to control history as you see fit. But no worries, you are not the only ones in the struggle.

 

[darksider]

Pakistan has 6 times land than punny Bangladesh. Pakistan should absorb all Rohingyas in the interests of humanity.

India is bidder than Pakistan and Bangladesh you guys should give refuge chakmas.
Help your hindus in Bangladesh. Give them land in india.

 

[Loafer]

India is bidder than Pakistan and Bangladesh you guys should give refuge chakmas.
Help your hindus in Bangladesh. Give them land in india.

We have 10% of Bangladesh population in our land staying illegally. Even Jinnah would be craving in his grave today thinking subcontinental muslims are ready to pole vault and face bullet to go in India. In fact we should snatch CHT from Bangladesh and expel all Bangladeshi Muslims from there.

 

[Mage]

We have 10% of Bangladesh population in our land staying illegally. Even Jinnah would be craving in his grave today thinking subcontinental muslims are ready to pole vault and face bullet to go in India. In fact we should snatch CHT from Bangladesh and expel all Bangladeshi Muslims from there.

Careful man cub. You might end up losing your entire NE trying that.

 

[Jacob Martin]

you lot

Are you mistaking me for a Sanghi by any chance? I am not one. However, I do dislike ingrates and whiners.