Kerala School Drops Vande Mataram from I-Day Programme as Radical Group Objects

[nair]

were you tying to say ISIS or ISS is some nasty commie/Islamist org in Kerala

NO I meant "ISS", they were the other side of the coin of RSS.....

@Spring Onion @seiko I think we 3 are running in circle for a long time.... I am tired.... and retiring

 

[ranjeet]

Down with the Hindu Extremists ..How dare they force Habibi minority community to sing the National Song.
Al Brotest !!!

 

[Iggy]

It is core ego problem for radical hindus nothing to do with freedom struggle angel .
When you have national anthem why impose this hindu religious song in schools?

You are making it again a religious song.. It has nothing to do with any religion.. This song was sung by many freedom fighters irrespective of the religion.. Many had died chanting Vande Matharam.. You are hell bent on making this song as Hindu outfits song which is not.. This is a song composed for freedom fighting and we used to sing it with out an issue..

 

[trueINDIANpatriot]

It is core ego problem for radical hindus nothing to do with freedom struggle angel .


When you have national anthem why impose this hindu religious song in schools?

Your flag has marks of a particular religion why enforcing your religious faith on the minorities (even if they are less than 1%)...Change your flag we will consider about the song..

 

[Nova2]

first of all i dint say that.

Secondly you hindus can worship anything on earth so NO chanting that cant make you non-hindu.

We Muslims dont worshiping objects.

We just bow to only ONE GOD



NO this does not make them radicals.

But u did say ,someone singing vande matram is not a muslim anymore ,which sounds very stupid.vande matram is not about bowing down to an IDOL or sort of worshiping one, it is about giving respect to your mother and mother land,and singing it doesn't makes you a non-muslim

first of all my reply was in another context to another post.

Secondly in Islam we dont bow to even our mothers

Bowing down to your mother makes you a non muslim , i love the way you twist things around

 

[Iggy]

@Spring Onion @seiko I think we 3 are running in circle for a long time.... I am tired.... and retiring

She is trying to make the issue as an Hindu Muslim issue.. So that she can blame it on radical Hindus..

Its her usual rant

 

[Echo_419]

NO I meant "ISS", they were the other side of the coin of RSS.....

@Spring Onion @seiko I think we 3 are running in circle for a long time.... I am tired.... and retiring

Suckers stole our name

 

[nair]

Suckers stole our name

That is a banned organisation and the founder and father of that organisation is in Jail in bangalore (he is under treatment and out on bail for a month)

 

[Spring Onion]

But u did say ,someone singing vande matram is not a musnolim anymore ,which sounds very stupid.vande matram is not about bowing down to an IDOL or sort of worshiping one, it is about giving respect to your mother and mother land,and singing it doesn't makes you a non-muslim

i said those who already bow to idols have NO issue with even singing it.

Bowing down to your mother makes you a non muslim , i love the way you twist things around

You hindus can bow to anything. in Islam we are not allowed to bow to any human even if its your mother simple as that.

We only bow to One GOD

Your flag has marks of a particular religion why enforcing your religious faith on the minorities (even if they are less than 1%)...Change your flag we will consider about the song..

the mark specifies one religion the white part represents non-Muslims.

BTW your comparison is lame .

We dont mince our words like you Indians do. The issue is you are majority Hindu country but for a face-palm use this "secularism" excuse due to which you are in a fix. You cant stop imposing Hindu beliefs on others and at the same time claim you are not imposing it.

NO I meant "ISS", they were the other side of the coin of RSS.....

@Spring Onion @seiko I think we 3 are running in circle for a long time.... I am tired.... and retiring

all rat (in punjabi english) you take rest am also going for a mad drive on Peshawar roads since due to PTI Azadi March our city roads are so clam and without traffic so its a golden opportunity .

will come back for debate tomorrow

 

[nair]

all rat (in punjabi english) you take rest am also going for a mad drive on Peshawar roads since due to PTI Azadi March our city roads are so clam and without traffic so its a golden opportunity .

will come back for debate tomorrow

Seat belt is your friend....... Ensure that especially when you are going for your "MAD DRIVE"

 

[doremon]

Secondly in Islam we dont bow to even our mothers

ohh thats too bad,here according to our culture we consider mothers as living gods

 

[Nova2]

the more clear answer is that there is no room for this religious song even half century ago there was non .

Muslims in India are not others. its another matter that biased Hindus still dont consider these Muslims as Indians.

These Muslims are asked to prove nationalism by bowing down to Hindu rituals

no one asks muslims in India to prove their nationality , anyone living in India is an Indian ,just cos u have read about few attacks on muslims doesnt mean everyone out here hate muslims ,hindus in pakistan are also murderd,forced conversions ,comunal voilence occur in pakistan aswell (off topic) ,doesnt mean everyone out there in pakistan wana do the same wid the hindus
Vande matram is not some hindu song,it was written in 1870's and was sung during freedom struggle by everyone ,which gives it its own importance,but it is still not mandatory to be sung by everyone in schools ,it's optional

i said those who already bow to idols have NO issue with even singing it.

I will say it again you dont bow down to an idol if you are singing vande matram, hence they are all still muslims, weather you like it or not

You hindus can bow to anything. in Islam we are not allowed to bow to any human even if its your mother simple as that.
We only bow to One GOD

okay if that is how it is in Islam, than i would respect it and move on

all rat

for once i thought you were calling him a rat

 

[Spring Onion]

Seat belt is your friend....... Ensure that especially when you are going for your "MAD DRIVE"

Its just a second day am driving. Thanks for reminding i forgot seat belt altogether.

no one asks muslims in India to prove their nationality , anyone living in India is an Indian ,just cos u have read about few attacks on muslims doesnt mean everyone out here hate muslims ,hindus in pakistan are also murderd,forced conversions ,comunal voilence occur in pakistan aswell (off topic) ,doesnt mean everyone out there in pakistan wana do the same wid the hindus
Vande matram is not some hindu song,it was written in 1870's and was sung during freedom struggle by everyone ,which gives it its own importance,but it is still not mandatory to be sung by everyone in schools ,it's optional

am in hurry will reply you in details.

and i know when it was written who wrote it how biased and radical is his Anand math novel

 

[SQ8]

Was it meant towards the posters, or towards the subject?

The subject. It seems kerala is having in infestation of extremism in its muslim population.

 

[nair]

The subject. It seems kerala is having in infestation of extremism in its muslim population.

Yes there is infestation.....But there are several muslims who are moderate and not share the views of these morons.... Agencies are able to keep a tab on their local activities, but there is another issue, of Middle east.... Lot of support (financial) come from Middle east and the money is received thru hawala channels...... Lot of them work in middle east...