Khalistan?

[kakashi]

I'm all for supporting them if they want an independent Punjab that succeeds from India and they can call it Khalistan. I'd even be completely open to letting them use our roads and ports for trade if India tries to be a bitch about it.

However, I wouldn't give a non-Muslim even a pebble of Muslim soil which belongs to the Pakistani civilization.

Muslims threw out Ranjit Singh from Pakistan and his invaders after their invasion of our ancestral land why would we ever give them our territory or allow them to rule any inch of it?

Pakistan is my ancestral land it's not theirs.

It belongs to me and my people not them.

Anyone can come at us and we'll defend our territory.

lol kiddo....you threw our ranjit singh ? If it wasn't for anglo-sikh war you would still be under sikh empire..

 

[East or West India Best]

I know it's kinda random but what do you feel about air India bombing as a sikh? any guilt in sikh community abroad or back home?

Air India bombing alienated the whole Sikh community from the Khalistan idea. That one event basically killed the concept of getting our homeland. We as a community live with that shame, it hangs over us all the time and we constantly have to apologize for it.

 

[Goenitz]

First things first, stop defining India by taking a country or eu as a referrence.. we are special in our own way.. A nation's definition is not limited to jst common language, history, descent and culture are among other things. The constitution of India follows a bilingual approach were both hindi and english are given official status. there are more than 30 languages in India spoken by more than a million people and more than 130 languages spoken by more than 10,000 people, adding to this countless dialects for each of these specific languages.

Man admit it India is a regionality (if thats a word)... the tthings u described as nation, every region of india has their own, histroy, food, language and even own religious prefernece... like bengalis, i think worship more some godess whereas hanuman is more highlighted in UP and Mahrashtra... anyway its religion which is common between north and south...

 

[illusion8]

some migrated bcz of TTP... anyway Muslims also suffered in the hands of those vicious hounds..howverm number remained near one thousand... not much

Refugees have been moving many decades before TTP came into existence. Your minority population has dwindled down to bare minimum - basically the one's who do not have the resources to flee.


And No...it's not 1000, it's more than 200,000 registered refugees awaiting Indian citizenship.

19000 of them have been given long term visas, 4300 of them have received Indian citizenship last year alone.


This thread and the op is a fine example of pakistani mentality, - cut the nose to smite the face. There is an ulterior motive to foment terrorism and to again use its people as terrorists in the neighborhood...and not out of any concern for the minority.

 

[Goenitz]

Refugees have been moving many decades before TTP came into existence.

And No...it's not 1000, it's more than 200,000 registered refugees awaiting Indian citizenship.

some might be seeking... like of US and canada.. so some religiously motivated **** hindus tried to live in india...
I meant refugee from pakistan... no way Pak had allowed 200,000 crossings. the few slippages occurred as they were on tour of india as per visting holy places...

 

[nForce]

I know stakes are very high...

Stakes very high ? What is it for ? Absolutely no return on investment ! This is not one of those high risk - high value cases where you get to say the stakes are high

 

[Goenitz]

ok... my thread was moved...
i thought its more of foreign and strategic issue rather than political point scoring issue....anyway admin knows better...

 

[illusion8]

some might be seeking... like of US and canada.. so some religiously motivated **** hindus tried to live in india...
I meant refugee from pakistan... no way Pak had allowed 200,000 crossings. the few slippages occurred as they were on tour of india as per visting holy places...

Wake up and smell the coffee - thousands flee pakistan in rickety boats to get away from the killings...thousands of pak ahmedis are stranded in sri lanka, 15000 pak christians are living a hellish life in refugee camps in thailand...yeah...

do they desire a better life or they desire to be alive?

This might and would are useless words.. read the pakistani links I posted first...4,300 Hindus, Sikhs from Pakistan, Afghanistan get Indian citizenship - Pakistan - DAWN.COM

Whenever India reforms its citizenship laws - will be the day when tens of thousands of pakistani hindus and sikhs will make their way to India.

 

[Goenitz]

you are deviating from topic now and doing blame games

This thread and the op is a fine example of pakistani mentality, - cut the nose to smite the face. There is an ulterior motive to foment terrorism and to again use its people as terrorists in the neighborhood...and not out of any concern for the minority.

1. your minisers said, Kanty sa Knata nikalain ga.
2. Modi said, we spilled blood along with Muktis in 71
3. General, VK sing said same in his book "chanting jai bangla" in Muktis training facility
4. Dovel said many things.....

 

[Shan-e-ibrahim]

useless

 

[East or West India Best]

Man admit it India is a regionality (if thats a word)... the tthings u described as nation, every region of india has their own, histroy, food, language and even own religious prefernece... like bengalis, i think worship more some godess whereas hanuman is more highlighted in UP and Mahrashtra... anyway its religion which is common between north and south...

That's true but now India has been forged as a country and an idea. You notice how rabbit ultranationalist these Indians are on here? While that is a sentiment reflected by nearly all Indians (including my parents) so the the idea that India going to disintegrate is not seeing the bigger picture.

 

[illusion8]

you are deviating from topic now and doing blame games

1. your minisers said, Kanty sa Knata nikalain ga.
2. Modi said, we spilled blood along with Muktis in 71
3. General, VK sing said same in his book "chanting jai bangla" in Muktis training facility
4. Dovel said many things.....

pakistan used mujjis in 48 against india after that punjabi terrorist groups against india, it used mujjis from 80's onwards till date in afghanistan..look where that has landed you.

as hillary said rearing snakes in your backyard.

 

[Goenitz]

Wake up and smell the coffee - thousands flee pakistan in rickety boats to get away from the killings...thousands of pak ahmedis are stranded in sri lanka, 15000 pak christians are living a hellish life in refugee camps in thailand...yeah...

do they desire a better life or they desire to be alive?

This might and would are useless words.. read the pakistani links I posted first...4,300 Hindus, Sikhs from Pakistan, Afghanistan get Indian citizenship - Pakistan - DAWN.COM

Whenever India reforms its citizenship laws - will be the day when tens of thousands of pakistani hindus and sikhs will make their way to India.

thats the topic of some other day.... u shd consider why refugees move...we have millions of Afghans too...

 

[illusion8]

thats the topic of some other day.... u shd consider why refugees move...we have millions of Afghans too...

i very well consider and know why pakistani minorities flee.

 

[Goenitz]

pakistan used mujjis in 48 against india after that punjabi terrorist groups against india, it used mujjis from 80's onwards till date in afghanistan..look where that has landed you.

as hillary said rearing snakes in your backyard.

the first one was war not insurgency but battle..every pakistani tried to play role in that.
2nd one was a rebel group which mught have been supported by paskitan after their stand.. we didn't create them to revolt...it was self rising movment.. S.Swami still support that person...

FYI, indian started proxies fromm 55 nwards for independent balchistan and pakhtunstan .. then in in svoiet era they firs time made BLA... then again under US umbrella... india supported Muktis, They supported Tamil tigers...
BTW Haliry also admitted creating Taliban and AL qaeda....

useless

realising now....