What's new

No lessons learned: 'Reckless' media does a 26/11, reveals troops' movement during Kashmir operation

Abingdonboy

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 4, 2010
Messages
29,597
Reaction score
46
Country
India
Location
United Kingdom
1962_ht2.jpg



New Delhi: "The shots and visuals that were shown live by TV channels could have also been shown after all the terrorists were neutralized and the security operations were over. But in that case, the TV programmes would not have had the same shrill, scintillating and chilling effect and would not have shot up the TRP ratings of the channels."

"It must, therefore, be held that by covering live the terrorists attack on Mumbai in the way it was done, Indian TV channels were not serving any national interest or social cause. On the contrary, they were acting in their own commercial interest, putting national security in jeopardy."
This was the observation made by a bench of Justices Aftab Alam and C K Prasad of honourable Supreme Court of India in reference to the 'reckless' coverage of electronic media while covering the Mumbai terror attacks of 2008.


On Friday, television screens were brimming with 'live and exclusive' visuals of military operations from Jammu and Kashmir’s Uri sector. As soldiers put their lives on stake to neutralise the militants, television camera were engaged in a battle of their own. To grab 'that exclusive shot', television reporters- sans any regards for the security of soldiers- went all guns blazing while covering the operation.




1962_ht3.jpg




It seemed that the Supreme Court ruling was the last thing on their minds as they brazenly went about reporting positions and movement of the troops.

And what happens when one concerned Indian citizen reminds the television channel that their coverage could compromise the operation? His phone is disconnected!

"Are you naïve to the fact that by telecasting LIVE VISUALS of army movements, you COMPROMISE their positions !!! Any person in contact with the terrorists hiding inside, after watching these visuals can relay the information directly to the terrorists, who can then take advantage of it ! DON'T YOU REALISE YOU ARE AIDING THE TERRORIST INDIRECTLY? And when you are given calls from concerned citizens, requesting you to please remove LIVE VISUALS while reporting, you simply ignore and bang the phone down !!!" Rahul narrated his experience on his Facebook account.
It is time that media fraternity defines guidelines to be followed while covering live military operations. A strict ban on visuals during the operation, gagging 'over enthusiastic' reporters from divulging sensitive details on live television or perhaps delaying the coverage till the conclusion of the operation.

However, going by the frenzied and mindless TRP-chasing-mode of the news channels, a change looks unlikely.


Media's coverage of Kashmir operation reveals details of troop movement - daily.bhaskar.com




The media got both NSG operator and civilians killed during 26/11-FACT. Did anyone blink twice? Did anyone try to take action against the media then? They have blood on their hands.



 
.
I dont understand how and why the so called TRP hungry media is so irresponsible... In a way they are also becoming a instrument of providing realtime intelligence to terrorists and thus helping them indirectly and directly.. Such news channels, reporters, cameraman and the top management all should be prosecuted or impeached in a manner where such things are not repeated... for the death of our jawans its not only the bullets which are responsible but also such media who helps to find the target of such bullets "accurately" via such mindless reporting s..

Its a shame that our countrymen are only helping terrorists shoot bullets on our jawans. Strong condemnation is needed..
 
. . .
Even i noticed this.Lets teach them a good lesson and stop their broadcast for a month and next time they will think twice before doing anything like this.

Must go to court again and sue them, They understand only money. Make the fine so steep that others will think twice before airing such incidents. Bloody Morons!! Govt. cannot do anything, it is also scared of them.
 
.
In Pakistan and India media covers all things live from robbery to terrorism just for sake of TRP,they will even cover a rape case live if they get chance.
thankfully not that much in pak.
 
.
Some experts had raised this question after 26/11 events and recommended that either Media behave Responsibly or laws be formulated that put some sort of restraint on Media houses telecasting such sensitive information. As usual there was hue and cry over attack on freedom of press and nothing was done.
At that time it was understood that media would understand the repercussions of such activities as sometimes (as we saw in Mumbai attacks), the security forces are at the receiving end.
Unfortunately, the media has shown no signs of maturity and in this blind race for getting the next Breaking News, they can stoop to any level.
What a Shame :mad:
 
.
“Now I’m going to tell you, one of these days, if you keep publishing how you do this, the other guy’s going to be there ready for you, and you’re going to fly in and he’s going to shoot down every damn helicopter and kill every one of your SEALs. Now, watch it happen. Mark my words. Get the hell out of the media.."

-LT GEN James Vaught former SEAL commander.


Sadly this general's words came true (Chinooks loaded with SEALs have been shot out of the sky by the Taliban) and this practice of covering these sort of events in the Indian media is going to (and has) get Indian soldiers killed.

The actions of those in the media is getting Indians killed and compromising Indian national security if this isn't the definition of treason I don't know what is.
 
.
In Pakistan and India media covers all things live from robbery to terrorism just for sake of TRP,they will even cover a rape case live if they get chance.

Agreed it is a problem with us 3rd world countries
On topic
Some sort of law should be made to stop media covering these sensitive events
 
.
Must go to court again and sue them, They understand only money. Make the fine so steep that others will think twice before airing such incidents. Bloody Morons!! Govt. cannot do anything, it is also scared of them.
Try and criticize them and they go berserk. "Media is being targeted, media's freedom is getting curbed, it's against the constitution, media is being gagged," blah,blah and more blah.

People especially like Arnob Goswami will throw a massive fit and explode, cracking our TV screens with his hot-air blasts, blaming every living being on planet Earth except himself! Jeeez! Our fukin' media needs to be collared.
 
.
Media is turning out to be a curse for our forces. Media should STFU and mind their own fvcking business. All these arnab goswami types should be dragged to courts for compromising the security of our forces and helping the terrorists.
 
.
1962_ht2.jpg



New Delhi: "The shots and visuals that were shown live by TV channels could have also been shown after all the terrorists were neutralized and the security operations were over. But in that case, the TV programmes would not have had the same shrill, scintillating and chilling effect and would not have shot up the TRP ratings of the channels."

"It must, therefore, be held that by covering live the terrorists attack on Mumbai in the way it was done, Indian TV channels were not serving any national interest or social cause. On the contrary, they were acting in their own commercial interest, putting national security in jeopardy."
This was the observation made by a bench of Justices Aftab Alam and C K Prasad of honourable Supreme Court of India in reference to the 'reckless' coverage of electronic media while covering the Mumbai terror attacks of 2008.


On Friday, television screens were brimming with 'live and exclusive' visuals of military operations from Jammu and Kashmir’s Uri sector. As soldiers put their lives on stake to neutralise the militants, television camera were engaged in a battle of their own. To grab 'that exclusive shot', television reporters- sans any regards for the security of soldiers- went all guns blazing while covering the operation.




1962_ht3.jpg




It seemed that the Supreme Court ruling was the last thing on their minds as they brazenly went about reporting positions and movement of the troops.

And what happens when one concerned Indian citizen reminds the television channel that their coverage could compromise the operation? His phone is disconnected!

"Are you naïve to the fact that by telecasting LIVE VISUALS of army movements, you COMPROMISE their positions !!! Any person in contact with the terrorists hiding inside, after watching these visuals can relay the information directly to the terrorists, who can then take advantage of it ! DON'T YOU REALISE YOU ARE AIDING THE TERRORIST INDIRECTLY? And when you are given calls from concerned citizens, requesting you to please remove LIVE VISUALS while reporting, you simply ignore and bang the phone down !!!" Rahul narrated his experience on his Facebook account.
It is time that media fraternity defines guidelines to be followed while covering live military operations. A strict ban on visuals during the operation, gagging 'over enthusiastic' reporters from divulging sensitive details on live television or perhaps delaying the coverage till the conclusion of the operation.

However, going by the frenzied and mindless TRP-chasing-mode of the news channels, a change looks unlikely.


Media's coverage of Kashmir operation reveals details of troop movement - daily.bhaskar.com




The media got both NSG operator and civilians killed during 26/11-FACT. Did anyone blink twice? Did anyone try to take action against the media then? They have blood on their hands.


---
I hope its DELAYED telcast as LIVE and not REAL TIME..
Dont underestimate Defence guys.... if you and me can see so they too.
one phone call will do it..
do beter ahve delayed by few hrs feed as live than like 26./11 live coverage
 
.
Oh please. If the government wants to, they could legislate security restrictions from media reporting whilst any security or military operation is underway. Don't blame the media for the incompetency of the legislators or the military
 
. .
Lol India needs person like Gen. Zheer Ul Islam from the day media is under control half of the terrorists/separatist are just vanished in the thin air.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom