What's new

Maoists will overthrow govt much before 2050 : Kishenji

Status
Not open for further replies.
Prabhat Sharan is a Senior Journalist and Editor of MEDIA PRAXIS a monthly magazine published from Mumbai. He can be contacted at verdictweekly@gmail.com




Roiling with contained anger at the revisiting of colonial history with a new face, the deep hinterlands of the Indian sub-continent is once again witnessing the explosion and implosion not seen since late Sixties when the peasants and tribal uprising shook the entire Indian peninsula..

A spectre is haunting Europe — the spectre of communism. All the powers of old Europe have entered into a holy alliance to exorcise this spectre: Pope and Tsar, Metternich and Guizot, French Radicals and German police-spies. (Manifesto of the Communist Party: 1848)

Now, again a spectre is haunting. The region is [India] and the spectre is of people’s movements. All the exploitative powers in [India] have come together to pulverize the resistance movements.

Movements-soaked in anger against the usurious usurpation of forests, hills, rivers and ocean waters–movements voicing protest against the destruction of the livelihood and autocratic attempts to transmogrify lives into that of zombies trapped in internal diasporia in alienation saturated heterotopias– are simmering and glimmering and igniting fire in the minds of the oppressed people across the country.

Roiling with contained anger at the revisiting of colonial history with a new face, the deep hinterlands of [India] is once again witnessing the explosion and implosion not seen since late Sixties when the peasants and tribal uprising shook the entire Indian peninsula.

Spontaneous and peaceful in nature with stray incidents of a cornered-retaliatory violence- the movements like in the Sixties when the sub-human conditions of tribal folks and landless labourers came to fore following the revolt, at the dawn of the new millennium the protests are revealing the rapacious Medusa locks of corporate greed.

The result-even as the wild life on land, air and sea are fast disappearing from the country – the Indian State in a bid to keep the memories of the creatures of the wild alive and as an apology to Nature, are churning out forces like-Octopus, Cobras, Scorpions, Tigers (with green stripes) Cats of all hues and shades, Grey Hounds, Mastiffs, Wolves, Vipers, Black Mamba etc.

If by any chance the Indian Home Ministry exhausts the zoological who’s who in their war against the people’s resistance, then the readers and viewers of the corporate establishment media may soon read and hear eulogised announcements of forces with names like Vampires, Draculas, Aadamkhors-all with a sole purpose- to crush people’s movements and usurp the land, rivers and oceans, for corporate houses.

After all there is gold in the hills and pearls of profits in water. Indian sub-continent is witnessing what the American sub-continent witnessed in 19th century-the Gold Rush. The country is the 21st century El Dorado for the western world and their Indian lackeys. And like in the past when the imperialist forces decimated the American natives, the history is being re-enacted in India.

Describing the devastation during the Gold Rush, Rawls, James J. and Orsi, Richard J. in their book “A golden state: mining and economic development in Gold Rush California,” write, “The human and environmental costs of the Gold Rush were substantial. Native Americans dependent on the health and bounty of the natural environment, became the victims of starvation and disease when it suffered from the effects of placer mining (or the later, even more damaging, hydraulic mining), as gravel, silt and toxic chemicals from prospecting operations killed fish and destroyed habitats. The surge of mining population also resulted in the disappearance of game and food gathering locales as gold camps and other settlements were built amidst them, causing the forests to be cut down and domestic animals put to graze on the land. Later farming spread to supply the camps, taking more land from the use of Native Americans. Starvation often provoked the Native tribes to steal or take by force food and livestock from the whites, increasing white hostility and provoking retaliation against them.

“The Act for the Government and Protection of Indians passed on April 22, 1850 by the California Legislature, allowed settlers to continue the Californio practice of capturing and using Native people as bonded workers. It also provided the basis for the enslavement and trafficking in Native American labor, particularly that of young women and children, which was carried on as a legal business enterprise. Native American villages were regularly raided to supply the demand, and young women and children were carried off to be sold, the men and remaining people often being killed in genocidal attacks.” The same dance of death reduced the African continent from lush green land of plentiful to a bleached, gnarled bones, with its people now dying in hunger and women opening their legs for a loaf of bread to feed their children and themselves.

The countries in this continent, reduced to the darkest darkness of a black hole, emerge at the dawn only to disappear in the twilight of gun fires; and this blood-soaked melee of power, hunger and survival rake in profits for the corporate dictators strutting around as peddlers of “democracy and development.”

The same screenplay is being played out in Indian sub-continent. Not that Indian sub-continent had not seen the imperialist invasion and greed earlier, but then the battle-lines were not so obfuscated, as it is now. The script that is being played out in the forests is more insidious.

The forested regions are home to some of the oldest communities of India, described variously as adivasi (aboriginal), vanvasi (forest dwellers), girijan (people of the hills) and after the transfer of power in 1947, the Indian constitution under a façade of benevolence brought them under a collective name of “Scheduled Tribes.”

What the powers of the State had forgotten is the history of struggle and resistance by tribes who are no strangers to displacement. The Godavari hills still reverberate with the sound of the drums when tribes of Koya and Reddy opposed the British colonial oppression.

Similarly, for the Santhal resistance, a British officer remarked in his journal: “The one piece of equipment they did not have among their meagre possessions was a white flag.”

The scene today is also the same. Raising the white flag is not an option for the Chenchu of the southern Tiger Hills, the Gond of the central Adilabad, the Gadrchiroli, the Moraya and Dorla Koya of Chhattisgarh, or the Dongri Khond of Orissa who lead a simple life not very different from their stone-age ancestors.

Though overtly there seems to be nothing that would attract the predators from the corporate houses, but then like in the 19th century American continent, or in Africa, the adivasis are sitting on a cornucopia which they can jingle their insatiable money vaults.

According to a research report, “a conservative list includes bauxite in Orissa, Iron ore in Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand states, and deposits of uranium, limestone, marble, dolomite, tin, graphite, copper, gold, diamonds, corundum, beryl, alexandrite and fluorite, and possibly coal in addition to teak, hardwood, bamboo, waters of several rivers, wildlife and fish. The bauxite deposits alone have been estimated to be worth between US$2-4 trillion. “

This El Dorado which the pirates from the multinationals are eyeing, stretches approximately 10,000 kilometres encompassing uncharted dense forests known locally as Abhujmad (unknown forests) cutting across states like Chhattisgarh, Orissa, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh and Andhra Pradesh.

And in the language of the government, the corporate establishment media and self-proclaimed “security” experts, the stretch is the “red corridor”, “red zone” or “Maoist stronghold”.

Of course, the tribes are not the only one who inhabit this stretch, along with them living on the fringes are petty traders, police and forest departments and guerrillas termed as “Naxalites”, “extremists”, “Maoists” or the self-described armed squads of the Communist party of India-Maoist.

The Maoist party, which is one of the biggest faction of the so-called Naxalite parties, is reportedly known for sabotage activities, arbitrary violence, sometimes amounting to barbaric brutality.

But for the State this brand of Naxalism has come as a boon and a bogey to launch a war against the tribes ironically under the name: Operation Green Hunt. A hunt to throw out the natives from the forests and hand it over to the corporate for ravaging and pillaging.

The scale of pillaging operations can be seen from the fact that a small state like Jharkhand had signed 90 memorandum of understanding (MoU) with various big plundering houses. The now tainted chief minister of the state once lauded by the corporate media, was found in possession of 1 billion $. Till date no enquires have been made as to who were the beneficiaries who paid these monies.

With Operation Green Hunt being planned as long drawn protracted armed campaign, every vested interest in the region wants to perpetuate the violence and since such armed conflict grants enormous powers to extract bribes shady activities like poaching and logging has abounded.

The State in its indifference to environment or the natives want to install power plants, open cast mines, highways, airstrips and of course generate employment for the tribal folk as measly-paid security guards or sweat shop workers and prop up some of the folk as quisling collaborators.

But not everybody wants to be a quisling collaborator. Struggles in Nandigram, Singur, Plachimada and other places have shown that people’s resistance call them Naxalism or by any other name, cannot be suppressed and it is this spectre which is haunting the State and Corporate predators alike in the post-recession period since even the uneasy squeamish urban populace is fast losing faith in the Friedman economics. Naxalism: Spectre Of People’s Movements By Prabhat Sharan, 04 March, 2010, MEDIA PRAXIS / The Verdict

Prabhat Sharan is a Senior Journalist and Editor of MEDIA PRAXIS a monthly magazine published from Mumbai. He can be contacted at verdictweekly@gmail.com
 
.
Your home sec appears to disagree with you. Thousands of sq km of territory is under Maoist control... and the areas are growing. Not only that, the Home Sec's estimate is 10 years to free these areas given the 100,000 troops deployed.

If the Home Sec is even half right, the future does not look all that good...

"He said the operations to recover territory from Maoist control would take anything between seven to 10 years, revealing that paramilitary forces did liberate 4,000 square kilometres during 2009. But he candidly admitted that they (Maoists) have take over territories in other regions."

Daily Times - Leading News Resource of Pakistan

The threat perception and the timeframe quoted by the Home Sec is more from the point of view of the difficult terrain (jungles) rather than the size of the area. The terrain and local support in rural areas makes it hard to clear them out.

And yes indeed it is thousands of kms but in in terms of the areas - The north and west completely and south in majority is unaffected by the Maoist problem. Its just the central and eastern jungles that need to be controlled.
 
.
My response to the video

The guest on he show, Radha D Souza says that govt should look at economically uplift the areas, instead of military options. Its very easy to sit in an AC office in London and pass such tree hugging hipppie comments. The situation on ground in these areas is very different. These people dont care about recourses or upliftment anymore. They have a history of blowing up goverment buildings, infrasructure, derailing trains even blowing up schools. They kidnap and murder anyone associated with the govt. how can the govt provide aid in such areas then. The social upliftment can be achieved once the areas are free of these pests.:sniper:
 
.
Let's assume you are correct and the home minister has indeed pointed to the future of "these rebels"

In that case, you are still in for a decade long fight with over 100,000 troops committed. Do you not think this will create massive problems for the economy, stability and future prospects?

Sorry for interrupting,
How do you assume hat the fight will last 10 years ? The article states it could last between 7-10 years for FULLY cleaning the mess.

The Indian Army has stated it will eliminate the naxals in 4 years, if necessary.

Also, we have already fought naxals in 2009 and it did not have any significant effect on the economy. With the maoist problem solved India's future will only get better and the future development will be more uniform. Naxalites are trying to topple the Indian government and they do not harm civilians to the extent of what other organizations in the subcontinent do ! :pakistan:
 
.
Let's assume you are correct and the home minister has indeed pointed to the future of "these rebels"

In that case, you are still in for a decade long fight with over 100,000 troops committed. Do you not think this will create massive problems for the economy, stability and future prospects?

These fights are limited to certain areas. The maoists are not a huge army, but a fragmented band of soldiers, well maybe a bit more one might argue. These areas are economically very poor, and do not contribute much economically and are not densely populated. So occurance of civil wars on a sizable scale is ruled out along with the possiblity of economic losses. I agree that the govts have been negligent in the past, to provide social and economic aid to these people which led to the movement in the first place. But the movement itself is now a hinderance in the way of development of these areas. Once the areas are clear, situation starts improving, the goverment will provide the resources to help these lagging regions. India will emerge more stronger, socially and economically after this operation , which i feel should not take a decade. Well i may be wrong i am no defence analyst!
 
.
Talk or we'll attack cities, Kishanji warns Centre
Sukumar Mahato, TNN, Mar 7, 2010, 12.47am IST

SOMEWHERE ON THE BENGAL-JHARKHAND BORDER: The Maoists are now training their guns on big cities and Kolkata and Bhubaneswar could be among their next targets if the government does not announce talks immediately, a senior commander has warned.

The threat came from CPI (Maoist) politburo member and military commander Koteswar Rao, alias Kishanji. He served the government with an ultimatum from his jungle hideout on Saturday, threatening to strike cities and towns if it rejected their offer of talks.

Chief ministers Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee and Naveen Patnaik — in Kolkata and Bhubaneswar respectively — have been insisting that operations against the Maoists be stepped up.

Kishanji put Jharkhand chief minister Shibu Soren in a different bracket. "He comes from a tribal family and understands their problems. We will confront him only when he acts adversely," the Maoist leader said. He also endorsed Bihar chief minister Nitish Kumar's demand that a major share of mining income should be spent in the area instead of being sent to Delhi.

Asked whether Naxals would be responsible for the bloodbath in case of intensified strikes, Kishanji said, "Why blame us? The government is not sure what it wants. We honoured Chidambaram's proposal of a 72-hour ceasefire before the talks. I gave my cell number to the media and kept it open for three hours on February 25 waiting for the government to call me. None of the officials called me."

But many caution that the Maoists are not sincere about talks and will use the truce as an opportunity to regroup and re-arm themselves.

And as proof, they point out that although Kishanji gave a ceasefire call on February 23, there was no let up in Maoist attacks. Kishanji blamed government for not honouring the truce call, saying forces went ahead with their operations and killed Lalmohan Tudu, leader of People's Committee against Police Atrocities.

The Maoists will not take it lying down, he asserted. "We will intensify our strikes if government does not initiate talks. If need be, we will proceed towards towns and cities." "Governments have been blaming us for violence. Our party came into being some years ago. What about the phase when we were not there? What have the governments done for welfare of the adivasis in last 53 years?" he asked.

He claimed that 90% of adivasis can't avail of government jobs under reserved category. Quite a number of reserved posts have to be converted to the general category because the authorities do not get any applications under this category.

Talk or we'll attack cities, Kishanji warns Centre - India - The Times of India
 
.
Talk or we'll attack cities, Kishanji warns Centre
Sukumar Mahato, TNN, Mar 7, 2010, 12.47am IST

SOMEWHERE ON THE BENGAL-JHARKHAND BORDER: The Maoists are now training their guns on big cities and Kolkata and Bhubaneswar could be among their next targets if the government does not announce talks immediately, a senior commander has warned.

The threat came from CPI (Maoist) politburo member and military commander Koteswar Rao, alias Kishanji. He served the government with an ultimatum from his jungle hideout on Saturday, threatening to strike cities and towns if it rejected their offer of talks.

Chief ministers Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee and Naveen Patnaik — in Kolkata and Bhubaneswar respectively — have been insisting that operations against the Maoists be stepped up.

Kishanji put Jharkhand chief minister Shibu Soren in a different bracket. "He comes from a tribal family and understands their problems. We will confront him only when he acts adversely," the Maoist leader said. He also endorsed Bihar chief minister Nitish Kumar's demand that a major share of mining income should be spent in the area instead of being sent to Delhi.

Asked whether Naxals would be responsible for the bloodbath in case of intensified strikes, Kishanji said, "Why blame us? The government is not sure what it wants. We honoured Chidambaram's proposal of a 72-hour ceasefire before the talks. I gave my cell number to the media and kept it open for three hours on February 25 waiting for the government to call me. None of the officials called me."

But many caution that the Maoists are not sincere about talks and will use the truce as an opportunity to regroup and re-arm themselves.

And as proof, they point out that although Kishanji gave a ceasefire call on February 23, there was no let up in Maoist attacks. Kishanji blamed government for not honouring the truce call, saying forces went ahead with their operations and killed Lalmohan Tudu, leader of People's Committee against Police Atrocities.

The Maoists will not take it lying down, he asserted. "We will intensify our strikes if government does not initiate talks. If need be, we will proceed towards towns and cities." "Governments have been blaming us for violence. Our party came into being some years ago. What about the phase when we were not there? What have the governments done for welfare of the adivasis in last 53 years?" he asked.

He claimed that 90% of adivasis can't avail of government jobs under reserved category. Quite a number of reserved posts have to be converted to the general category because the authorities do not get any applications under this category.

Talk or we'll attack cities, Kishanji warns Centre - India - The Times of India

These cowards do not have the balls, to take their *** out of the thick jungles which has been shielding them. Signs of desperation. Barking dogs seldom bite.:bunny:
 
.
Sorry for interrupting,
How do you assume hat the fight will last 10 years ? The article states it could last between 7-10 years for FULLY cleaning the mess.

The Indian Army has stated it will eliminate the naxals in 4 years, if necessary.

What kind of estimate do you think the Home Sec would give? A highly inflated estimate reflecting badly on him and his dept. or an optimistic one? I think the latter. Therefore, I was being generous in accepting the upper end of the Home Sec's own estimate. In reality, it may take longer.

As for the Indian Army's statement, what they mean by "if necessary". Is it currently not necessary to eliminate an insurgency that has spread across a significant percentage of Indian territory?

Coulda, shoulda, woulda... DIDN'T.

Also, we have already fought naxals in 2009 and it did not have any significant effect on the economy. With the maoist problem solved India's future will only get better and the future development will be more uniform. Naxalites are trying to topple the Indian government and they do not harm civilians to the extent of what other organizations in the subcontinent do !

Ok. So they are nice and polite insurgents I suppose... then why even position 100,000 troops against them.

For folks that "do not harm", their stated aim of violently overthrowing the Indian Government doesn't seem to quite fit your novel caricature.
 
.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^6666
Dude ignore the troll comment. Please, this has been a good thread so far, otherwise again there will be a flame war!!btw i have tried to sort of answer your question through my reply, its pretty generalised but we can just speculate the future!!
 
.
Talk or we'll attack cities, Kishanji warns Centre
Sukumar Mahato, TNN, Mar 7, 2010, 12.47am IST

SOMEWHERE ON THE BENGAL-JHARKHAND BORDER: The Maoists are now training their guns on big cities and Kolkata and Bhubaneswar could be among their next targets if the government does not announce talks immediately, a senior commander has warned.

The threat came from CPI (Maoist) politburo member and military commander Koteswar Rao, alias Kishanji. He served the government with an ultimatum from his jungle hideout on Saturday, threatening to strike cities and towns if it rejected their offer of talks.

Chief ministers Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee and Naveen Patnaik — in Kolkata and Bhubaneswar respectively — have been insisting that operations against the Maoists be stepped up.

Kishanji put Jharkhand chief minister Shibu Soren in a different bracket. "He comes from a tribal family and understands their problems. We will confront him only when he acts adversely," the Maoist leader said. He also endorsed Bihar chief minister Nitish Kumar's demand that a major share of mining income should be spent in the area instead of being sent to Delhi.

Asked whether Naxals would be responsible for the bloodbath in case of intensified strikes, Kishanji said, "Why blame us? The government is not sure what it wants. We honoured Chidambaram's proposal of a 72-hour ceasefire before the talks. I gave my cell number to the media and kept it open for three hours on February 25 waiting for the government to call me. None of the officials called me."

But many caution that the Maoists are not sincere about talks and will use the truce as an opportunity to regroup and re-arm themselves.

And as proof, they point out that although Kishanji gave a ceasefire call on February 23, there was no let up in Maoist attacks. Kishanji blamed government for not honouring the truce call, saying forces went ahead with their operations and killed Lalmohan Tudu, leader of People's Committee against Police Atrocities.

The Maoists will not take it lying down, he asserted. "We will intensify our strikes if government does not initiate talks. If need be, we will proceed towards towns and cities." "Governments have been blaming us for violence. Our party came into being some years ago. What about the phase when we were not there? What have the governments done for welfare of the adivasis in last 53 years?" he asked.

He claimed that 90% of adivasis can't avail of government jobs under reserved category. Quite a number of reserved posts have to be converted to the general category because the authorities do not get any applications under this category.

Talk or we'll attack cities, Kishanji warns Centre - India - The Times of India

The statement by him clearly shows how much he is desperate for talks and how operation green hunt is sucessfull is tackling naxals..
 
.
What kind of estimate do you think the Home Sec would give? A highly inflated estimate reflecting badly on him and his dept. or an optimistic one? I think the latter. Therefore, I was being generous in accepting the upper end of the Home Sec's own estimate. In reality, it may take longer.

As for the Indian Army's statement, what they mean by "if necessary". Is it currently not necessary to eliminate an insurgency that has spread across a significant percentage of Indian territory?

Coulda, shoulda, woulda... DIDN'T.

Tech buddy you misunderstood his point..The army said they will eliminate the red menace with in four years if they were called up on..they were not deployed yet to hunt down maoists...

Ok. So they are nice and polite insurgents I suppose... then why even position 100,000 troops against them.

For folks that "do not harm", their stated aim of violently overthrowing the Indian Government doesn't seem to quite fit your novel caricature.

Actually some of them are patriotic persons.Some of the leaders got arrested are well settled people with nice jobs..but they sacrificed all for the poor and for the empowerment of poor.Government itself know they also have to blame them selves for the naxal menace..and also that organisation was heavily infiltrated by criminals ..naxals were not used to kill innocent civilans ..there targets were police and other govt officials..But recentlt they burned down an entire villageand kill some villagers becuase villagers refused to join them ..steps like this will making them unpopular among people and it also shows deperation among naxalites of not getting new recruits..
 
.
Let's assume you are correct and the home minister has indeed pointed to the future of "these rebels"

In that case, you are still in for a decade long fight with over 100,000 troops committed. Do you not think this will create massive problems for the economy, stability and future prospects?

About The Economy:

India has been fighting the Kashmir issue since its independence. Terrorists have always targeted economic centers like Mumbai in order to create terror among both Indians and its investors, but India has only grown strength to strength when it comes to its economy.

About Stability

Again, trouble makers have targeted India's social fabric, Religious Sentiments and what not. Cases to note are trying to fabricate a Hindu-Muslim divide, Kashmir issues, Khalistan, Tamil issues but that has not divided India. These issues are in fact based on the biggest sentiments of India but nothing has happened!

You tell me about the future prospects? Being a victim of terror, mismanagement, bureaucracy, India today is in the headlines for all the good reasons. After Mumbai, After a serious Global Economic Slowdown, India soldiered on.. India seems to get stronger with every problem it faces. I'm not saying it out of pride, its a fact that you know too.
 
.
As for the Indian Army's statement, what they mean by "if necessary". Is it currently not necessary to eliminate an insurgency that has spread across a significant percentage of Indian territory?

Coulda, shoulda, woulda... DIDN'T.

"If necessary" means that the Government of India will try and take every step necessary to ensure that the Maoist insurgency is resolved peacefully. The Government also realizes that it is the Government who is responsible for the uprising, and the Naxals are not the usual run of the mill terrorists. They are Indians who have been denied existence by the government and were better off during the British Raj. Hence, it is logical for the government elected by the world's largest democracy to try to solve the mess instead of making it worse.

If this does not work out, then the naxals will be eliminated using force.

Ok. So they are nice and polite insurgents I suppose... then why even position 100,000 troops against them.

For folks that "do not harm", their stated aim of violently overthrowing the Indian Government doesn't seem to quite fit your novel caricature.

If you want this sentence to hold any weight, then kindly elaborate
1) Where are these 100,000 troops positioned ?
2) How many of these have entered combat ?

Last I knew, only a fraction had entered combat along with a few IAF choppers who were instructed NOT to fire at any naxals.
 
.
What kind of estimate do you think the Home Sec would give? A highly inflated estimate reflecting badly on him and his dept. or an optimistic one? I think the latter. Therefore, I was being generous in accepting the upper end of the Home Sec's own estimate. In reality, it may take longer.

True, it might take a while to wipe out the maoists. The government has been all but absent in these remote parts of the country but from what I understand they are trying to tackle the maoists at all levels, i.e economically, militarily and diplomatically.

Also remember that their (maoists) influence is limited to jungles and swamps, they don't really have the ability to seriously disrupt the state and as such their main focus is to hold what lands they already control, the maoists are already under tremendous pressure, they've called for talks at least 3 times now. Attacking cities or anything along those lines would invite swift retaliation by the government and leave them little room to maneuver. The government as of now is still open to talks and the maoists don't want to change that.

As for the Indian Army's statement, what they mean by "if necessary". Is it currently not necessary to eliminate an insurgency that has spread across a significant percentage of Indian territory?

Coulda, shoulda, woulda... DIDN'T.

The IA isn't even in the picture here, genius. So far the govt. has only deployed policemen from the CRPF and various paramilitary units. The IA will jump in only if the situation spirals out of control.

The government isn't trying to go in guns blazing, these are our people, they feel alienated/exploited, the idea is to contain the violence and bring about social and economic development, not carpet bomb them.

Ok. So they are nice and polite insurgents I suppose... then why even position 100,000 troops against them.

We aren't talking about the TTP here, we're talking about angry villagers. Once again, the IA hasn't been deployed against the maoists, there are no 'troops'.

Furthermore, these guys can't harm the economy, our economic centers are thousands of kilometers away, do you realize that the Maoists have been around for decades? We're still growing aren't we? The maoists are becoming a problem, but the state has already taken action against them and they are more or less contained. India's size has its advantages, a little instability here or there usually isn't enough to derail the economy as is the case with Pakistan.
 
.
Also remember that their (maoists) influence is limited to jungles and swamps, they don't really have the ability to seriously disrupt the state and as such their main focus is to hold what lands they already control, the maoists are already under tremendous pressure, they've

Hmm. That doesn's seem to jive with the following:

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/01/world/asia/01maoist.html
BBC NEWS | South Asia | India is 'losing Maoist battle'
India warns of growing Maoist control | openDemocracy
Growing Maoist strength in Orissa Indian Vanguard
Growing Indian Maoist Menace, Train Hostage Drama: Who is Responsible? | Trends Updates

If the area shown by the following map is all "swamps" then I must say India has a LOT of swamps...

7791e6c767c244b4e582cf0008cfa197.jpg


called for talks at least 3 times now. Attacking cities or anything along those lines would invite swift retaliation by the government and leave them little room to maneuver. The government as of now is still open to talks and the maoists don't want to change that.

Trains held hostage... Banks shut down due to Maoist threats... The map above shows their area of influence bordering Hyderabad and Bangalore... I don't know how you conclude the above.

The IA isn't even in the picture here, genius. So far the govt. has only

Thank you for the honorific title and respect.

deployed policemen from the CRPF and various paramilitary units. The IA will jump in only if the situation spirals out of control.

The government isn't trying to go in guns blazing, these are our people, they feel alienated/exploited, the idea is to contain the violence and bring about social and economic development, not carpet bomb them.

Ok. Then why is the movement growing?

Maoists growing stronger, waging war of the mind: CRPF chief (Interview)


We aren't talking about the TTP here, we're talking about angry villagers. Once again, the IA hasn't been deployed against the maoists, there are no 'troops'.

The TTP has been dismantled by Pakistan Army action over just a few months. In contrast, the Maoist threat and area of influence continues to grow... but yes, I agree that the Maoists are not receiving sophisticated weapons and foreign financial assistance like the TTP is/was.

However, here is what your Home Sec. says:

He called the rebels "highly motivated" and said they "operate like a well-trained army."

AFP: Maoists aim to topple India by 2050: minister


Furthermore, these guys can't harm the economy, our economic centers are thousands of kilometers away, do you realize that the Maoists have been around for decades? We're still growing aren't we? The maoists are becoming a problem, but the state has already taken action against them and they are more or less contained. India's size has its advantages, a little instability here or there usually isn't enough to derail the economy as is the case with Pakistan.

Really? These are your Home Sec's views:

"We have a long, bloody war ahead,"

"It's quite likely violence will go up in 2010 or 2011,"

Security operations "have not hit even five percent of their hardcore militants,"

“They (Maoists) are working under a plan. They have capacity to bring many sections of the Indian economy to its knees."
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom