New Charge Sheet Links Tablighi Jamaat & Deoband to Delhi Riots

[Taimoor Khan]

That is incorrect. Law and order is a state subject. He is specifically empowered only to act on law and order matters within Union Territories. Delhi is a Union Territory. He has NO authority to do anything within any duly constituted state.

I am sorry, but your wish to see something happen does not change facts on the ground.

What is your understanding of "establishment" and "deep state". The indian states got their own "deep states" as well?

 

[Vasudhaika]

Unfortunately, you are not pointing a finger at me, but rather, defending the actions of those that initiated the pogrom and those that continue to ensure that justice is not served.

This country is bigger than who rules it, no matter how big they are. I have trust in this country and it is not possible for man or an ideology to peddle lies and serve injustices forever.

Most people like you no qualms with injustice or majoritarianism that form the hallmark of a fascist society. Thank you for confirming that you fit very comfortably within such a society.

Lol, make sure you keep blaming majorities and one day it will lead to utopian society.

If your voting pattern in 2024 depends on what I say on a forum, then you were that fruit that never fell far away from that tree of hate.

Is that what you take away from it? keep thinking 'everyone hates me because I'm muslim'

They want it to be removed but for those who support it - it has already passed, what more do you want?

You're acting naive or you're really thin skinned. I personally, don't want anything including CAA to begin with. But BJP sure wanted something politically.

Lol, just look at how ridiculous is this. No support to full support, woah.

Wut? That's my stance from the top. I feel opposition had an important role in the whole fiasco, which you guys won't agree to. That's fine.

 

[xeuss]

This country is bigger than who rules it, no matter how big they are. I have trust in this country and it is not possible for man or an ideology to peddle lies and serve injustices forever.

Nothing lasts forever. But that does not mean you sit back and enjoy injustice wreaked upon others. Of course, as long as the injustice is on others. Typical thought process from a depraved society.

Lol, make sure you keep blaming majorities and one day it will lead to utopian society.
Is that what you take away from it? keep thinking 'everyone hates me because I'm muslim'

You say nothing to permit me to think anything else. If you choose to revise your words, then perhaps I can revise my thoughts. Till then, your depravity is telling.

 

[Vasudhaika]

Nothing lasts forever. But that does not mean you sit back and enjoy injustice wreaked upon others. Of course, as long as the injustice is on others. Typical thought process from a depraved society.

Have you protested when Congress closed doors of parliament, shut the cameras and passed AP reorganisation bill back in 2013 when constituent AP assembly rejected the bill? No one gave a shit then, no national media covered. Well, injustices wreaked upon others in the past too. If we have to call this depraved, well, it'd always been for some and it'd never been for some, 'some' is not permanent.

 

[Naofumi]

You're acting naive or you're really thin skinned. I personally, don't want anything including CAA to begin with. But BJP sure wanted something politically.

Not naïve, a serious question, we want law to be removed, what are the supporter's objectives given that the law has already passed?

 

[Vasudhaika]

Not naïve, a serious question, we want law to be removed, what are the supporter's objectives given that the law has already passed?

Dude, when an act is passed for the refugees, and citizen muslims of Delhi want it to be removed, it is already political.

 

[Joe Shearer]

What is your understanding of "establishment" and "deep state". The indian states got their own "deep states" as well?

Please focus. Rambling and stringing words together doesn't add up to a rational argument.

 

[xeuss]

Have you protested when Congress closed doors of parliament, shut the cameras and passed AP reorganisation bill back in 2013 when constituent AP assembly rejected the bill? No one gave a shit then, no national media covered. Well, injustices wreaked upon others in the past too. If we have to call this depraved, well, it'd always been for some and it'd never been for some, 'some' is not permanent.

I'm sure there are more injustices than the ones you cite above. I am not sure how that is relevant this discussion.
I am also not sure how does a past crime justify a current one?

You are free to start another thread on the topic of AP reorganization, and I will be more than sympathetic to your cause.

Dude, when an act is passed for the refugees, and citizen muslims of Delhi want it to be removed, it is already political.

Because that very act is Part 1 of a two step process to disenfranchise Muslims and render them stateless by using the NRC.

 

[Naofumi]

Dude, when an act is passed for the refugees, and citizen muslims of Delhi want it to be removed, it is already political.

NPR was supposed to commence in April and government have admitted thousand of times "NPR is the first step of NRC".

 

[Shantanu_Left]

Oh come on, why acting naive as if it is 100% genuine emotion and not political at all? Protests took a turn after Sonia Gandhi's appearance at Ramlila, isn't it? It is 100% political from both sides.

Poor Muslims and Hindus will be played as long as they're willing to be played by both sides. Just don't say our emotions are genuine and their's are politically motivated.

And @Shantanu_Left offering legal services, it is nice of you to offer, but I feel they'll be represented by best of the lot congress legal teams. Congress and BJP both are loyal to their 'patrons'.

Another brainwashed Indian poster, sadly. The most jahill quom in this planet happen to live in India.

If I compare these spineless bunch with the White American protesters who are RIGHT NOW facing violence in Trump's America as they stand shoulder to shoulder in solidarity with a dead Black man, I feel ashamed to call any of them my fellow human beings, let alone that we share a nationality.

I have made up my mind finally. I am not arguing with any Sanghi posters on here anymore. They are incorrigible, and their views cannot be changed. They only understand the "might is right" principle: and I promise they will get a lot of that in the coming few months.

Disgusting Indians.

 

[Vasudhaika]

I am also not sure how does a past crime justify a current one?

Nope, it doesn't justify the current injustice. But this is a complex society with many complicated layers. My point being, injustices are not new and hence they wont vanish all of a sudden and most importantly they're not exclusively directed at muslims.

You are free to start another thread on the topic of AP reorganization, and I will be more than sympathetic to your cause.

No thanks, we came to terms with it.

 

[Taimoor Khan]

Please focus. Rambling and stringing words together doesn't add up to a rational argument.

You are either gullible or you dont understand how states work.

This video gives all the information you need to know. If still clueless, apply some burnol.

 

[Vasudhaika]

Another brainwashed Indian poster, sadly.

And I'm ignoring you.

 

[xeuss]

Nope, it doesn't justify the current injustice. But this is a complex society with many complicated layers. My point being, injustices are not new and hence they wont vanish all of a sudden and most importantly they're not exclusively directed at muslims.

Did anyone claim that the only injustice in India is against Muslims?

Speaking on the behalf of one, does not negate the existence of the other. You can do it too. You can speak on the behalf of Muslims without negating whatever cause is near and dear to you. Unfortunately, you choose to trivialize it.

 

[Vasudhaika]

Unfortunately, you choose to trivialize it.

That's what past injustices taught me unfortunately, the bitter truth - everyone's on their own.