More than 50 afghan soldiers killed:IG FC

[Eminent Mainstream Media]

Hahaha ... any other joke ... they cant control anything other than Kabul ...

Yet they came and did what they did yesterday- You should avoid quoting me unless you have something useful to say-

 

[Icarus]

Let the Greeks make the claim first why are we Jumping into It already- The point with Afghanistan is that they are not shying away from making their claims even while they are at such weak position- and such claims unite them-

Their "unity" has kept the country in a state of civil war for 4 decades, I think we have different interpretations of the word.

 

[Eminent Mainstream Media]

*Ceded to the British by the Afghans in exchange for the guarantee that they will allow Afghanistan complete internal autonomy and provide them protection against the Russians.

Russians are gone and so have the British-

 

[saiyan0321]

The Greeks just called, they conquered this land first. Well, based on historical claims I guess we should all just pack up and enjoy a χωριάτικη σαλάτα.

Lolzz they surrender these lands and gave it away signing treaties with British to protect Kabul. Anyhow what does it matter. The areas in pakistan are loyal. Even the most dangerous movement of Taliban was not a secessionist but an ideological one.

When was the last time Afghanistan was united. Three generations have come and Afghanistan has not seen unity. Always some part is always forming their own government. A state of prepetual civil war in a never ending game.


As for this incident. As I said in the main thread. Torkham all over again. I am expecting some afghan official to come forward and say that, " if pakistan does not stop the census then we will reveal the secrets of the Durand line that will shake pakistan". They said the same thing in torkham.

 

[Path-Finder]

Russians are gone and so have the British-

Russians are re entering afghanistan slowly and Britain is in afghanistan as part of NATO

 

[Icarus]

Just noticed the sub-text. The Rawalpindi Treaty of 1919 did not have any expiry clause. It stated that the treaty may be rescinded by either party within the first three years of signing, which it wasn't.

Russians are gone and so have the British-

But we have inherited the land, as was legally released to the (then) Dominion of Pakistan by the British.

 

[Eminent Mainstream Media]

Their "unity" has kept the country in a state of civil war for 4 decades, I think we have different interpretations of the word.

I think It would be a mistake to see the civil war as a state of disagreement when It comes to the extent of Afghan Nation territorially, ethnically and linguistically- Its a known fact historically that they unite when It comes to their national interests-

 

[Basel]

Check out @Insafipk's Tweet:

https://twitter.com/x/status/860835542380019713

 

[Icarus]

I think It would be a mistake to see the civil war as a state of disagreement when It comes to the extent of Afghan Nation territorially, ethnically and linguistically- Its a known fact historically that they unite when It comes to their national interests-

I would categorically disagree to this assessment. Afghan identity is indeed valuable to the people but their interests have always been split into three distinct groups, the Pushtuns, the Darriwals and the Northerners.

Even as close as last elections the country was on the brink of war (war-ception) when Abdullah Abdullah refused to accept the results.

 

[Dhara]

A humble advice to Pakistani members and forces as being former Indian army officer, R&AW, CIA wants Afghan, Pakistan war since CIA fails to clear Taliban and they know Pakistan army is quite capable to handle this mess but I must say in this quest Pakistani forces would be consumed heavily and that is Why R&AW is interested and working with CIA, Just leave them they are good for nothing, they have nothing to save and Pakistan has lot of things on stake.

 

[Eminent Mainstream Media]

But we have inherited the land, as was legally released to the (then) Dominion of Pakistan by the British.

You inherited their land which they had to surrender to the imperial power British- try explaining your case to a Afghan- now that imperial power Britain/Russia no longer exists-

Add to that the humiliation of having their territory under the people whom they have ruled for most part of recent medieval history-

I am not Justifying their demands- Just trying to figure out their case-

 

[cerberus]

https://twitter.com/x/status/861185632613392385

Ispr lies busted

 

[nangyale]

They want their historical territory back which was taken by British- Afghanistan is older than Pakistan-

This unites all warring Afghan fraction like Taliban along with the present Government-

Good to see that Indians are advocating for the independence of Kashmir. So when is the Indian occupation army vacating Kashmir?

 

[Morpheus]

What is common between indian and Afghan army? They both like to kill civilians.

 

[Eminent Mainstream Media]

I would categorically disagree to this assessment. Afghan identity is indeed valuable to the people but their interests have always been split into three distinct groups, the Pushtuns, the Darriwals and the Northerners.

Even as close as last elections the country was on the brink of war (war-ception) when Abdullah Abdullah refused to accept the results.

I think there have been five groups historically- even before Islam came- Yes they have great differences but their idea of Afghan boundaries match-

Good to see that Indians are advocating for the independence of Kashmir. So when is the Indian occupation army vacating Kashmir?

If Pakistan has already evacuated and surrendered Baluchistan and NWFP we can settle Kashmir with Afghans-

Now please stay on topic-