What's new

New China law says children 'must visit parents'

JayAtl

BANNED
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
8,812
Reaction score
-14
Grown children in China must visit their parents or potentially face fines or jail, a new law that came into effect on Monday says.

China's new "Elderly Rights Law" deals with the growing problem of lonely elderly people by ordering adult children to visit their ageing parents.

The law says adults should care about their parents "spiritual needs" and "never neglect or snub elderly people".

The regulation has been ridiculed by tens of thousands of Chinese web users.

Many across China are questioning how the law could be enforced, since it fails to spell out a detailed schedule dictating the frequency with which children should make parental house calls.

"Those who live far away from parents should go home often," it says.

However, that does not mean the law is toothless.

Instead, it serves as an "educational message" to the public, while also serving as a starting point for law suits, explained Zhang Yan Feng, a lawyer with Beijing's King & Capital Law Firm.

"It's hard to put this law into practice, but not impossible," Mr Zhang explained.

"If a case is brought to court on the basis of this law, I think it'll probably end up in a peaceful settlement. But if no settlement is reached, technically speaking, court rulings can force the person to visit home certain times a month."

"If this person disobeys court rulings, he could be fined or detained."

We all know to cherish our elderly parents, but sometimes we are just too busy trying to make a living” Weibo user


But few in China seem to fear they will end up behind bars if they fail to log visits home.

"Who doesn't want to visit home often? What is considered "often"? Who will oversee the process?" complained one poster on weibo, China's version of Twitter.

"We all know to cherish our elderly parents, but sometimes we are just too busy trying to make a living and the pressure is too much."

"It's fine that no-one is paying for us to visit our parents, but is there someone who can give us time off to do it?" asked another.

The question of how to deal with ageing parents is a mounting problem in China.

According to Chinese government statistics, more than 178 million people in China were 60 years or older in 2010. By 2030, that figure will double.

As China's population goes grey, the Chinese media fills with stories of neglected old people.

Many were shocked by the story of a 91-year-old grandmother who was beaten and forced out of her home in China's southern Jiangsu province after she asked her daughter-in-law for a bowl of rice porridge.

Two days later, internet forums were filled with a similar story of farmers in the same province who allowed their family's 100-year-old matriarch to sleep in a pig sty, sharing close quarters with a pungent pig.

But those stories have not lead most people to support the new Elderly Rights Law.

"Family bonds should be based on spontaneous emotions," argued one weibo user.

"It's funny to make it part of a law; it's like requiring couples to have a harmonious sex life after marriage."

BBC News - New China law says children 'must visit parents'
 
. .
The law will only be useful when dividing assets after the elderly died.
 
. .
Very good initiative. And they should come up with something like compulsorily supporting elderly parents financially.
 
.
Very good News :china: this is needed in India to
 
.
This law is not meant to be enforced similar to say, the criminal laws. The real purpose of the law is to assign legal ground in arbitrating this type of cases where the children are neglecting the elderly. Currently, the consequences of neglecting the elderly is mainly peer, society and moral pressure, which do not work against some individuals. With this law, there is actually, legal grounds for to take definite action against elderly negligence.

So no, the Chinese policy force is not gonna go door to door and ensure everyone got their visitation quota filled, that will be just silly. However, if they receive a report of such negligence, they will be legally empowered to intervene if initial arbitration fails.

As for some internet users complaining, please, if Chinese government actually bend over for some lowlife that hides their identity behind a crowd, it would have collapsed long ago.
 
.
Very good initiative. And they should come up with something like compulsorily supporting elderly parents financially.

Very good News :china: this is needed in India to

Nice to know you want a nanny state because you are incapable unless told by the govt to do so.

This law is not meant to be enforced similar to say, the criminal laws. The real purpose of the law is to assign legal ground in arbitrating this type of cases where the children are neglecting the elderly. Currently, the consequences of neglecting the elderly is mainly peer, society and moral pressure, which do not work against some individuals. With this law, there is actually, legal grounds for to take definite action against elderly negligence.

So no, the Chinese policy force is not gonna go door to door and ensure everyone got their visitation quota filled, that will be just silly. However, if they receive a report of such negligence, they will be legally empowered to intervene if initial arbitration fails.

As for some internet users complaining, please, if Chinese government actually bend over for some lowlife that hides their identity behind a crowd, it would have collapsed long ago.

This is just another indicator that China knows its citizens best i.e. they need to be babysat. How do " arbitrate" how many visits and quality of visits?
 
.
Nice to know you want a nanny state because you are incapable unless told by the govt to do so.



This is just another indicator that China knows its citizens best i.e. they need to be babysat. How do " arbitrate" how many visits and quality of visits?
Unintended consequences are often known. For example, if I decide to drill into concrete, I know there are two possible consequences: Either I get a nice round hole or the concrete cracks and my project will be ruined. The nice round hole is the intended consequence while the cracks is a known unintended consequence.

I do not think the Chinese legislators took sufficient analyses on what could be unintended consequences of this law. The reason the Chinese members here will blindly support this law is because they do not want the government to appear un-wise. Yes, they do believe that the Chinese government do know best. From how many children to have to how often the child should visit his/her parents, not in love but in fear of legal repercussions.
 
.
Children who don't visit their parents should be ashamed, many people just admit their parents in care homes and then don't visit at all, they should be fined or punished, this is a good law.
 
.
what should happen to those who don't pray 5 times a day- maybe add them to blasphemy law breakers list too? why stop at parent visits , heh.

ok stupid why there is a law FOR RAPE ARE YOUR PEOPLE INCAPABLE To think rape is bad

Unintended consequences are often known. For example, if I decide to drill into concrete, I know there are two possible consequences: Either I get a nice round hole or the concrete cracks and my project will be ruined. The nice round hole is the intended consequence while the cracks is a known unintended consequence.

I do not think the Chinese legislators took sufficient analyses on what could be unintended consequences of this law. The reason the Chinese members here will blindly support this law is because they do not want the government to appear un-wise. Yes, they do believe that the Chinese government do know best. From how many children to have to how often the child should visit his/her parents, not in love but in fear of legal repercussions.

LOL now this moron claims he is better than Chinese legislators:omghaha:
 
.
ok stupid why there is a law FOR RAPE ARE YOUR PEOPLE INCAPABLE To think rape is bad



LOL now this moron claims he is better than Chinese legislators:omghaha:

Rape and visiting parents are the same equation to a Chinese...everyday you post here, it just becomes easier and easier. I'm beginning to think the Chinese deported you to UK :rofl:
 
.
Rape and visiting parents are the same equation to a Chinese...everyday you post here, it just becomes easier and easier. I'm beginning to think the Chinese deported you to UK :rofl:

I m talking to a retard here , are we not talking about law here. I m sure law is there to protect people to make life better for people no? explain why there is a law telling people not to talk on their mobile while driving are they incapable of thinking talking while driving is bad? don't make stupid thread retard
 
.
LOL now this moron claims he is better than Chinese legislators:omghaha:
Yes, I do. Outside of physical assaults, the government have no place in telling how people should treat each other. Is that too difficult to grasp?

what should happen to those who don't pray 5 times a day- maybe add them to blasphemy law breakers list too? why stop at parent visits , heh.
It is fine to kill babies in the wombs, but not fine if you do not visit your parents X amount of times a month.
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom