Most of the muslims believe in Divine Command theory, which holds the view that, all of ethics can be reduced to God's commandments. That is to say, if God wills it, it is good, and if he commands against it, it is bad. Man's moral intuitions and reason have been thrown out the window. God would surely want us to avenge those who hurt our prophet, right? Therefore not only is it virtuous but also a moral obligation to do it. There is no space for reason here.
God created Man. He is the sole source for all Command. And your sentiments above show that you are speaking of a Single Divine Being. You are speaking of One God. And that is what Islam teaches. There is only One God.
When someone believes in God, by default, it is one of the attributes of being God that He possess the power of Will. The concept of God without Will as an attribute makes no sense.
God, by default, is attributed with Justice. Injustice is not an attribute of God. And under human moral standards, isn't justice good? Don't you think justice is good?
Man's reasoning capability is a creation of God.
You have misunderstood Islam. Every man/woman, Muslim or non-Muslim, has the right to protect himself/herself. And every man or woman must stand for justice, NOT injustice.
God does not want anything. He does not need anything. Because He is God. He created everything. Islam does not teach revenge. Islam teaches forgiveness, and moving on.
God would surely want us to avenge those who hurt our prophet, right?
Wrong. God is not limited or attributed with doubt. God is attributed with Certainty, Truth. He knows all the past, and all the future, and every hidden thing. As He is the creator of everything. He is attributed with vengeance against evil.
He has commanded Muslims to protect themselves, but NOT to do injustice to anyone, Muslim or non-Muslim.
Islamic is a very academic faith, with millions of works on literature spanning libraries going back 1400 years across 80 countries. One of the sciences in Islam is "Mantiq", which is Arabic for logic. Other two sciences in Islam are "Falsafa", which is Arabic for Philosophy, and "Hikma", which is Arabic for wisdom.
Muslim Sufis have written hundreds of thousands of works on reasoning and its connection to spirituality, which is known in Arabic as "Tasawwuf".
LARKANA: Rangers and Police fired warning shots and resorted to tear gas as a frenzied mob set a Hindu Dharamshala on fire over alleged desecration of holy pages.
Furious protesters attacked a Mandir and set the Dharmashala on fire while few of them surrounded the house of the Hindu man who was accused of burning the pages.
Police and Rangers reached on the spot to protect the Mandir and imposed a curfew in different areas to bring the situation under control.
Larkana: Hindu worship place set ablaze over ‘burning of holy pages’ | PAKISTAN - geo.tv
Prophet Muhammad salallaho alaihi wa alihi wa sallam told Muslims not to attack the churches, synagogues, temples, or any religious site of the non-believers (non-Muslims). This is one of the best well known facts in our Gospels (Hadith).
Do not insult the religion of a non-Muslim, because he/she will then insult Islam and God.
The burning of this temple is injustice and a sin in Islam. What does the temple of the whole community have to do with the act of a single non-Muslim man? What did his house have to do with his act? What did his family living in the house have to do with his act? Isn't all of this great injustice?
What proof does the frenzied mob have that the hindu man is guilty of the act?
This frenzied mob are not fighting for religion. They are probably fighting for taking over property, or for political or other worldy reasons. Their acts, as this news story depicts, is not how Islam has asked Muslims to behave.
