Thank you for trying to score a propaganda point yourself for your team. The topic is about Jinnah and his grandson, and from there by natural consequence, his daughter.
It is indeed sad that the first rejection of the Two-Nation Theory came from the great man's own child.
They say blood is thicker than water ..... well in this case Indian water proved that it was thicker than blood ..... Indian blood no more, but Pakistani blood.
Nusli is proud of his grandfather ..... thats blood talking. But Nusli is still a proud Indian and will remain so regardless of if Pakistan makes him an offer of honorary citizenship ...... thats Indian water.
And for all the pakistanis here claiming they dont really care for Jinna's chachas or bhatijas, well I'm sorry but as a nation you do have a hangup and it must still rankle deep inside somewhere.
Remember the Lahore cricket match and your leader literally sweeping the floor before your Quaid's daughter and grandson?
Cheers, Doc
How does Dina staying in India reject the two nation theory?
You mean to imply that Dina's falling out with her father was over the two nation theory and not her marriage against her father's wishes?
The decisions of a people and its leader cannot be weighed against one individual and proven wrong...millions of people passionately wanted more autonomy based on their needs and that is what created Pakistan.
History is full of great men whose children towed a different line altogether so even if Dina says that she does not believe in two nation theory...does not change anything for us.
Still i have not heard her saying anything against Pakistan, last time she visited, these were her comments
"This has been very sad and wonderful for me. May his dream for Pakistan come true."
Jinnah did not initially work for a separate homeland however the feeling that Muslims deserve a more secure political future was always on his mind and the eventual falling out with Congress whereby he was shunned by its leadership despite building bridges between the two parties was actually something which turned the tide. The creation of Pakistan was an evolution of a political thought and the final outcome was not decided till certain events took place.
Indian water is thicker than blood?
That is sheer arrogance my friend to try to twist and steer a family feud in such a direction and cite it is an attestation of India's greatness...
How could Dina go to Pakistan when she had a falling out with her Father who disowned her and all this happened prior to Partition?
Still even if they did not have a falling out, she would have stayed with her husband as a wife wherever they would have stayed and not just India, so it is a really pointless argument that is portrayed as Indian water thicker than blood.
Nusli is proud of his grandfather on what account?
In his personal life he never met his grandfather and his mother was disowned by his grandfather so it cannot be based on the wonderful relationship he enjoyed with his grandfather surely?
The basis is the great man's bearing as a leader of millions and the qualities he possessed and that is the same reason we are proud of Quaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah
Who said we do not care for Jinnah's relatives?
It is just that to us Jinnah is the central figure and towers above the rest and so if any of his relative does not agree with his life's work (which btw i do not think is the case) and criticizes him; does not matter to us at all...
Our leader sweeping the floor before Jinnah's daughter???
You my friend need to stop making such uncalled for and crude remarks...
Being hospitable is certainly not sweeping the floor...with this kind of attitude we shall always have horns locked and despite being a proud Pakistani, i do wish for an era of peace and stability in the region.
You would really do well to remember that all your countrymen got a very good treatment in Lahore and most came back to India with very good memories. All in all the spirit of peace was instilled in the masses and for that i really appreciate Pakistani Leadership!
If such positive moves and efforts are taken like sweeping the floor then i guess it is true that our peaceful co existence is just a dream.
Stop portraying Pakistan as a mistake and accept Jinnah as a great leader and only then you guys can move forward without regret, otherwise how can you have peace with us?