What's new

Murder, rape and shattered families: 1947 Partition Archive effort underway

WAJsal

SENIOR MODERATOR
Joined
Aug 31, 2014
Messages
7,879
Reaction score
212
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Avoid trolling,thank you.
5502810fc0e0e.jpg

Sept. 19, 1947: Muslim refugees sit on the roof of an overcrowded coach railway train near New Delhi in trying to flee India. Millions of Muslims migrated from India to Pakistan. Partition marked a massive upheaval across the subcontinent. Hindus living for generations in what was to become Pakistan had to flee their homes overnight. —AP/file
LAHORE: Sitting in his office while students stroll by under leafy shade trees and rickshaws tut-tut on a nearby road, Khawaja Muhammad Zakariya thinks back to a tumultuous time decades ago when his country was violently split in two: the partition of India.

His father hurried home one day, telling his young son they had to gather up their money and jewelry and leave their Muslim neighborhood immediately for an uncle's house across town.

“The day we moved ... that area was attacked, and many were killed and injured but we had left about two hours before,” Zakariya said, recalling the violence-plagued months leading up to partition.

The family later left Amritsar for good, taking only the valuables they could carry, joining other families on packed trains to Lahore.

The retired professor of Urdu literature in his mid-70s spoke from his office at Punjab University in Lahore, just 50 kilometers (30 miles) from the Indian city of Amritsar.

He was relaying his life history to a volunteer from The 1947 Partition Archive.

550280f3c29d8.jpg

Sept. 19, 1947: Muslim refugees sit on the roof of an overcrowded coach railway train near New Delhi in trying to flee India. Millions of Muslims migrated from India to Pakistan. Partition marked a massive upheaval across the subcontinent. Hindus living for generations in what was to become Pakistan had to flee their homes overnight. —AP/file
The archive is a massive effort to collect stories from people who remember the 1947 split of the subcontinent, often referred to the largest mass migration in history.

The generation that still remembers the birth of modern India and Pakistan are now elderly men and women, and it's a race against time to record as many stories as possible. “That segment of the population is disappearing really, really fast,” said Guneeta Singh Bhalla, the Berkeley, Calif.-based executive director and driving force of the archive, speaking by telephone. “Within the next five years the vast majority of what's remaining is going to be gone. “

Partition marked a massive and bloody upheaval.

Hindus living for generations in what was to become Pakistan had to flee their homes overnight.

At the same time, millions of Muslims abandoned their homes to cross the border into Pakistan.

550283830b468.jpg

A man looks at pictures regarding the history of Pakistan's independence, displayed at a museum in Lahore, Pakistan. Partition marked a massive upheaval across the subcontinent. Hindus living for generations in what was to become Pakistan had to flee their homes overnight. —AP
The hastily-arranged partition of the subcontinent into India and Pakistan was brokered by the departing British colonialists.

Months of violence preceded the partition announcement, often whipped up by politicians or various religious and political groups jockeying for power.

In the chaotic days and months following the August independence of India and Pakistan, violence multiplied as religious sentiment intensified and there was little in the way of police or military to maintain order.

There are no exact numbers of people killed and displaced, but estimates range from a few hundred thousand to two million killed and more than 10 million displaced.

Bhalla's interest in oral histories was sparked by a visit to a memorial in Hiroshima featuring similar work.

She began recording stories of survivors she knew in the US until there were so many people wanting to tell their story she recruited more volunteers.

Eventually she created a non-profit organization in 2011 devoted to tracking down survivors and recording their stories.

She quit her job in December 2012 and now devotes all her time to the archive, based out of offices at U.C. Berkeley.

So far, their contributors have collected more than 2,000 oral histories from partition survivors.

5502815dbe7c9.jpg

Prakhar Joshi, left, asks a question to 86-year old Desh Raj Kalra during an interview at his residence in New Delhi, India. Joshi has spent the last 15 months crisscrossing the country interviewing about 150 people to record oral histories including the partition of India. Often, this means listening to extremely personal stories of murder, rape and shattered families. —AP
They want to have 10,000 by 2017, she said. In a sign of how far people traveled after partition, Bhalla has received stories from nine countries and in 10 different languages.

Her own family migrated from Lahore to India during partition but emotional ties to the family's old hometown are strong:

“I still know their addresses."

In India, Prakhar Joshi has spent the last 15 months crisscrossing the country interviewing about 150 people.

550280f3c0bb4.jpg

86-year old Desh Raj Kalra talks with Prakhar Joshi, right, at the end of an interview at his residence in New Delhi, India. Joshi has spent the last 15 months crisscrossing the country interviewing about 150 people to record oral histories including the partition of India. Often, this means listening to extremely personal stories of murder, rape and shattered families. —AP
Often, this means listening to extremely personal stories of murder, rape and shattered families.

While every person he interviewed had their own version of displacement, some stories left Joshi distraught for weeks.

He recalled a 76-year old man in New Delhi who was an eight-year old boy in a refugee camp on the Indian side of the border in the days when violence was at its height. “One of the camp leaders handed out sticks and other weapons to the men. And small spears to the young boys in the camp,” Joshi said.

The man told Joshi they were ordered to kill anyone younger than them.

After almost 68 years, Joshi said, the man still has trouble sleeping thinking about the children he killed. “When I started collecting stories, my first few stories were very traumatic. They shook me to the core. I knew riots had happened, but I never knew the scale of the savagery,” Joshi said.

Not every story is so horrific although partition seems to have left a lasting memory for most.

Desh Raj Kalra was 18 when his family left behind their sprawling house and grain trading store in Pakistan. He remembers a childhood where Hindus and Muslims lived together amicably.

But one day the village chief, who was Muslim, told them he'd heard reports of violence and that they should leave. “We thought we would be back in 10 to 15 days so we left everything behind. My grandfather told us: governments may change but people will never change. But it's been 68 years now. None of us ever went back. And now I am too old to make the journey,” he said.

The interviewers don't just ask about partition itself.

Armed with an extensive questionnaire, volunteer Umair Mushtaq talked with Zakariya, the retired professor, for three hours.

They discussed Zakariya's memories of flying kites as a young child, watching wrestling matches, his family's struggles as refugees in Pakistan, and Zakariya's university studies and marriage.

Eventually, Bhalla said, the archive would like to have a physical space where people can hear the histories and learn more about partition.

Zakariya said he's glad there's a project like this to make the stories available for future generations. “Even my children, they put many questions to me about partition,” he said.

“When I started collecting stories, my first few stories were very traumatic. They shook me to the core. I knew riots had happened, but I never knew the scale of the savagery,”
so sad ......:( The misery,the savagery.........
@levina ,@BetterPakistan ,@nair ,@SpArK ,@utraash ,@Blue_Eyes ,@Green Arrow ,@Imran Khan ,
@DESERT FIGHTER ,@Zarvan ,@LoveIcon ,@doppelganger ,@Akheilos .....
Avoid blaming Muslims,Hindus,Sikhs.....
Avoid trolling or else i have contacts with some mods.:p: Seriously,avoid trolling ,please.
 
Last edited:
.
Very painful story Waj bhai. What you want to do by raking it up again? Thankfully soon most who lived through it would be resting peacefully. Hopefully we too can as well then.
 
.
Partition was quite bad.... Several people lost their life on both sides of the border...... Probably that is one of the reason why we still hate each other.......
 
.
Very painful story Waj bhai. What you want to do by raking it up again? Thankfully soon most who lived through it would be resting peacefully. Hopefully we too can as well then.
This time it wont turn into a troll thread!
Partition was quite bad.... Several people lost their life on both sides of the border...... Probably that is one of the reason why we still hate each other.......
Lets not discuss that"Why we hate each other" ,off-topic ho jai ga .
 
.
This time it wont turn into a troll thread!

Lets not discuss that"Why we hate each other" ,off-topic ho jai ga .

The point was not to discuss it in specific, but to highlight how bad things were ......
 
.
I read somewhere that it features in the Guinnes Book of Records or maybe not but is widely accpted as the biggest single displacement of mankind in the history of humanity.

Quite serious shit.
 
.
Really a betrayal on Hindus. Lots of hindus had to leave Pakistan and lots of Muslims want to cross across to Pakistan . I really have one doubt . Then how and why Muslims are still left in India ? If this was to divide on the basis of religion ? Brutal betrayal. We lost our land yet we have share with Muslims in left out land. And Pakistan wants more land which is Kashmir and Bangladesh want more land and keep infiltrating it's Muslim population into East. Hope one day we will get our land back. May be in future in the next 100 years never mind. It belongs to our kids ...

And Father of Nation of India said All Muslims who want be in India can be here... Now this is called blunder. Same dint happen in Pakistan. How many minorities are left ? Many won't even know that they wr converted forcefully in their past. Sad man. Wonder what is the purpose of this post !!!
 
.
I have met few such people ho survived 47 .. There stories are indeed very painful .. Girls who jumped into wells to save their dignity .. Father who killed their daughters to save them from rioters... People whose family members were killed by sikh "jathas"(mobs).. Babies trying to feed from their dead mothers ...

We got this country soaked with blood and yet we don't respect it .. Take it all for granted.
 
.
Really a betrayal on Hindus. Lots of hindus had to leave Pakistan and lots of Muslims want to cross across to Pakistan . I really have one doubt . Then how and why Muslims are still left in India ? If this was to divide on the basis of religion ? Brutal betrayal. We lost our land yet we have share with Muslims in left out land. And Pakistan wants more land which is Kashmir and Bangladesh want more land and keep infiltrating it's Muslim population into East. Hope one day we will get our land back. May be in future in the next 100 years never mind. It belongs to our kids ...

And Father of Nation of India said All Muslims who want be in India can be here... Now this is called blunder. Same dint happen in Pakistan. How many minorities are left ? Many won't even know that they wr converted forcefully in their past. Sad man. Wonder what is the purpose of this post !!!

Your logic is diseased by hate. India was a larger country then Pakistan. Many Muslim communities wouldn't migrate during partition simply out of fear. Everyone knew what was happening on both sides, rape, murder and looting. Some Muslims like Hindus in Sindh decided it was safer to stay where they are rather then face risks on the journey.
 
.
Really a betrayal on Hindus. Lots of hindus had to leave Pakistan and lots of Muslims want to cross across to Pakistan . I really have one doubt . Then how and why Muslims are still left in India ? If this was to divide on the basis of religion ? Brutal betrayal. We lost our land yet we have share with Muslims in left out land. And Pakistan wants more land which is Kashmir and Bangladesh want more land and keep infiltrating it's Muslim population into East. Hope one day we will get our land back. May be in future in the next 100 years never mind. It belongs to our kids ...

And Father of Nation of India said All Muslims who want be in India can be here... Now this is called blunder. Same dint happen in Pakistan. How many minorities are left ? Many won't even know that they wr converted forcefully in their past. Sad man. Wonder what is the purpose of this post !!!

Modern day Pak was never part of Hindustan .. It was always a clear majority muslim territory .. The "frontier provinces" of the British empire.



The muslims supported Muslim League .. than there was a segment lead by the likes of Maulana "Azad" who were against the creation of Pak and were pro india... but they never had any influence in modern day Pak.. That is why they couldn't win any seat from this region (despite support from congress).


We don't want Kashmir (kashmir along with other muslim majority areas was already destined to be a part of Pakistan according to the partition formula).

Even in 47 .. Ghulab singh used genocode to try to stop the struggling KAshmiris who wanted to merge with Pak .. The genocode is well documented by neutral sources but I doubt you will accept them.
 
.
Avoid trolling,thank you.
5502810fc0e0e.jpg

Sept. 19, 1947: Muslim refugees sit on the roof of an overcrowded coach railway train near New Delhi in trying to flee India. Millions of Muslims migrated from India to Pakistan. Partition marked a massive upheaval across the subcontinent. Hindus living for generations in what was to become Pakistan had to flee their homes overnight. —AP/file
LAHORE: Sitting in his office while students stroll by under leafy shade trees and rickshaws tut-tut on a nearby road, Khawaja Muhammad Zakariya thinks back to a tumultuous time decades ago when his country was violently split in two: the partition of India.

His father hurried home one day, telling his young son they had to gather up their money and jewelry and leave their Muslim neighborhood immediately for an uncle's house across town.

“The day we moved ... that area was attacked, and many were killed and injured but we had left about two hours before,” Zakariya said, recalling the violence-plagued months leading up to partition.

The family later left Amritsar for good, taking only the valuables they could carry, joining other families on packed trains to Lahore.

The retired professor of Urdu literature in his mid-70s spoke from his office at Punjab University in Lahore, just 50 kilometers (30 miles) from the Indian city of Amritsar.

He was relaying his life history to a volunteer from The 1947 Partition Archive.

550280f3c29d8.jpg

Sept. 19, 1947: Muslim refugees sit on the roof of an overcrowded coach railway train near New Delhi in trying to flee India. Millions of Muslims migrated from India to Pakistan. Partition marked a massive upheaval across the subcontinent. Hindus living for generations in what was to become Pakistan had to flee their homes overnight. —AP/file
The archive is a massive effort to collect stories from people who remember the 1947 split of the subcontinent, often referred to the largest mass migration in history.

The generation that still remembers the birth of modern India and Pakistan are now elderly men and women, and it's a race against time to record as many stories as possible. “That segment of the population is disappearing really, really fast,” said Guneeta Singh Bhalla, the Berkeley, Calif.-based executive director and driving force of the archive, speaking by telephone. “Within the next five years the vast majority of what's remaining is going to be gone. “

Partition marked a massive and bloody upheaval.

Hindus living for generations in what was to become Pakistan had to flee their homes overnight.

At the same time, millions of Muslims abandoned their homes to cross the border into Pakistan.

550283830b468.jpg

A man looks at pictures regarding the history of Pakistan's independence, displayed at a museum in Lahore, Pakistan. Partition marked a massive upheaval across the subcontinent. Hindus living for generations in what was to become Pakistan had to flee their homes overnight. —AP
The hastily-arranged partition of the subcontinent into India and Pakistan was brokered by the departing British colonialists.

Months of violence preceded the partition announcement, often whipped up by politicians or various religious and political groups jockeying for power.

In the chaotic days and months following the August independence of India and Pakistan, violence multiplied as religious sentiment intensified and there was little in the way of police or military to maintain order.

There are no exact numbers of people killed and displaced, but estimates range from a few hundred thousand to two million killed and more than 10 million displaced.

Bhalla's interest in oral histories was sparked by a visit to a memorial in Hiroshima featuring similar work.

She began recording stories of survivors she knew in the US until there were so many people wanting to tell their story she recruited more volunteers.

Eventually she created a non-profit organization in 2011 devoted to tracking down survivors and recording their stories.

She quit her job in December 2012 and now devotes all her time to the archive, based out of offices at U.C. Berkeley.

So far, their contributors have collected more than 2,000 oral histories from partition survivors.

5502815dbe7c9.jpg

Prakhar Joshi, left, asks a question to 86-year old Desh Raj Kalra during an interview at his residence in New Delhi, India. Joshi has spent the last 15 months crisscrossing the country interviewing about 150 people to record oral histories including the partition of India. Often, this means listening to extremely personal stories of murder, rape and shattered families. —AP
They want to have 10,000 by 2017, she said. In a sign of how far people traveled after partition, Bhalla has received stories from nine countries and in 10 different languages.

Her own family migrated from Lahore to India during partition but emotional ties to the family's old hometown are strong:

“I still know their addresses."

In India, Prakhar Joshi has spent the last 15 months crisscrossing the country interviewing about 150 people.

550280f3c0bb4.jpg

86-year old Desh Raj Kalra talks with Prakhar Joshi, right, at the end of an interview at his residence in New Delhi, India. Joshi has spent the last 15 months crisscrossing the country interviewing about 150 people to record oral histories including the partition of India. Often, this means listening to extremely personal stories of murder, rape and shattered families. —AP
Often, this means listening to extremely personal stories of murder, rape and shattered families.

While every person he interviewed had their own version of displacement, some stories left Joshi distraught for weeks.

He recalled a 76-year old man in New Delhi who was an eight-year old boy in a refugee camp on the Indian side of the border in the days when violence was at its height. “One of the camp leaders handed out sticks and other weapons to the men. And small spears to the young boys in the camp,” Joshi said.

The man told Joshi they were ordered to kill anyone younger than them.

After almost 68 years, Joshi said, the man still has trouble sleeping thinking about the children he killed. “When I started collecting stories, my first few stories were very traumatic. They shook me to the core. I knew riots had happened, but I never knew the scale of the savagery,” Joshi said.

Not every story is so horrific although partition seems to have left a lasting memory for most.

Desh Raj Kalra was 18 when his family left behind their sprawling house and grain trading store in Pakistan. He remembers a childhood where Hindus and Muslims lived together amicably.

But one day the village chief, who was Muslim, told them he'd heard reports of violence and that they should leave. “We thought we would be back in 10 to 15 days so we left everything behind. My grandfather told us: governments may change but people will never change. But it's been 68 years now. None of us ever went back. And now I am too old to make the journey,” he said.

The interviewers don't just ask about partition itself.

Armed with an extensive questionnaire, volunteer Umair Mushtaq talked with Zakariya, the retired professor, for three hours.

They discussed Zakariya's memories of flying kites as a young child, watching wrestling matches, his family's struggles as refugees in Pakistan, and Zakariya's university studies and marriage.

Eventually, Bhalla said, the archive would like to have a physical space where people can hear the histories and learn more about partition.

Zakariya said he's glad there's a project like this to make the stories available for future generations. “Even my children, they put many questions to me about partition,” he said.

“When I started collecting stories, my first few stories were very traumatic. They shook me to the core. I knew riots had happened, but I never knew the scale of the savagery,”
so sad ......:( The misery,the savagery.........
@levina ,@BetterPakistan ,@nair ,@SpArK ,@utraash ,@Blue_Eyes ,@Green Arrow ,@Imran Khan ,
@DESERT FIGHTER ,@Zarvan ,@LoveIcon ,@doppelganger ,@Akheilos .....


you have hit the nerves.... heard a lot of painful stories from my grandparents when they had to leave Dhaka and Noakhali.....:(:(
 
.
than there was a segment lead by the likes of Maulana "Azad"

Did you know that Maulana Azad also supported likes of Ahrar? Known extremist Mullahs whose goal was to wipe Ahmadiyya from face of the world. Today these Ahraris reside in Pakistan and create a lot of trouble in Rabwah. Ahraris were anti Pakistan, so wtf are they doing in Pakistan? They should be sent back to their motherland India to be buried with Moualna Azad.
 
. .
Modern day Pak was never part of Hindustan .. It was always a clear majority muslim territory .. The "frontier provinces" of the British empire.



The muslims supported Muslim League .. than there was a segment lead by the likes of Maulana "Azad" who were against the creation of Pak and were pro india... but they never had any influence in modern day Pak.. That is why they couldn't win any seat from this region (despite support from congress).


We don't want Kashmir (kashmir along with other muslim majority areas was already destined to be a part of Pakistan according to the partition formula).

Even in 47 .. Ghulab singh used genocode to try to stop the struggling KAshmiris who wanted to merge with Pak .. The genocode is well documented by neutral sources but I doubt you will accept them.
75% plus of the muslim vote and 90%+ of the UP vote went to the Muslim League which wanted an independent Pakistan.
 
.
No point in opening this thread.

Hindus will say, they were killed & oppressed.

Muslim will say, they were killed & oppressed.

Sikhs will say, they were killed & oppressed.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom