Muslim Indians Should Demand A Seperate Nation:--

[BanglaBhoot]

Its not a bad demand..But again, this demand is already met in 1947....If they demand again, the again, the original discussion will come into play....Why the heck even Pakistan got created if Indian Muslim did not choose for Pakistan..

It took a further 80 years for Indian Muslims to realize that Jinnah was right after all ....

 

[Lord ZeN]

Pakistanis since their inception in 1947 always wet dreamed of breaking India but what actually happened was the exact opposite. There is a really high chance of history repeating itself once again. So it's Pakistanis who should be worried about their country and it's survival not India.

 

[Arsalan mehmud]

Actually, as a died-in-the-wool nominalist, I object to the term 'Indian Muslim'. That is a false category. I believe that we should correctly refer to Indians who follow Islam as their religion as 'Muslim Indians', as I am an 'Atheist Indian'.



I know this will make no difference to a fine, upstanding hater like you, but if it were not for the portions in green, I was about to give you a positive rating.

I am not a hater.. but such a incident happened in India is enough to create hatred...

 

[Stag112]

and all retards should be burnt to death

You are really a horrible excuse of a human being to say such a thing about people suffering from a neuro-physical disability. Thank Jinnah I don't have to share ANYTHING with the likes of you.

 

[Arsalan mehmud]

I don't know where you are from sir....But by seeing all your comments in this thread I come to the conclusion that you are not from India....I have been in India for sometime now....and I live in a neighborhood which is predominantly middle class and lower middle class....and I have to say there is NO Hindu Muslim problem here....as far as the state that I am living in is also experience NIL Hindu Muslim problem....Yes there is a Hindu and Muslim tension in India right now thanks to Media hype well this tension has been prevailing in this country since its independence isn't it.....


Demanding a new nation for Muslims in India in the current situation is a bad idea...I guess you know you what happened when India and Pakistan was separated how many people were killed in this incident, well if this happens again I fear many more innocent Muslims will die...

So instead of concentrating on Indian Muslims welfare I would ask Pakistan and Pakistani people to take care of their own people and take care of their own internal affairs make your nation prosperous




So what ?? Yes they are called chota Pakistan and I have heard that too....

your above post reminds me of an incident which took place nearly 35 years ago approx., That day India and Pakistan were playing cricket match... and India lost that match the adjacent restaurant owner started to waive Pakistani flag and started saying slogans or verses from Quran and said something to the effect of Pakistani Zindabad or something...And that was it...This started a major revamp of that whole area....the area where this restaurant was located was a very well high end Muslim area but now it is nearly a slum....Government of India didn't do that revamp it was the common people who did that....and that area is also called as chota Pakistan (thanks to that restaurant owner) and you should know that most of the people live there are Hindus right now....

That's mean there is propaganda by your govt who shows census about growth of muslim population rises...

 

[Rajesh12379]

Pakistanis since their inception in 1947 always wet dreamed of breaking India but what actually happened was the exact opposite. There is a really high chance of history repeating itself once again. So it's Pakistanis who should be worried about their country and it's survival not India.

Till the time the identity crisis and the obsession with India continues, this is going to be their fate.

This whole thread is about such wet dreams, self loathing and identity crisis.

Rather than following the sane advice of Hussain Haqqani to stop obsessing with India, such people find no other way to vent out their insecurities and the need for validation. Every bloody second.

Husain Haqqani to Pakistan: Stop competing with India and start focusing on our own welfare

It took a further 80 years for Indian Muslims to realize that Jinnah was right after all ....

But you realized just in 24 years the exact opposite.

 

[Max]

But you realized just in 24 years the exact opposite

See we dont want new Pakistan to merge in old Pakistan... we want friendly east Pakistan (new Pakistan) as new state.. may be we can have a joint military command with them along with Bangladesh in future... nothing more.. i agree we have our own quota of racists who cant tolerate ppl of alien cultures living in their land like equals... just like Bal thakray in India.. and u have to read history of ppl of Indus.. we were never land grabbers in history and will never be... hence only Kashmirs or maybe east Punjab or western pushtuns are open to join Pakistan... rest can have their own country.

Pakistanis since their inception in 1947 always wet dreamed of breaking India but what actually happened was the exact opposite. There is a really high chance of history repeating itself once again. So it's Pakistanis who should be worried about their country and it's survival not India.

When did we tried to break India? quote me one example? when did Pakistan tried to exploit Indian Muslims? when did Pakistan send weapons to Indian Muslims?

 

[Indika]

It took a further 80 years for Indian Muslims to realize that Jinnah was right after all ....

Oh yeah muslims in india are idiots and you are smart. This comes from a person who stays in a alien country rather than his own. ppl will always move to better place based on their capability & capacity. If pakistan was better muslims would have already done that.

If muslims of the other country were so welcoming than there was no need for pakistan every one could go to saudi and be happy.
LOL....Your own country is good example why pakistan is a unmitigated disaster and you end up preaching to others says volumes about your thinking capacity.

 

[Ahmad Sajjad Paracha]

Don'y worry. Pakistan has greater chance of breaking up. You have been broken before and this would happen as you could not keep peace between 4-5 ethnicities that you have (strange: Must be something to do with your religion). You people could not keep peace between even different sect of your religion. It is as if Islam makes people inherently bloodthirsty.

Grow up babies you have been saying these sort of things from long time but its if no avail

 

[Lord ZeN]

When did we tried to break India? quote me one example? when did Pakistan tried to exploit Indian Muslims? when did Pakistan send weapons to Indian Muslims?

Your country tried to do it but it miserably failed because unlike your Islamic republic of Pakistan where millions are ready to take up AK's for religious wars , in India it's not easy to get proxies.

For that very same reason your establishment had to send terrorists like Kasab & co. from Pakistan to carry out 26/11 attacks. It's because your establishment were incapable of finding Indian Muslims who would betray our country. On another note Pakistani support to terrorist organizations like Indian Mujahideen , Lashkar-e-Taiba and other terror outfits are well known and well documented.

Pakistan and state-sponsored terrorism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[prashantazazel]

Hundreds Of Pakistani Hindus Are Crossing The Thar Desert To Find Home And Hope In Jaisalmer!


Pakistan should look at the way it treats its own minorities before it starts to criticize India.

 

[Jackdaws]

I am just looking at population index

Population of India 1,000,000,000 (1 Billion)



Population of Muslims : 172,000 Million (Stuck In India)
Population of Pakistan : 180 Million
Population of Bangladesh: 161 Million


Therefore population of Muslims : 515 Million people in sub continent

That means population of Hindus : 800 Million People

(Note: I am not considering deducting Dalit 201 million in india if I did that the ration would be 1:1)


About Ratio 1 : 1.6

LOL - sure. You realize land is not a piece of cake.

So Hindus or should I say territorial India should have been just 0.5 % bigger then Muslim Pakistan

If anything the Land should have been divided
50:50
Or more justly 45 : 55

Not 27 : 73



Now , if the division was done CORRECTLY , there would more territory for Pakistan

 

[Rajesh12379]

Hundreds Of Pakistani Hindus Are Crossing The Thar Desert To Find Home And Hope In Jaisalmer!


Pakistan should look at the way it treats its own minorities before it starts to criticize India.

And people like the OP doing reverse hijarat to non Muslim countries should be subjected to similar treatment till they don't stop treating their non Muslims (and even Shia and Ahmedi and other non dominant sects) better.

 

[Spring Onion]

Pakistanis since their inception in 1947 always wet dreamed of breaking India but what actually happened was the exact opposite. There is a really high chance of history repeating itself once again. So it's Pakistanis who should be worried about their country and it's survival not India.

in fact these were indian leaders who claimed in 47 that Pakistan wont survive more than few days. but we did against all odds and at the same tine giving you nightmares

 

[Rajesh12379]

in fact these were indian leaders who claimed in 47 that Pakistan wont survive more than few days. but we did against all odds and at the same tine giving you nightmares

And there were Muslims who shouted "Hans ke liya hai Pakistan, lad ke lenge Hindustan". Those who were wet dreaming of returning with another Gaznavi. Those who thought that one Pakistani convert = 10 Indian Dharmic persons.

What happened to that?

We don't give a damn about Pakistan. You people need to move beyond 47 and stop obsessing about India and the fake history taught in Pakistan.