What's new

Myanmar General Discussion (non military)

. . . . .
China??? :disagree:
They belong to Bamars dude... :haha:

Well, same concept.

He is saying that Rohingyas should be deported to BD as they are ethnic Bengali.
Apply the same logic and he has no place in India and should be deported to the land of his ethnic kin wherever that happens to be.
 
. . . .
Ray of hope for the Rohingya
Published on Oct 25, 2014 5:57 AM
7 2 0 0 PRINT EMAIL


The acceptance of the "Bengali" label gave 54-year-old Min Aung, a Rohingya in Rakhine state, a much-coveted green card. This gives him freedom to move around Myanmar, but comes with restricted political rights. -- PHOTO: CHAN HTAW


Rohingyas: No light at the end of the tunnel

UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon's latest report on Burma has once again drawn global attention to the sad plight of Muslims known as Rohingyas in that Buddhist country. His annual report to the UN General Assembly's Third Committee, which focuses on human rights, raises serious concerns about the condition of Muslims who are victims of ethnic and religious tensions created by official policies and hate campaigns by some radical monks, particularly Wirathu whom Time magazine describes as the "face of Buddhist terror."

This has so poisoned the atmosphere that even the democratic reforms initiated by President Thein Sein are working to the disadvantage of Rohingyas. While the government intensifies its campaign of hate, opponents of the regime don't want to alienate the Buddhist majority by supporting the minority. Even the leader of the democracy movement, Nobel Peace Laureate Aung San Suu Kyi, is avoiding any criticism of the government on the Rohingya issue.

Meanwhile, some 140,000 Muslims are still languishing in refugee camps on the western coast of Burma. They were rounded up in the wake of communal riots in 2012, although they were the victims of the ugly incidents which took place that year. The situation is so dire that US President Barack Obama on his visit to Burma in 2012 spoke of the “crushing poverty and persecution” being faced by Muslims. The best that most of them can hope for is to escape on an overloaded fishing boat to Malaysia or Thailand. Some 86,000 people have tried to flee risking their lives. Those who manage to reach their destination face uncertain prospects.

There are some eight million Muslims in Burma of whom about one in six is Rohingya. Most of them live in Rakhine state on the western coast. Muslims have faced repression in Burma since it achieved independence in 1948. Their plight can be traced to the fact that they have been denied citizenship.

Rohingyas are not a part of the 135 recognized ethnic groups in Burma. It is estimated that there are at least 10 million stateless people in the world today. One of the largest is the Rohingya. They were deprived of their nationality in 1982 by Burma’s Citizenship Law. The Burmese government and extremist Buddhist groups claim that the Rohingyas are migrants from Bangladesh, although there is ample evidence of centuries of Muslim settlement in the region.

What is causing particular worry to UN and human rights groups is the Rakhine State Action Plan which will require Rohingyas to first declare themselves Bengali (which they say they are not) and then try to prove that they are eligible for citizenship by the standards of the 1982 law. Those who fail to meet the nearly impossible conditions of the law — including tracing their family history in Burma back to the days before British colonization in 1823 — would be put into what the Burmese authorities call "a resettlement zone." Those who refuse to go through the process would be sent to a displacement camp.

This means there is no light at the end of the tunnel for these people. This is bad not only for Rohingyas but for Southeast Asia as a whole. There are already disturbing signs to show that the repercussions of anti-Rohingya violence may not be confined to Burma. In May 2013, two Indonesians were arrested for allegedly planning to attack the Burmese Embassy in Jakarta with pipe-bombs to express solidarity with Rohingyas. The blasts in India's Bodh Gaya last year were also supposedly executed to avenge the killing of Rohingyas. At the same time, Sri Lanka's Bodu Bala Sena (BBS) defends the anti-Rohingya campaign in Burma, claiming that Buddhists are acting out of self-preservation. Thailand’s four southernmost provinces, where Muslims are in a majority, are witnessing an insurgency. All this is certain to further vitiate the atmosphere in Southeast Asia.

so whats ur take on illegal immigration?

They ain't illegals there in lies the problem. They've been there for centuries so they're in no way fit the description of illegals.
 
. . . . .
Is there even an immigration law in the 14th century?

ofcourse some of them mustve been there for centuries,,but bulk of the migration occurred during 1970's
@alaungphaya

There were no immigration laws in the 14th century but there were immigration controls in the 19th century. However, the British came in then and brought Bengali coolies with them. This is the first wave.

The bulk of them came in the early 70's after the Bangladesh independence war. This is the second wave. This is why the article mentioned the law passed in 1982 which was in reaction to this. This law was coincidental to a military operation called 'Naga Min' whose objective was to purge the West of Islamists who were trying to fight for a separatist Islamic state. Do you think this is the work of 14th century muslims?

Notice the last part of the article I posted:

In May 2013, two Indonesians were arrested for allegedly planning to attack the Burmese Embassy in Jakarta with pipe-bombs to express solidarity with Rohingyas. The blasts in India's Bodh Gaya last year were also supposedly executed to avenge the killing of Rohingyas. At the same time, Sri Lanka's Bodu Bala Sena (BBS) defends the anti-Rohingya campaign in Burma, claiming that Buddhists are acting out of self-preservation. Thailand’s four southernmost provinces, where Muslims are in a majority, are witnessing an insurgency. All this is certain to further vitiate the atmosphere in Southeast Asia.

Source: Myanmar General Discussion (non military) | Page 14

This is why the Rohingya situation is beyond critical.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom