"Made in China" vs "Make in India": a Glimpse from Their Auto Industries

[Beast]

Shame on BYD.
BYD is copying this beautiful make-in-india electric bus (see those heavenly indian decoration, which makes that bus make-in-india)
View attachment 435056

shame on USA!
They should stop buying BYD, instead, importing make-in-india bus with those shining indian decoration
View attachment 435057

Indian will come out self comforting explanations that rebuke you

 

[ito]

Manhindra jeep. look into mirror before talk about others.

Mahindra Jeep is 100 times better than any Chinese car. Mahindra products are rugged, and will give no problem even in the remotest of areas. China cars will fell apart in such conditions.

 

[Beast]

Mahindra Jeep is 100 times better than any Chinese car. Mahindra products are rugged, and will give no problem even in the remotest of areas. China cars will fell apart in such conditions.

Manhindra jeep is copy of USA jeep. So now you have no issue over copy? As for quality , your self bragging post can't prove anything.

I trust a China product over an India one. Even India import made in China BYD buses.
Action speaks louder than words.

 

[AndrewJin]

Haha, but they have one more deadly weapon: Wiki editing! look at this list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_vehicles_per_capita
India has more vehicles per capita than China... of course everyone knows, although this list exclude 2 wheelers, but india will always be an exception...
They did it again

indian car market is the biggest in the universe...
You have to consider the PPP factor....
A car is not a car....
A tuktuk is 3 cars because it has three wheels....

Time to edit this quarterly sales rank.....
So fake! No consideration of PPP-number.

 

[ito]

Shame on BYD.
BYD is copying this beautiful make-in-india electric bus (see those heavenly indian decoration, which makes that bus make-in-india)
View attachment 435056

shame on USA!
They should stop buying BYD, instead, importing make-in-india bus with those shining indian decoration
View attachment 435057

Nobody brought them, they were offered by BYD to run trials. India is planing to replacing huge number of their government diesel vehicles to electric ones.

 

[Beast]

indian car market is the biggest in the universe...
You have to consider the PPP factor....
A car is not a car....
A tuktuk is 3 cars because it has three wheels....

Time to edit this quarterly sales rank.....
So fake! No consideration of PPP-number.

View attachment 435063 View attachment 435064 View attachment 435062

They even need to import China 3 wheelers

 

[Kai Liu]

Made in China products are butt of jokes for Indian masses. By the way India is the third largest Auto market in the world and growing faster than Chinese markets.

And no Chinese cannot afford Audis, your GDP per capita less than most African countries. What you ca afford is Chinese products.

Indian mouth...Lol
536,289 Audis, 326,690 Benzs, and 310,000 BMWs sold in Chinese market. So this list are fake?? Poor indian loser..
http://carsalesbase.com/china-car-sales-analysis-2016/

 

[ito]

Manhindra jeep is copy of USA jeep. So now you have no issue over copy? As for quality , your self bragging post can't prove anything.

I trust a China product over an India one. Even India import made in China BYD buses.
Action speaks louder than words.

No it is not a copy.

I don't trust any Chinese products. And no India didn't import any China BYD buses. BYD offered them for trials. Mahindra, TATA, and western companies too is in contest to replace diesel government vehicles.

 

[AndrewJin]

Manhindra jeep is copy of USA jeep. So now you have no issue over copy? As for quality , your self bragging post can't prove anything.

I trust a China product over an India one. Even India import made in China BYD buses.
Action speaks louder than words.

You r wrong.
A BYD bus with indian decoration automatically becomes MAKE IN INDIA!

I hope indian members could edit these fake ranks....
The sales number of cars should consider the all vehicles including walking people.....

 

[Kyle Sun]

Speaking about the industry capability, all I want to say is India has less than 10 in the list of top 500 while China more than 100.

Or you can try another way, just type "made in" in goolge.

 

[AndrewJin]

Indian mouth...Lol
536,289 Audis, 326,690 Benzs, and 310,000 BMWs sold in Chinese market. So this list are fake?? Poor indian loser..
http://carsalesbase.com/china-car-sales-analysis-2016/

Those cars are worst than indian tuktuk.
@Götterdämmerung will agree.

 

[Beast]

No it is not a copy.

I don't trust any Chinese products. And no India didn't import any China BYD buses. BYD offered them for trials. Mahindra, TATA, and western companies too is in contest to replace diesel government vehicles.

Self comforting post. It is a copy. Anybody can see from those photo. Your double standard can work in India but out of it, you are nothing.

 

[GuardianRED]

Manhindra jeep is copy of USA jeep. So now you have no issue over copy? As for quality , your self bragging post can't prove anything.

I trust a China product over an India one. Even India import made in China BYD buses.
Action speaks louder than words.

Consistent in talking BS !! ....

If you bothered to check that Mahindra are licensed to build the variant of the willies jeep for the military and civilian market and only upgrade and continue to build the latest in house their own variant till today!

If it was a copy why has GM sue Mahindra? We know that they tried the same in your courts and lost because of your BS Law!!

 

[Cybernetics]

I think this back and forth between Chinese and Indians started only a few years ago when some Chinese who visited India started to look at their news, comments and social media. They were shocked by some Indian's arrogant views of themselves and of China, so they shared that finding with other Chinese via social media. This is surprising to Chinese as from their perspective, India is far behind in terms of industry, infrastructure, organization and STEM education. This is not coming from Chinese who haven't visited India but the ones who went there and saw for themselves. As a reaction you will see many Chinese in recent years making fun of India, its just a reaction to their perceived arrogance from Indian media/politicians, now it snowballed. Its a very recent phenomenon, if you look at older comments you will see quite positive comments of Indian progress by Chinese as words of encouragement.

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/in-5-years-people-forget-about-shanghai-and-talk-mumbai.26534/
"India 2030" video (honestly its degrading and cringe worthy, shouldn't be posted)

I understand where some Indians are coming from with them thinking India is better or should be better than China. I have talked to many older educated Indians in the west. Other than the usual talking points, they don't understand or haven't come to terms with why China should be ahead of India since India was left with better infrastructure and a British educated elite post independence. Don't want to explain the reasons for China's rise here but I understand its hard to swallow pride when a country that was poorer, worse infrastructure, perceived as inferior by the Indian elite is doing better technologically, industrially, and economically for a prolonged period. Most Indians in the west are fine people including educated ones coming from India that I've met.

IMO is not so much that India is doing bad because its actually above average in terms of growth and trying to engage in large scientific projects, its just the sad reality that its competitor/rival is China who is much better at organisation, technology, and industrialisation than any other developing nation. Both nations rising at approximately the same time with similar global ambitions thus dictating competition. Individuals can get along but nations are interest groups beyond the individual.

Regarding industrial copying, the people who are in charge of industry are engineers and physicists who think in the framework of physics, which means they emphasise having the knowledge and having the industrial base, all others considerations like design and marketing are secondary and afterthoughts. Unless China is going to relive 300 years of British industrialisation it better skip steps much like the Germans, Americans, and Japanese who were all known for copying in order to catch up to the industrialised world. Most countries can't even learn and replicate what is freely available on the markets. In recent years there are many innovative and internationally successful products from China, it would be ignorant to say otherwise but Chinese just have high standards for themselves. Chinese understands problems within China and wants to improve upon the economy of China but they feel funny when some Indians say they are better than China or make fun of China.

Needlessly bashing anther country is counter productive, its better to celebrate successes of science and technology for mankind. Maybe its my personal value but I think anybody/organisation contributing to furthering mankind is a positive force and anybody/organisation taking progress away should learn from the positive force or not be given fuel or should be eliminated from civilisation. Those in the middle should be happy there are people hard at work making your lives better.

TLDR; Chinese tend to make fun of people they perceive as arrogant and look up to hardworking countries/individuals they can learn from.

 

[AndrewJin]

They even need to import China 3 wheelers

India imports everything, but no worries, they are make-in-india from China.
For example, this DJI used by indian military to spy Pakistan....
They are make-in-india drones from Shenzhen....